Lulla ParivarLULLA FAMILY, HomeHindi
  1. Home
  2. Library
  3. The Mahabharata
← Collection

The MahabharataUdyoga Parva

Chapter 18 of 41

Mahabharata · Chapter 18 · Part 4 of 7 · Dhritarashtra’s night and Vidura’s counsel

Dhritarashtra’s night and Vidura’s counsel

Selected retellingAbout 64 minutes14 leaves

Dhritarashtra cannot sleep: Vidura describes wisdom and folly

After Sanjaya left, Dhritarashtra said to the attendant in waiting, “I want to see Vidura. Bring him here without delay.” The messenger carried the king’s wish to Vidura, his brother, who came to the palace and asked to have his arrival announced. The attendant went in: Vidura was here at the king’s command and wished to pay his respects at his feet. What should he be told to do? “Let Vidura enter,” Dhritarashtra said. “I am never unwilling or unprepared to see Vidura.” The attendant went back with the invitation to the inner apartments. Vidura entered the chamber, where the king sat absorbed in thought, and stood before him with joined hands. “I am Vidura, come at your command. If there is anything to be done, I am here. Command me.” “Sanjaya has come back,” the king said. “He went away after rebuking me. Tomorrow, in the midst of the court, he will deliver Yudhishthira’s message, and all day I have not been able to learn what that message is. So my body is burning, and the burning has taken my sleep. You know both righteousness and advantage, Vidura. Tell me what would help a man who is sleepless and burning. Ever since Sanjaya returned from the Pandavas my heart has known no peace. Anxiety over what he may say has thrown all my senses into disorder.”

“Sleep deserts a thief,” Vidura said, “and a man eaten by lust. It deserts a man who has lost all his wealth, a man whose efforts have failed, and a weak man attacked by the strong. I hope none of these grave misfortunes has come upon you. I hope you do not grieve, coveting the wealth of others.” “I want to hear words from you that will do me good and carry the highest morality,” Dhritarashtra said. “In this line of royal sages you alone are revered by the wise.” “Yudhishthira is graced with every virtue,” Vidura answered. “He is worthy to be sovereign of the three worlds, and he should have been kept at your side. You sent him into exile. Your own qualities are the reverse of his. Virtuous as you are, and versed in duty, your blindness gives you no right to a share of the kingdom. Through his harmlessness and kindness, his righteousness, his love of truth and his energy, and because he remembers the reverence due to you, Yudhishthira bears innumerable wrongs with patience. You have handed the management of the empire to Duryodhana, to Shakuni the son of Subala, to Karna and Duhshasana. How can you hope for prosperity?”

Vidura described the person he considered wise. Self-knowledge, effort, patience, and steadiness in righteousness kept such a person aligned with life’s higher purposes. Wisdom showed in praiseworthy actions, rejection of blameworthy conduct, faith, and reverence. Anger, delight, pride, false modesty, bewilderment, and vanity failed to draw that person away from the proper goal. Intended actions and deliberations remained concealed from enemies. The work became known after its completion. Cold, heat, fear, attachment, prosperity, and adversity could not obstruct it. Judgment remained free from desire and followed righteousness and practical advantage, choosing purposes beneficial in this life and the next. Wise people made every effort their strength allowed, acted to the full extent of their ability, and dismissed nothing as too insignificant for attention. Vidura identified a leading sign of understanding: the ability to grasp something quickly while listening patiently and to pursue a purpose through considered judgment. It was also the ability to refrain from speaking about other people’s business without being asked. The wise avoided chasing the unattainable, grieving over what was already lost, and allowing calamity to cloud their minds. Once they began a task, they worked until it was finished. They used their time carefully and kept themselves under control. Honest conduct gave them pleasure. They undertook work conducive to happiness and prosperity and treated good things with respect.

Honors did not make such a person exult, and slights did not bring grief. Vidura compared that steadiness to the untroubled water of a lake along the Ganga. A wise person understood the mortal nature of living creatures, the connections among actions, and the means available for accomplishing human purposes. Bold speech, the ability to converse across different subjects, knowledge of argument, insight, and the capacity to interpret books also belonged to wisdom. Study followed reason, reason remained informed by scripture, and good people always received their due respect. Vidura then described folly. Someone could be ignorant of scripture and still vain, poor and still proud, intent on a goal and willing to use dishonest means to reach it. Abandoning one’s own responsibilities to pursue another person’s business, and practicing deception to help a friend, were further signs. Foolish people desired what they should leave alone, abandoned legitimate desires, and bore malice toward the powerful. They treated enemies as friends, hated and injured their friends, and undertook wicked actions. They disclosed their plans, doubted everything, and spent a long time on work that should have required little.

Vidura included religious and social obligations in the account. A fool neglected shraddha, the offerings made for departed ancestors, failed to worship the deities, and formed no friendships with noble-minded people. Entering uninvited, talking at length without a request, and trusting the untrustworthy marked a particularly poor character. A person guilty of wrongdoing who shifted blame onto others, or a powerless person who gave vent to anger, displayed extreme folly. So did someone who failed to assess his own strength, ignored righteousness and practical benefit, and wanted a difficult prize without adopting adequate means. Vidura condemned punishing the undeserving, paying homage to people without their knowledge, and waiting upon misers. He returned to a mark of wisdom that could survive success: a person might gain immense wealth and prosperity, or extensive learning, and still behave without arrogance.

Vidura’s numbered counsel: forgiveness, protection, and care

Vidura asked who could be more heartless than a wealthy man who ate well and dressed finely while withholding a share of his wealth from his dependents. One person might commit a wrong from which many people benefited. In the end, guilt attached to the person who acted, while those enjoying the proceeds escaped. An archer’s arrow might fail to kill even one person. Intelligence directed toward evil could destroy an entire kingdom together with its king. Then came a compact sequence of numbers: distinguish the two through the one, and bring the three under control through the four. Conquer the five, understand the six, abandon the seven, and be happy. Poison killed one person, and a weapon one person. Wicked advice could destroy the king, his people, and the whole realm. A person should avoid enjoying delicious food alone, deliberating alone over material interests, traveling alone, or remaining awake alone among sleeping companions. Vidura spoke of the Being who was one, without a second, whom Dhritarashtra had failed to understand. That Being was the very essence of Truth, a way to heaven, like a boat across the sea.

People found a single fault in someone who forgave: they mistook that person for weak. Vidura dismissed the objection because forgiveness possessed great power. It was a virtue of the weak and an adornment of the strong. It could subdue everything. What lay beyond its reach? What could a wicked person do to someone carrying the sword of forgiveness? Fire falling on ground without grass died away by itself. A person who refused to forgive became stained by many wrongs. Righteousness was the highest good, forgiveness the supreme peace, knowledge the greatest contentment, and benevolence the sole happiness. The earth swallowed a king incapable of fighting and a Brahmin who never journeyed to sacred places, just as a snake swallowed creatures living in holes. Two actions earned renown: avoiding harsh speech and disregarding the wicked. Two kinds of people surrendered their own judgment: women who desired a man solely because other women desired him, and someone who worshiped another solely because other people did so. The desires of the poor and the anger of the powerless were like sharp thorns piercing the body. An inactive householder and a beggar absorbed in schemes failed to shine because their conduct conflicted with the lives they professed. A powerful person who forgave and a poor person who gave generously lived above heaven itself.

Wealth acquired honestly could be misused in two ways: by giving to the undeserving and withholding from the deserving. A rich man who gave nothing and a poor man who was proud should have weights tied tightly around their necks and be thrown into water. A mendicant accomplished in yoga and a warrior killed in open battle could pierce the sphere of the sun. People versed in the Vedas recognized means that were good, middling, or bad. People too fell into those three classes and should be assigned work suited to their capacities. Three could hold no wealth of their own, a wife, a slave, and a son. Whatever they earned belonged to the person to whom they belonged. Three acts created great fear: stealing another person’s property, violating another person’s wife, and breaking with a friend. Desire, anger, and greed were three gates to hell that destroyed the self and should be abandoned. Three people should be protected even when danger was imminent: a follower, someone who sought refuge by declaring allegiance, and someone who had come into one’s home. Rescuing an enemy from distress carried the combined merit of three attainments: granting a boon, acquiring a kingdom, and obtaining a son.

However powerful a king might be, learned people advised him to avoid deliberating with the unintelligent, procrastinators, the lazy, and flatterers. Four kinds of people should find a place in the home of a prosperous householder: elderly blood relatives and people of distinguished birth who had fallen into adversity. Poor friends and sisters without children should find a place there too. Indra, the chief of the gods, had asked Brihaspati, the divine counselor, about things that could come to fruition within a single day. Then Brihaspati had named four: the resolve of the gods, the understanding of intelligent people, the humility of the learned, and the destruction of the sinful. Four practices intended to remove fear could produce it when performed improperly: the Agnihotra offering into the sacred fire, a vow of silence, study, and sacrifice more generally. Five fires were to be served with reverence: father, mother, the actual sacred fire, the self, and the teacher. Service to another five brought fame in the world: the gods, departed ancestors, human beings, mendicants, and guests. Wherever a person went, five groups followed: friends, enemies, the indifferent, dependents, and people entitled to maintenance. Of the five senses, a single one left vulnerable could drain away all understanding, as water escaped through one hole in a leather vessel.

Someone seeking prosperity should avoid six faults: sleep, drowsiness, fear, anger, laziness, and procrastination. Vidura also named six people to leave as one would leave a boat breaking apart at sea. They were a teacher unable to explain scripture, a priest without learning, and a king unable to protect. So were a wife whose words were disagreeable, a cowherd unwilling to go out to the fields, and a barber who wanted to abandon the village for the forest.

Self-control and kingship: Vidura urges the return of the rightful share

Vidura named six qualities that should always be retained: truthfulness, charity, diligence, benevolence, forgiveness, and patience. Six things quickly suffered destruction through neglect: cattle, service, agriculture, a wife, learning, and the wealth of a Shudra. He described six ways people forgot those who had helped them. Students forgot their teachers after receiving an education, and married people forgot their mothers. Men whose desires were satisfied forgot women, and people who had succeeded forgot their helpers. Travelers who had crossed a river forgot the boat, and recovered patients forgot their physicians. Six conditions promoted happiness: health, freedom from debt, life at home, companionship with good people, a secure livelihood, and freedom from fear. Six kinds of people remained miserable: the envious, the malicious, the discontented, the quick-tempered, the constantly suspicious, and those dependent on another person’s fortunes. Vidura then named six sources of happiness: wealth, continuous health, a wife’s affection, her sweetness of speech, an obedient son, and learning that provided an income. Someone who mastered the six that dwell always in the heart gained command of the senses, avoided sin, and remained free of its resulting calamities. He described six groups that lived through the circumstances of six others: thieves through the carelessness of their victims, physicians through illness, and women through men’s desire. Priests lived through people who offered sacrifices, kings through people’s disputes, and the learned through the needs of the unlearned.

A king should abandon seven faults that could ruin even firmly established monarchs: indulgence in women, dice, hunting, drinking, harsh speech, excessive severity in punishment, and misuse of wealth. Eight immediate signs of approaching destruction concerned a person’s treatment of Brahmins: hatred of them, disputes with them, seizure of their possessions, and killing them. Pleasure in insulting them, distress at hearing them praised, forgetting them on ceremonial occasions, and spite when they asked for something were signs too. A wise person recognized these transgressions and avoided them. Vidura also described eight joys available in this life: meeting friends, receiving great wealth, embracing a son, and sexual union. Conversation with friends at a fitting time, advancement of people on one’s own side, obtaining something long anticipated, and respect in society were joys too. Eight qualities brought distinction: wisdom, high birth, self-restraint, learning, courage, moderation in speech, generosity according to one’s means, and gratitude. He offered the image of a house with nine doors, three pillars, and five witnesses, presided over by the self. The learned person who understood it was truly wise. He then told Dhritarashtra of ten people unable to recognize duty in their condition: the intoxicated, the inattentive, the mentally disturbed, the exhausted, and the angry. The starving, the hasty, the greedy, the frightened, and the sexually obsessed could not recognize duty either. The wise should avoid their company.

Here Vidura cited the old story of Sudhanvan and Prahlada, king of the Asuras, over Prahlada’s son. A king who abandoned desire and anger, placed wealth in worthy hands, exercised discrimination, cultivated learning, and acted promptly became a standard others respected. Prosperity attended the ruler who inspired trust, punished people whose guilt had been established, understood the proper measure of punishment, and knew when mercy was appropriate. A prudent person took even a weak enemy seriously and dealt with an enemy intelligently while watching for an opportunity. He avoided seeking hostility with a stronger opponent, and showed courage at the right time. Someone who met calamity without being overwhelmed, gathered all his faculties for action, and bore suffering patiently became foremost among people and overcame his enemies. Happiness belonged to the person who avoided useless absence from home, friendship with wrongdoers, violation of another person’s wife, arrogance, theft, ingratitude, and drinking. Vidura praised the person who pursued the three human aims of righteousness, material prosperity, and pleasure without boastfulness. Such a person answered questions truthfully, refrained from quarrels even for friends, and kept anger in check when slighted.

Kindness to everyone, freedom from malice, restraint from starting disputes while weak, modest speech, and the willingness to let a quarrel pass earned praise everywhere. People loved someone who avoided a haughty appearance, refrained from praising himself while condemning others, and kept from speaking harshly when he lost composure. Good conduct included leaving old hostilities at rest, behaving with neither arrogance nor excessive self-abasement, and avoiding improper acts even in distress. A good-natured person did not become carried away by his own happiness, take pleasure in someone else’s misery, or regret a gift after giving it. Vidura commended the desire to learn the customs of different countries, the languages of different peoples, and the practices of different social groups. Such knowledge let a person understand distinctions of high and low and gain influence wherever he went, even among people already content. An intelligent person should relinquish pride, folly, insolence, sinful acts, and disloyalty to the king. He should also relinquish crooked conduct, hostility toward many people, and arguments with the drunk, the mentally disturbed, and the wicked. The gods themselves promoted the prosperity of someone who daily practiced self-restraint, purification, auspicious observances, worship, expiation, and the other rites recognized by the community.

Vidura also prescribed relationships according to standing: marriage with equals and never with inferiors, conversation, dealings, and friendship with equals, and precedence for people of superior qualities. A learned person who kept to these choices acted with consideration and skill. Suppose a person distributed food among dependents before eating sparingly himself, worked much and slept little, and gave even to enemies who asked. That person possessed self-command and kept calamity at a distance. Well-guarded counsel, properly carried into action, with deeds never known to others as injurious, allowed a person to secure even the smallest object. Someone committed to sparing all creatures injury, truthful, gentle, generous, and pure in mind shone among his relatives like a clear and precious gem from an excellent mine. A person who felt shame over a fault known only to himself earned great honor. With a pure heart, boundless energy, and attention gathered inward, he shone like the sun. Then Vidura turned to the king. “King Pandu, consumed by a Brahmin’s curse, had five sons born to him in the woods, each like an Indra. You raised those children, son of Ambika, and taught them everything, and they obey your commands. Give them back their just share of the kingdom. Then rejoice, and be happy with your own sons. Do that, and gods and men alike will put their trust in you.”

The chariot of the self and the arrows of speech: Vidura warns the king

“Tell me what a man should do who is sleepless and burning with anxiety,” Dhritarashtra said. “You alone among us know both righteousness and advantage. Advise me wisely, Vidura. Tell me what you judge beneficial for Yudhishthira and good for the Kurus. I fear the evils to come, and I look back only on my own guilt. I ask you with an anxious heart: tell me exactly what is in Yudhishthira’s mind.” “Even unasked,” Vidura answered, “a man should speak the truth to one whose defeat he does not wish, whether his words are welcome or hateful, pleasing or painful. So I will say what is good for the Kurus, what is beneficial and consistent with duty. Listen to me. Do not set your heart on means of success that are unjust and improper.” An intelligent person, he went on, should accept that an undertaking might fail despite fair and proper methods. Before acting, he should consider the capacity of the person doing the work, the nature of the work, and its purpose. Action depended on those conditions. Impulse alone was a poor beginning. A wise person decided to proceed or desist after examining his ability, the task itself, and the consequences of success.

A king who failed to understand the proper measure of territory, gain, loss, treasury, population, and punishment would soon lose his realm. Knowledge of those measures as set out in the treatises gave him the understanding of righteousness and advantage needed to retain it. Uncontrolled senses, directed toward their separate objects, affected the world as planets affected the stars. When the five senses mastered a person and drew him into their various pursuits, his calamities increased like the waxing moon. A ruler who tried to control his counselors before mastering himself, or conquer his enemies before controlling his counselors, eventually collapsed for lack of strength. Someone who first treated his own uncontrolled self as an enemy and subdued it could then gain mastery over counselors and opponents. Great prosperity attended command of the senses, control of the mind, the capacity to punish offenders, considered action, and patience. Vidura offered the king an image: the body was a chariot, the self within it the driver, and the senses its horses. Properly trained, those excellent horses carried a wise person pleasantly through life, allowing him to wake in peace. Unbroken horses beyond control brought an unskilled driver to destruction along the journey. The senses could carry a person into the same disaster.

Inexperience and uncontrolled desire confused good with evil and misery with happiness. Someone who abandoned righteousness and practical benefit to follow the senses soon lost prosperity, life, wealth, and wife. Ownership of riches offered no security when their owner could not govern his appetites. Vidura urged a person to know the self through the self, bringing mind, understanding, and senses under control. The self could become one’s friend or one’s enemy. Self-conquest made it a friend. Desire and anger tore through wisdom like a large fish breaking a net woven from thin cords. Someone who sought the means of success with attention to both righteousness and advantage could obtain his aims and enjoy happiness. A person seeking victory over outside enemies while leaving the five inner, mind-born enemies unconquered was himself overcome. Vidura recalled the many ill-disposed kings whom hunger for territory and lack of self-command had ruined through their own actions. Association carried its own danger. Wet wood burned alongside dry wood. An innocent person constantly accompanying wrongdoers could receive punishment with them. Friendship with the sinful should be avoided. The five greedy enemies pursued five distinct objects, and ignorance of the need to control them exposed a person to calamity.

Guilelessness, simplicity, purity, contentment, pleasant speech, self-restraint, truthfulness, and steadiness were absent from the wicked. Self-knowledge, firmness, patience, devotion to righteousness, the ability to keep counsel, and generosity were likewise absent from people of inferior character. Fools tried to injure the wise through false accusations and malicious speech, and took the wise person’s sins onto themselves, leaving the target free of those sins and forgiven. He located the strength of the wicked in malice and the strength of kings in the law of punishment. He located the strength of the weak and of women in attentive service, and that of the virtuous in forgiveness. Command of speech was especially difficult. A long conversation filled with meaning and pleasure for its listeners was hard to sustain. Well-spoken words produced many benefits. Badly spoken words caused harm. A forest struck with arrows or cut by axes could grow again. A heart injured by cruel speech and condemnation never recovered. Arrows, shot, and barbed darts could be removed from a body. The dagger of speech lodged in the heart could never be extracted. Verbal arrows left the mouth and struck another person’s vital center, bringing pain through day and night. A learned person should refrain from shooting them.

“When the gods ordain a man’s defeat, they take away his judgment, and he stoops to ignoble deeds. As his understanding dims and destruction draws near, wrong settles firmly in his heart wearing the look of right. You do not see it clearly. A clouded understanding has possessed your sons through their hostility to the Pandavas. Yudhishthira bears every auspicious mark, deserves to rule the three worlds, and still obeys your commands. Let him rule the earth, Dhritarashtra, to the exclusion of all your sons. He is the foremost of your heirs. He has energy and wisdom, he knows the truths of righteousness and advantage, and out of kindness and sympathy he has suffered great misery to preserve your good name.”

Prahlada tells the truth: Virochana and Sudhanvan wager their lives

“Tell me more words like these, consistent with righteousness and advantage,” Dhritarashtra said. “My thirst for them is not quenched. What you say is a delight to hear.” “Bathing at every holy place and kindness to every living creature: these two are equal,” Vidura replied, “and perhaps kindness surpasses the bathing. Show kindness to all your sons. It will win you great fame in this world and heaven after it. For as long as a man’s good deeds are spoken of on earth, so long is he honored in heaven. In this connection an old story is told of Virochana and Sudhanvan, both suitors for Keshini’s hand.” Keshini, unmatched in beauty and wishing for a good husband, had decided to choose him through a svayamvara, an assembly at which she would select her spouse. Virochana, a descendant of Diti and a leader among the Daityas, came hoping to obtain her. She asked him, “Are Brahmins superior, Virochana, or are the sons of Diti? And why should Sudhanvan not sit on the couch?” “We are sprung from Prajapati himself, Keshini,” Virochana said. “We stand at the head of all creatures, and this world is ours beyond doubt. Who are the gods, and who are the Brahmins?” “Then we will stay here in this pavilion,” Keshini said. “Sudhanvan comes tomorrow. Let me see the two of you sitting together.” “I will do as you say,” Virochana said. “In the morning you will see Sudhanvan and me together.”

Night passed and the sun rose. Sudhanvan, the son of the sage Angiras, reached the place where Virochana waited with Keshini. Seeing the Brahmin arrive, she rose from her own seat and offered him a seat, water for his feet, and arghya, the formal offering of welcome. Virochana invited him to share his place. “I touch your fine golden seat, son of Prahlada,” Sudhanvan said. “But I cannot let myself be counted your equal and sit on it with you.” “A wooden plank, an animal skin, a mat of grass or straw: these are fit for you, Sudhanvan,” Virochana said. “You do not deserve the same seat as I.” “Father and son may sit together on one seat,” Sudhanvan answered, “and so may Brahmins of the same age and equal learning, two Kshatriyas, two Vaishyas, or two Shudras. No others may share a seat. Your father used to pay me his respects from a seat lower than mine. You are a child raised in every luxury at home, and you understand nothing.” “Then let us stake all the gold, cattle, horses, and every other kind of wealth we Asuras own,” Virochana said, “and put the question to those able to answer it.” “Leave your gold and cattle and horses alone, Virochana. We will wager our lives on it, and put the question to those who are competent.” “Wagering our lives, where shall we go?” Virochana asked. “I will appear before none of the gods, and never before any man.” “Then, with our lives wagered, we go to your father,” Sudhanvan said. “Prahlada will never speak an untruth, even for the sake of his son.”

With the wager laid, both men went angrily to Prahlada. He saw them coming along the same road. “These two were never companions before,” he said, “and now they come together by one road, like two angry snakes. Have you become companions, you who never were? I ask you, Virochana: is there friendship between you and Sudhanvan?” “There is no friendship between us,” Virochana said. “We have wagered our lives. I will ask you a question, and you must not answer it untruly.” “Let water, honey, and curds be brought for Sudhanvan,” Prahlada said. “You deserve our worship. A fat white cow is ready for you.” “Water, honey, and curds were given to me on my way here,” Sudhanvan said. “I have a question. Answer it truly, Prahlada: are Brahmins superior, or is Virochana?” Prahlada faced the two of them. “This one is my only son, and you stand here in person. How can one like me answer a question over which you two have quarreled?” “Give your son your cattle and whatever precious wealth you have,” Sudhanvan said. “But on the matter the two of us dispute, you must declare the truth.” “Then tell me this, Sudhanvan. How does a man suffer who misuses his tongue, who gives a false answer to the question put to him?”

“The man who misuses his tongue,” Sudhanvan said, “suffers like a deserted wife who lies awake at night watching her husband sleep in the arms of a co-wife. He suffers like a man who has lost at dice, or one bent beneath an unbearable load of anxieties. He stays starving outside the city gates, barred from entering. A man who gives false witness is destined always to meet his enemies. A lie told for an animal casts five of his ancestors down from heaven. A lie for a cow casts down ten. A lie for a horse brings down a hundred, and a lie for a human being a thousand. A lie for gold ruins his line, those born and those unborn, and a lie for the sake of land ruins everything. So never speak an untruth for the sake of land.”

Prahlada gave his answer. “Angiras is superior to me, and Sudhanvan is superior to you, Virochana. Sudhanvan’s mother is superior to your mother. So you have been defeated by Sudhanvan, and he is now the master of your life. But I wish, Sudhanvan, that you would grant Virochana his life.” “Since you preferred virtue, Prahlada, and did not speak an untruth from temptation, I grant your son the life that is dear to you,” Sudhanvan said. “Here is Virochana, restored to you. He must, however, wash my feet in the presence of the maiden Keshini.”

No falsehood for land: Vidura examines righteousness and prosperity

“For these reasons you must never speak an untruth for the sake of land,” Vidura said. “Do not lie out of affection for your son and hurry to destruction with all your children and counselors. The gods do not protect men by standing over them with clubs like herdsmen. To those they wish to protect, they grant intelligence.” Success in a person’s aims followed the attention given to righteousness and moral conduct. The Vedas could offer no rescue from sin to someone living through deceit and falsehood. At death they deserted such a person, like birds leaving the nest once their wings had grown. Vidura warned against drinking, quarrels, hostility toward large numbers of people, and involvement in marital disputes. He also warned against breaking the bond between husband and wife, internal dissension, disloyalty to the king, and every sinful course. He named seven people unfit to serve as witnesses: a palm reader, a thief who had become a merchant, and a bird catcher. A physician, an enemy, a friend, and a minstrel were unfit too. Four practices innocent in themselves became harmful when performed improperly out of pride: the Agnihotra, a vow of silence, study, and sacrifice.

He then listed people whose moral wrongdoing he ranked with the killing of a Brahmin. The list included someone who burned a dwelling, administered poison, arranged sexual misconduct, sold soma juice, or made arrows. It also included someone who practiced astrology, injured friends, committed adultery, caused an abortion, violated a teacher’s marriage bed, or was a Brahmin addicted to drink. It continued with a harsh speaker, someone who reopened old wounds, an atheist, a reviler of the Vedas, and a bribe taker. Then came someone whose sacred-thread initiation had been delayed beyond the prescribed age, someone who secretly killed cattle, and someone who killed a person asking for protection. Fire tested gold. Deportment tested a person of high birth, and conduct tested honesty. Panic tested courage, poverty tested self-restraint, and danger and calamity revealed friends and enemies. Age and infirmity destroyed beauty, and ambitious hopes destroyed patience. Death destroyed life, and envy destroyed righteousness. Anger destroyed prosperity, and low company destroyed good conduct. Desire destroyed modesty, and pride destroyed everything. Prosperity began in good deeds, grew through activity, took deep root through skill, and became stable through self-command.

Eight qualities brought distinction to their possessor: wisdom, good lineage, self-control, knowledge of scripture, courage, freedom from excessive talk, giving according to one’s means, and gratitude. Vidura added that royal recognition could bring the brilliance of all these qualities together in a single person. When the king honored someone, his favor made them shine. Another eight things signaled heaven within human life. Four were inseparable from good people: sacrifice, generosity, study, and austerity. The good continually followed four others: self-restraint, truth, simplicity, and avoidance of harm to all creatures. Vidura gave a further group of eight as the paths of righteousness: sacrifice, study, charity, austerity, truth, forgiveness, mercy, and contentment. The first four could be practiced from pride. The last four belonged to the truly noble. An assembly required elders, and elders earned that standing by declaring what was right. Righteousness depended on truth, and truth was free of deceit. He named ten attributes of heavenly origin: truth, beauty, familiarity with scripture, knowledge, high birth, good conduct, strength, wealth, bravery, and the ability to converse on many subjects.

Wrongdoing brought harmful consequences, and virtuous conduct brought great happiness. A person should therefore resolve firmly to abandon sin. Repeated wrongdoing destroyed understanding. Diminished understanding led to further wrongdoing. Repeated righteousness increased understanding, and the growth of understanding encouraged further righteous action. Through that practice, a virtuous person reached blessed regions. Envy, deep injury to others, cruelty, constant quarrels, and deceit quickly brought great misery. Someone free of envy, possessed of judgment, and continually doing good avoided such misery and shone everywhere. Learning wisdom from the wise made a person truly learned. Attention to both righteousness and practical advantage made happiness possible. Vidura urged preparation across the stages of time: work during the day so the night could be happy. Work during eight months of the year so the rainy season could be happy. Act in youth to secure a happy old age. Act throughout this life to secure happiness afterward. The wise valued food that digested easily, a wife whose youth had passed, a victorious hero, and an ascetic whose efforts had succeeded. Wealth obtained unjustly failed to cover the gap it was meant to fill, while opening new gaps elsewhere.

A teacher governed people who already possessed self-command, and a king governed wrongdoers. Yama, the son of Vivasvat and ruler over the dead, governed those who sinned in secret. The greatness of sages, of rivers, of riverbanks, and of noble souls, and the cause of women’s wickedness, could never be fully determined. Devotion to honoring Brahmins, generosity, righteous behavior toward relatives, and noble conduct in a Kshatriya sustained lasting rule over the earth. Three kinds of people could always gather golden flowers from the ground: the brave, the learned, and those who knew how to protect others. Vidura ranked work accomplished through intelligence first and work accomplished through the arms second. Work using the thighs and labor carrying burdens on the head he placed lowest. Then he turned to the king again. “You have placed the care of your kingdom on Duryodhana, on Shakuni, on the foolish Duhshasana, and on Karna. How can you hope for prosperity? The Pandavas possess every virtue, and they depend on you as their father. Rest on them as on your sons.”

Atreya’s teaching and the meaning of a worthy family

Vidura told another old story, the discourse between Atreya, the son of Atri, and the deities called Sadhyas. The Sadhyas had met the sage while he traveled in the guise of a mendicant, living on what others gave him. He kept rigorous vows, but his appearance left them unable to identify him. “We are the deities called Sadhyas,” they said. “Seeing you, we cannot guess who you are. Yet it seems to us that knowledge of the scriptures has given you intelligence and command over yourself. Speak to us, then, in generous words full of learning.” “I have heard this,” the sage answered. “Untie all the knots of the heart by tranquility, by mastery over the passions, and by the practice of true righteousness. Regard the agreeable and the disagreeable alike, as you regard your own self. Do not return the slanders and reproaches of others. The pain felt by one who bears them in silence consumes the slanderer, and the one who bears them takes the slanderer’s merit for his own. Do not slander or reproach. Do not humiliate or insult others. Do not quarrel with friends. Shun the company of the vile and the low. Be neither arrogant nor ignoble in conduct, and avoid words that are harsh and full of anger.” Harsh speech, heated with anger, could burn the very places on which a human life depended: the vital organs, the bones, the heart. A person committed to virtue must keep that kind of speech from his own mouth.

Someone who drove verbal thorns into other people’s most vulnerable places carried hell on his tongue, the sage said. He became a source of suffering wherever his words reached. The person struck by those words would feel their force as sharply as an arrow, with the burning heat of fire or the sun. Even deeply wounded, the wise person should endure, remembering the transfer of merit from the aggressor. The company one kept also entered one’s character. Serve a good person or a wicked one, an ascetic or a thief, and that companion’s color would gradually become one’s own, as dye entered cloth immersed in it. The gods themselves desired the company of someone who could receive an insult and decline to retaliate. Having someone else return it would count as retaliation too. The same restraint applied to blows: neither strike back nor arrange for another to strike, and wish no injury upon the person who caused the hurt. The sage described speech through a series of choices. Silence came first. When speaking became necessary, speak truthfully. Make the truth agreeable to hear, and make agreeable speech consistent with righteousness. A person grew to resemble those he lived with, those he looked up to, and the person he wished to become. Whatever he relinquished ceased to bind him. Complete relinquishment brought freedom from even the smallest suffering. Such a person neither conquered others nor suffered conquest, neither injured nor opposed them. Praise and blame could no longer move him, and grief and elation lost their power over him.

Atri’s son then distinguished kinds of character. The finest person wished prosperity for everyone and never set his heart on another’s misery. Truthfulness, humility, and mastery of the passions accompanied that wish. A person of middling goodness refused to comfort someone with a lie, gave what he had promised, and kept watch over other people’s vulnerabilities. A bad person resisted control, exposed himself to danger, yielded readily to anger, failed to feel gratitude, could not become a true friend, and harbored wickedness in his heart. The sage also placed among the worst those who remained dissatisfied with every benefit another person offered, distrusted even themselves, and drove away their real friends. Someone seeking his own welfare should associate with the good, occasionally with people of indifferent character, and never with the wicked. Wicked people could certainly become wealthy. Strength, unremitting effort, intelligence, and courage might all serve their pursuit of possessions. They would still lack honorable fame and the conduct that made a family worthy of respect, even if their birth placed them within such a family. Here Dhritarashtra put in a question. “The gods, and those who hold to both righteousness and advantage without swerving, and the greatly learned, all express a liking for high families. I ask you this, Vidura: what are the families that are called high?”

Vidura gave seven foundations: austerity, self-restraint, the Vedas, knowledge, sacrifice, pure marriages, and the giving of food. Families in which these were practiced properly were high. Such people kept to the right course. Their dead ancestors were spared the pain of seeing their descendants do wrong. They embraced good conduct willingly, wanted to add to the unblemished name inherited from their forebears, and avoided falsehood of every kind. Vidura also named the ways a family could fall. Abandoning sacrifice, impure marriages, neglecting the Vedas, and insulting Brahmins brought decline. So did treating Brahmins with contempt, speaking ill of them, and taking for oneself property that someone else had entrusted to the household. Large numbers of relatives, accumulated wealth, and herds of cattle could never compensate for poor conduct. A household with little money could nevertheless win a great name through the way its members behaved. Wealth arrived and departed. Manners and integrity required continual care. Lacking money alone did not make a person truly deficient. Losing the conduct that deserved respect did. Even full fields, cattle, and other livestock left a family without a claim to honor when its behavior failed.

“Let no one in our line foster quarrels, or serve a king as a minister, or steal another’s wealth, or provoke divisions within the family. Let none be deceitful or false, and let none eat before the sages, the gods, and guests have received what is due to them. Whoever in our line kills Brahmins, or hates them, or hinders and injures agriculture, does not deserve to mix with us.” A household’s poverty, however, need never prevent all hospitality. Four things remained available in the homes of good people. They were straw to offer as a seat, ground on which a visitor could sit, water for washing feet and face, and words spoken kindly. Someone intent on welcoming a guest could have these ready and present them with respect. A worthy family also carried burdens that might defeat another. Vidura compared it to the syandana tree: a slender piece of its timber could bear a weight that thicker wood from other trees could not sustain. Families formed by good conduct acquired that kind of strength under the weight of care.

Trust between friends and the strength of trees standing together

A person whose anger inspired fear, or whose company required fearful attendance, was no friend. A true friend could be trusted as a father could be trusted. Even someone with no connection by birth or blood could become a refuge and protector through the way he behaved. An unsteady heart, neglect of elders, and a restless disposition prevented that bond from forming. Success itself abandoned someone who could not govern his mind and remained enslaved to his senses, as swans abandoned a pool after its water dried up. A weak mind rushed into anger and became pleased again without sufficient cause, shifting like clouds. Even carrion birds avoided the bodies of people who received help from friends and repaid it with ingratitude. Rich or poor, a person owed friends respect. Their sincerity became clear when help was actually requested. Sorrow, once a person surrendered to it, diminished beauty, strength, and understanding. Disease followed. The body withered, enemies took pleasure, and the object that grief sought came no closer. Human beings died and were born again, declined and grew, asked for help and were themselves asked, mourned and became the subjects of mourning. Happiness and misery, abundance and want, gain and loss, life and death all came in their turn. The self-controlled person must remain steady through them. The six senses never stayed still. Whichever gained dominance could drain understanding in proportion to its strength, as a hole drained water from a pot.

Dhritarashtra answered with an admission. “I deceived Yudhishthira. He is like a flame of fire, and he will surely destroy all my wicked sons in battle. Everything seems dangerous to me. My mind is full of anxiety. Tell me something that will take it away.” “Only in knowledge and austerity, in restraint of the senses, and in the complete abandonment of greed do I see your good,” Vidura told him. Each had its work to do: self-knowledge dispelled fear, austerity won what was great and valuable, attendance upon one’s seniors brought learning, and self-restraint brought peace. People seeking liberation without the merit acquired through gifts or Vedic observances could pass through life free of anger and aversion, he said. Happiness arising from thoughtful study, from a battle fought in accordance with duty, and from rigorously practiced austerities increased at their completion. Estrangement from relatives carried a different consequence into daily life. Fine beds could give such people no sleep. Women offered no pleasure. The songs of bards and praise singers gave no satisfaction. Righteous conduct, happiness, and honor slipped beyond them. Peace lost its appeal, and advice meant for their benefit became unwelcome. They could neither acquire what they lacked nor hold on to what they possessed. Vidura foresaw destruction at the end of that course. As milk was possible in cows, austerity in Brahmins, and inconstancy in women, so fear was possible from relatives.

Good relatives acting together acquired strength that each lacked alone. Many thin threads of the same length, gathered into a fabric, could bear the repeated passage of the weaving tool across them. Separated firebrands produced smoke. Bring them together, and they flared into a powerful blaze. Vidura also warned against cruelty toward Brahmins, women, relatives, and cattle. Those who oppressed them would fall as ripe fruit fell from its stalk. A solitary tree might be enormous, strong, and deeply rooted, yet a mighty wind could twist and shatter its trunk. Trees growing close together resisted even stronger winds because each supported the others. An isolated person could possess every virtue and still appear easy to conquer to an enemy. Relatives grew through mutual help like the stems of lotuses standing together in a lake. Vidura also identified lives that must be spared: Brahmins, cattle, relatives, children, women, those whose food one had accepted, and those who surrendered and asked for protection. A meal received from someone created an obligation. So did another person’s appeal for refuge.

Without wealth a person’s good qualities had no means of showing themselves. Health nevertheless kept the possibility of welfare alive. Someone overcome by illness was as good as dead, unable to taste the pleasures that possessions might otherwise provide. Anger brought another affliction, which Vidura described as a bitter, pungent, acrid, burning drink. Its consequences were painful, like a headache arising without physical disease, and the unwise could never digest it. Dhritarashtra should swallow that anger, contain it within himself, and obtain peace. People tormented by disease lost their liking for enjoyments and their desire to draw happiness from wealth. Sorrow filled them, and both happiness and the uses of wealth became inaccessible. At the dice hall, when Draupadi had been won, Vidura had told Dhritarashtra that honorable people avoided cheating at play. “Stop Duryodhana,” he had urged. The king had not acted. Force set against gentleness was no strength at all. Strength joined with gentleness was the true policy, to be followed always. Prosperity founded entirely on crooked dealing would be destroyed. Prosperity sustained by strength together with gentleness could pass intact to children and grandchildren.

“Let your sons cherish the Pandavas, and let the Pandavas cherish your sons. Let the Kurus and the Pandavas, with the same friends and the same foes, live together in happiness and prosperity. Today you are the refuge of the sons of Kuru, Dhritarashtra. The whole race of Kuru depends on you. Keep your fame unstained and cherish the children of Pandu, worn as they are by the sufferings of exile. Make peace with them, and let no enemy discover the weak places in this house. They are all devoted to truth. Withdraw Duryodhana from his evil ways.”

Seventeen futile efforts, six threats to life, and the trust of servants

Manu, the son of the Self-created, had described seventeen kinds of foolish people as striking empty air. Manu had also described them as trying to bend Indra’s misty bow in the sky, or attempting to catch the sun’s intangible rays. The first tried to control someone incapable of restraint, and the second was satisfied with small gains. The third humbly courted enemies, and the fourth tried to restrain women’s frailty. The fifth asked for gifts from someone who should never be asked, and the sixth boasted of an achievement. The seventh, born into a high family, did something improper, and the eighth, though weak, maintained hostility toward someone strong. The ninth addressed a person listening with contempt, and the tenth desired the unattainable. The eleventh was a father-in-law who joked with his daughter-in-law, and the twelfth boasted that his daughter-in-law had dispelled his fears. The thirteenth scattered his own seed in another person’s field, and the fourteenth maligned his own wife. The fifteenth received something and denied remembering it. The sixteenth promised a gift at a holy place and boasted when asked at home to fulfill the promise, and the seventeenth labored to establish a falsehood as truth. Yama’s messengers, carrying nooses, dragged such people to hell. Social policy permitted responding to another person according to that person’s conduct: deceit toward the deceitful and honesty toward the honest.

Age wore away beauty. Patience brought an end to hope, death to life, and the practice of virtue to worldly enjoyments. Desire destroyed modesty, and bad company damaged good conduct. Anger consumed prosperity. Pride could destroy everything. “The Vedas all say that a man has a hundred years for his life,” Dhritarashtra asked. “Why then do not all men reach the allotted span?” “Too much pride, too much speech, too much eating, anger, the appetite for enjoyment, and division within one’s own people,” Vidura said. “These are six sharp swords that cut short the life allotted to creatures. It is these that kill men, and not death.” He then named acts whose guilt he placed alongside the killing of a Brahmin. Taking the wife of someone who had placed trust in the offender was one. Violating a teacher’s marriage bed was another. His list also included a Brahmin marrying a Shudra woman or drinking wine. He condemned commanding Brahmins, becoming their master, or seizing the land that maintained them, and killing someone who had yielded and asked for protection. He said the Vedas required expiation after contact with people guilty of those acts. He also described the conduct leading to heaven: accept wise instruction, understand duty, give generously, and eat after dedicating food to the gods and departed ancestors. Add freedom from envy and the wish to injure, together with gratitude, truthfulness, humility, and learning.

Agreeable words were easy to find. The difficulty lay with words that could heal while hurting the listener’s pride. Few people would speak them. Few would listen when they were spoken. The counselor who kept righteousness before him and told his master an unwelcome truth added to the king’s strength. Pleasing the king could never be his sole measure of useful advice. Vidura set out a hierarchy of claims. A member could be sacrificed for a family, a family for a village, a village for a kingdom, and the whole earth for the self. Wealth should be guarded against future calamity. Through wealth, a person should protect his wives, and through both wealth and wives, protect himself. Gambling had provoked quarrels since ancient times. A wise person should avoid it even as amusement. “At the dice game, I told you this was wrong,” Vidura reminded Dhritarashtra. “Like medicine to a sick man, my words were not agreeable to you. You want to defeat the sons of Pandu, who are peacocks of brilliant plumage, while your sons are all crows. You abandon lions to shelter jackals. When the time comes, you will grieve for all this.”

The same question of trust governed a ruler’s dealings with those who served him. A master won confidence by refraining from venting his displeasure on devoted servants who worked zealously for his good. They would stay with him when trouble came. Confiscating their grants or stopping their wages to increase his own wealth would destroy that attachment. Even counselors who loved him could turn away once he took the means of livelihood and enjoyment from them, leaving him without their help in distress. A king should first examine the work he intended to undertake. Wages and allowances needed to be considered alongside his income and expenditure. With that provision made, he should form the alliances required for the work, because cooperation could make every undertaking possible. Vidura described an officer who deserved to be regarded as a second self. Such a person understood the king’s intention fully and carried out his duties eagerly. He had standing of his own, remained devoted to his master, and consistently told him what would serve his good. He also understood the extent of his own power and that of the opponents he might face.

A servant who ignored commands, refused assigned work, and habitually argued from pride in his own intelligence should be dismissed without delay. Learned people looked for eight qualities in a servant: freedom from pride, ability, promptness, kindness, cleanliness, incorruptibility, birth in a family free from disease, and weight in speech.

Five kinds of strength and the tigers of the Kuru forest

Even an announced visit gave no assurance of safety when entering an enemy’s house after dusk. A person should avoid lurking in someone else’s yard at night and avoid pursuing a woman the king might desire. Someone who kept bad company and consulted everyone he met called for another kind of care: challenging his decision openly or declaring disbelief would be unwise. Give a reason, Vidura advised, and send him away on a pretext. He named people with whom one should avoid lending and borrowing: an excessively merciful king, a sexually promiscuous woman, a royal servant, a son, and a brother. A widow with an infant son, someone serving in an army, and a person who had suffered great losses should be avoided too. Eight qualities gave a person distinction: wisdom, high lineage, knowledge of scripture, self-restraint, courage, restraint in speech, giving within one’s means, and gratitude. One further endowment gathered the effect of these qualities together. When a king favored someone, that favor brought other advantages and held them in place. Vidura also named ten benefits of bathing: strength, beauty, clarity of voice, the ability to pronounce every sound, and delicacy of touch. A fine scent, cleanliness, grace, delicacy of the limbs, and beautiful women were benefits too. The sparing eater won health, long life, and ease. His children were healthy, and no one reproached him for gluttony.

A household should refuse shelter to someone who habitually behaved improperly, ate excessively, or was hated by everyone. Vidura included the highly deceitful, the cruel, those without a sense of the proper time and place, and those who dressed indecently. Distress could also tempt a person to seek help from an unsuitable giver. Even in that condition, he advised against asking a miser, a slanderer, or someone ignorant of scripture. He also advised against asking a forest dweller, a cunning person, or someone who withheld respect from those deserving it. He added the cruel, the perpetually quarrelsome, and the ungrateful. Service carried its own hazards. Six kinds of people should never be served: an enemy, someone constantly in error, and someone devoted to falsehood. Someone without devotion to the gods, someone without affection, and someone convinced that he could do everything should never be served either. The purpose a person pursued depended upon the means available. The means, in turn, had to fit that purpose. Both required consideration if the undertaking was to succeed. Vidura then described the proper withdrawal from household responsibilities. A father should have sons and establish them with provision for their independence. He should marry his daughters to suitable people. After completing those duties, he could retire to the forest and seek the life of a muni, directing himself toward a sage’s discipline. To gain the Supreme Being’s favor, a person should act for the good of all creatures together with his own happiness. That was the root of successful effort. With intelligence, energy, courage, strength, readiness, and perseverance, what reason had he to fear for his livelihood?

A break with the Pandavas would have consequences painful enough to sadden Indra and the other gods. First would come hostility among men who were all the king’s sons. Then came a life of continual anxiety, the loss of the Kurus’ good name, and the delight of their enemies. The anger of Bhishma, Drona, and Yudhishthira could consume the world like a great comet falling across the earth. Another future remained possible: Dhritarashtra’s hundred sons, Karna, and Pandu’s sons could together rule the entire land bounded by the seas. The king’s sons formed a forest, and the Pandavas were its tigers. “Do not destroy the forest with its tigers. Do not drive the tigers out. The forest shelters them, and they guard the forest.” Each survived through the other’s protection. Sinful people were eager to find faults and gave little attention to other people’s virtues. Anyone seeking lasting worldly advantage should practice righteousness from the beginning, because true advantage remained joined to heaven. A mind separated from sin and firmly established in virtue understood things in their natural state and in the conditions they acquired. Pursuing righteousness, advantage, and pleasure at their proper times brought all three together here and beyond this life. Prosperity came to the person who restrained both anger and elation and kept his judgment during calamity.

There were five kinds of strength. The power of the arms ranked lowest. The second was the acquisition of good counselors. Wealth came third. Fourth came the strength of birth, inherited from fathers and grandfathers. Intelligence stood above them all because it could obtain the other forms of power. A person who provoked an enemy capable of terrible injury should take no comfort in the distance between them. Vidura warned against placing trust in women, kings, snakes, one’s own master, enemies, enjoyments, or the allotted length of life. Someone struck by the arrow of intelligence could find no physician or medicine to heal the injury. The formulas used in a fire offering, auspicious ceremonies, the mantras of the Atharva Veda, and remedies against poison would all be powerless. He also cautioned against disregarding snakes, fire, lions, and blood relatives. Each possessed strength that required respect.

Fire lay within wood without consuming it until someone kindled it. Once friction drew it out, that same fire could burn its containing wood, an entire forest, and much besides. People of high lineage could hold their energy in the same way. Their forgiveness left them quiet, showing none of the outward signs of anger, like the fire still hidden in timber. “You and your sons have the nature of creepers, Dhritarashtra, and the sons of Pandu are sala trees. A creeper never grows unless there is a great tree to twine around. Your son is a forest, son of Ambika, and the Pandavas are the lions of that forest. Without its lions the forest is doomed to destruction, and without the forest to shelter them the lions are doomed as well.”

Honoring guests, guarding counsel, and bearing the kingdom’s burden

A young person’s heart rose when a venerable elder entered the house. By approaching and saluting the visitor, he recovered it. A disciplined host should first provide a seat and water for the guest’s feet and make the customary inquiries of welcome. Then he should speak of his own affairs and offer food with proper regard for the circumstances. The wise considered a life wasted when a learned Brahmin refused a household’s water, honey, curds, or cattle. He refused them because he feared being unable to make proper use of them, or because the giver was miserly and unwilling. Even guests as undeserving as these were to be offered water, and the offering was to be held dear. Such a guest might be a physician, an arrow maker, someone who abandoned the celibate student’s vow before completing it, a thief, or a crooked-minded person. He might also be a drinking Brahmin, someone who caused a miscarriage, a soldier, or a seller of the Vedas. Vidura forbade a Brahmin to sell salt, cooked food, curds, milk, honey, oil, clarified butter, sesame, meat, fruits, roots, greens, dyed clothes, perfumes of any kind, or treacle. A true yogi of the mendicant order remained above anger and grief, free of dependence on friendship and quarrels, indifferent to praise and blame, and withdrawn from attraction and aversion. A forest ascetic who lived on wild rice, roots, or greens, controlled himself, tended his sacred fire, and cared for guests stood foremost among his fellows.

Distance gave no safety after injuring an intelligent person whose reach could extend far enough to return the harm. A person should trust the trustworthy within limits and avoid trusting those who deserved none, since misplaced confidence could cut away one’s very roots. Vidura urged freedom from envy, protection of wives, payment of everyone’s due, and agreeable speech. A husband should speak pleasantly and sweetly to his wives while preserving his independence. Virtuous, blessed women who deserved reverence and adorned their homes embodied domestic prosperity and required particular protection. The father should oversee the inner apartments, the mother the kitchen, and someone trusted as oneself the cattle. Agriculture deserved personal supervision. Servants should attend merchant guests, sons the Brahmin guests. Fire originated in water, Kshatriyas in Brahmins, and iron in stone. Each possessed power over other things that became neutralized on contact with its own source. Fire remained concealed in wood, just as good and forgiving people of high lineage could conceal their fiery energy without outward signs.

A king whose deliberations remained unknown to outsiders and intimates, while his spies discovered the plans of others, enjoyed lasting prosperity. Intended acts should remain unannounced. Deeds concerning righteousness, advantage, and pleasure should become known after completion. A mountain summit, a palace terrace, or a wilderness bare of trees and plants provided places for secret deliberation. An unlearned friend and a learned friend without self-control were equally unfit to hold state secrets. Every prospective minister required careful examination because the king’s finances and confidential counsel depended on him. Vidura praised the king whose ministers learned of his actions only after they were done. Secrecy brought success. Blameworthy acts committed through ignorance could cost a person his life, while praiseworthy acts brought ease and their omission brought regret. A Brahmin without Vedic study was unfit to officiate at offerings for ancestors. A person ignorant of the six means of protecting a kingdom was unfit for political deliberations. A ruler who watched increase, decline, and surplus, understood the six means and himself, and maintained honored conduct could bring the earth under his authority. So could one whose anger and favor had real consequences, who personally supervised necessary work and controlled the treasury. The king should be satisfied with his name and the royal umbrella above him, sharing the kingdom’s wealth with those who served him. Brahmins understood Brahmins, husbands their wives, kings their ministers, and monarchs other monarchs.

In Vidura’s counsel, an enemy deserving death should never be set free once subdued. A weak person should court a stronger enemy even if that enemy deserved death, then kill him upon gaining sufficient strength, since leaving him alive allowed danger to arise. Anger toward gods, kings, Brahmins, elders, children, and the helpless required deliberate restraint. Avoiding the useless quarrels of fools brought fame and freedom from misery. People wanted no master whose favor gave no benefit and whose anger had no effect. Vidura compared this to women rejecting a eunuch as a husband. He said intelligence did not exist for acquiring wealth and idleness alone was no explanation for adversity. Only the wise understood the reasons for differences in people’s conditions. Fools disregarded those eminent in age, conduct, knowledge, understanding, wealth, and lineage. Wicked disposition, lack of judgment, envy, sin, harsh speech, and anger quickly brought calamity. Honesty, gifts, respect for established social dealings, and controlled speech won influence over others. An active, grateful, intelligent, honest, and guileless person could acquire friends, counselors, and servants even with an empty treasury. Intelligence, tranquility, self-control, purity, the absence of harsh words, and unwillingness to displease friends were the fuel of prosperity’s flame.

A person who withheld others’ due, was wicked, ungrateful, and shameless should be avoided. A guilty person who provoked an innocent one nearby could no more sleep peacefully than someone sharing a room with a snake. Those whose anger endangered property and the means of acquiring it should be appeased like gods. The outcome was doubtful when work depended on women, careless people, people who had abandoned their caste duties, or the wicked. Those guided by a woman, a deceitful person, or a child were like a stone raft sinking helplessly. Knowledge of the general principles of work earned a person recognition as learned even without expertise in a particular task, since particular tasks were subordinate to those principles. Praise from swindlers, performers, and women of ill repute made a person more dead than alive. Finally Vidura turned to the king’s own decision. “You have set aside the sons of Pandu, mighty bowmen of immeasurable energy, and laid the cares of a great empire on Duryodhana. You will soon see that swelling prosperity fall away, like Bali fallen from the three worlds.”

Attachment to a son and the duty to repair: Vidura renews the Pandavas’ claim

“Man is the master of neither his prosperity nor his adversity,” Dhritarashtra said. “He is a wooden doll moved by strings. The Creator has made him subject to destiny. Go on. I am attentive to what you say.” “Even Brihaspati,” Vidura answered, “speaking out of season, earns reproach and the charge of ignorance.” People became agreeable through gifts, kind words, or the power of incantations and drugs. Natural agreeableness endured of itself. Hatred prevented a person from recognizing honesty, intelligence, or wisdom in its object. Love assigned every good quality to someone, hatred every bad one. “As soon as Duryodhana was born I told you: give up this one son. By giving him up you would secure the prosperity of your hundred sons. By keeping him, destruction would overtake them all. A gain that leads to loss should never be rated highly, and a loss that brings gain should be. That is no loss which brings gain, and the loss to reckon with is the one certain to bring greater losses still.” Some people gained eminence through qualities, others through wealth. Dhritarashtra should avoid the wealthy who lacked good qualities. “All that you say is approved by the wise and is for my future good,” the king said. “I dare not, however, abandon my son. It is well known that where righteousness is, there victory is.”

Vidura described a virtuous, humble person as attentive even to the smallest suffering of living creatures. Habitual slanderers pursued quarrels and acts that hurt others. Receiving gifts from dangerous, inauspicious people brought sin, while giving to them carried danger. Quarrelsomeness, greed, shamelessness, deceit, and serious faults of that kind made companionship unworthy of pursuit. When the occasion that created a low person’s friendship ended, the friendship, benefit, and happiness ended with it. Slander of the former friend and efforts to cause loss followed. Such people could lose their own peace over even a small injury because they lacked self-command. Careful examination should lead the learned to avoid them from a distance. Helping poor, wretched, and helpless relatives brought children, livestock, and lasting prosperity. Anyone concerned for his own good should support his family. Dhritarashtra should seek the growth of his line through good conduct toward all its members. “Even relatives without virtues deserve protection. How much more, then, those endowed with every virtue, who wait humbly on your favor? Favor the heroic sons of Pandu, and let a few villages be assigned to them for their maintenance. Fame will be yours in this world for it. You are old. Control your sons. I say what is for your good. Know me as one who wishes you well.”

Relatives should share happiness, food, conversation, and affection, keeping themselves free of quarrels. Righteous relatives rescued their people. Unrighteous ones dragged them down. “Be righteous in your conduct toward the sons of Pandu. Surrounded by them, you would be unconquerable by your foes. If a relative shrinks before a prosperous kinsman like a deer at the sight of a hunter armed with arrows, the prosperous one takes all the other’s sins upon himself. You will repent of this inaction when you hear of the death of the Pandavas or of your own sons. Think of all this.” Life was uncertain. An act certain to produce remorse should be avoided before it brought a person into the chamber of grief. People other than Bhargava, the author of the science of moral conduct, could act against righteousness, yet intelligent people retained an understanding of consequences. Dhritarashtra was an elder of the Kuru line. If Duryodhana had wronged the Pandavas, the king had a duty to undo those wrongs. Restoring them to their position would cleanse him of sin and earn him reverence even from people of disciplined lives. Acting after considering the consequences of wise counsel preserved a person’s reputation.

Instruction from the learned and skilled could remain incomplete because its recipient misunderstood it or failed to put an understood lesson into practice. A learned person who avoided actions leading to sin and misery continued to prosper. Someone foolishly persisting in a sinful course sank into deep mud. Vidura identified six routes through which confidential plans escaped: intoxication, sleep, neglect of spies planted by others, behavior revealing inward thoughts, trust in a wicked counselor, and unskilled envoys. Anyone seeking success and a lasting dynasty should close those routes. Their protection while pursuing righteousness, advantage, and pleasure raised a ruler above his enemies. Even Brihaspati’s intelligence could never replace scriptural knowledge and attendance upon elders in understanding or winning righteousness and advantage. An object cast into the sea was lost, as were words addressed to someone unwilling to listen. So were scripture given to someone without self-command and clarified butter poured over the ashes of an extinguished fire. An intelligent person formed friendships with the wise after repeated examination through understanding, hearing, sight, and judgment. Humility removed disgrace, and courage overcame failure. Forgiveness conquered anger, and auspicious rites removed signs of evil.

Lineage could be tested through a person’s pleasures, birthplace, house, behavior, food, and clothing. Even someone who had attained liberation might accept an available pleasure. The attraction was stronger for someone still bound by desire. A king should support a counselor who honored wisdom and possessed learning, virtue, a pleasing appearance, friends, agreeable speech, and a good heart. High or low birth made no difference to Vidura’s next comparison. Someone who respected the rules of polite conduct, attended to righteousness, and maintained humility and modesty surpassed a hundred people of high birth. Friendship remained warm when hearts, private pursuits, pleasures, and attainments agreed. An ignorant, wicked person should be avoided like a pit hidden under grass. Friendship with such a person could never last. Pride, ignorance, fierceness, rashness, and departure from righteousness were further reasons to refrain from friendship. Gratitude, virtue, truthfulness, generosity of spirit, devotion, self-control, dignity, and steadfast loyalty marked the person to seek as a friend.

The limits of desire: prosperity, restraint, and equal treatment

Vidura compared complete separation of the senses from their objects to death itself. Excessive indulgence could ruin even the gods. Humility, love for all creatures, forgiveness, and respect for friends lengthened life. A person showed real strength by returning with firm resolve to a purpose that had failed and pursuing it through righteous means. Success belonged to someone who understood the remedies the future might require, stood firm in the present, and had considered from the beginning how an undertaking would end. What people pursued in speech, action, and thought drew them into its possession. They should therefore keep their attention on what served their good. Prosperity came through efforts toward good ends, understanding the time, place, and available means, knowledge of scripture, activity, straightforward conduct, and regular meetings with good people. Perseverance supported prosperity, gain, and well-being. Someone who continued without giving up in frustration could attain lasting happiness. For a powerful, energetic person, forgiveness was the most fitting and happiness-producing response at every time and place. A weak person should forgive under all circumstances. A strong person should do so out of righteousness. Someone who regarded success and failure alike would forgive naturally. Pleasure could be enjoyed fully when it caused no injury to righteousness or material well-being. Foolish surrender to the senses remained dangerous.

Prosperity would never settle with someone tormented by grief, committed to evil ways, denying the divine, idle, uncontrolled, or unwilling to exert himself. Yet Vidura recognized that badly directed minds could treat a humble, modest person as weak and persecute him. He also described prosperity as an unreliable presence. She seemed afraid to approach the excessively generous, those who gave without measure, the extraordinarily brave, practitioners of the most rigid vows, and people intensely proud of their wisdom. She settled with neither the supremely accomplished nor those entirely without accomplishment. Complete virtue and its complete absence both failed to attract her. Blind as a frenzied cow, she might stay with someone unremarkable. Vidura then named the results toward which several things tended. The Vedas bore fruit in ceremonies before the sacrificial fire. Scriptural knowledge bore fruit in goodness of character and behavior. Women bore fruit in sexual enjoyment and children. Wealth bore fruit in enjoyment and charity. Money acquired through sin would yield no reward in the next world when spent on acts intended to secure such a reward. Its wrongful acquisition spoiled the intended result. Strength of mind, meanwhile, kept a person fearless in deserts, deep forests, inaccessible strongholds, dangers and alarms, and even before weapons raised to kill him.

Exertion, self-control, skill, care, steadiness, memory, and beginning an undertaking after mature thought formed the roots of prosperity. Ascetics drew strength from austerity. Those who knew the Vedas drew strength from that knowledge. The wicked found strength in envy, the virtuous in forgiveness. Vidura listed eight things that did not break a vow: water, roots, fruit, milk, and clarified butter. An action undertaken at a Brahmin’s wish, an action commanded by a teacher, and medicine did not break a vow either. He condensed righteousness into a rule of conduct toward others: a person should never subject another to what he would find harmful himself. Other forms of righteousness, he said, could arise from individual whim. Anger should be overcome through forgiveness, wickedness through honesty, miserliness through generosity, and falsehood through truth. Women should be distrusted, along with swindlers, the idle, cowards, the fierce, people who boasted of their strength, thieves, the ungrateful, and those who denied the divine. Respectful greetings to superiors and service to elders enlarged four things: achievement, the length of life, reputation, and power. A person should avoid fastening his desire on an object obtainable only through terrible suffering, the sacrifice of righteousness, or submission to an enemy.

Vidura called four conditions pitiable: a person without knowledge, sexual union that produced no offspring, a kingdom’s people going without food, and a kingdom lacking a ruler. Roads brought pain and weakness to embodied creatures through the burden of travel. Rain wore down hills and mountains. Women suffered from the absence of enjoyment, and the heart from words sharp as arrows. Failure to study tainted the Vedas, absence of vows tainted Brahmins, the Vahlika people tainted the earth, and falsehood tainted a human being. Curiosity was the impurity of a chaste woman, and exile from home the impurity of women generally. The image continued through metals: silver was the impurity of gold, tin of silver, lead of tin, and useless dross of lead. Sleep could never be conquered by continuing to lie down, women through desire, fire through fuel, or wine through further drinking.

A life was successful when its owner won friends through gifts, enemies in battle, and his wife through food and drink. People with thousands managed to live. People with hundreds lived as well. Some means of supporting life could be found. “Give up desire,” he told the king. “All the rice, wheat, gold, animals, and women on earth cannot satisfy even one man. Knowing this, the wise never grieve for want of dominion over the whole world. I tell you again, Dhritarashtra: behave equally toward your children, toward the sons of Pandu and your own sons.”

Only deeds will follow: Vidura’s final appeal

A good person honored by the good, free of pride and willing to work within the limits of his strength, could soon gain a lasting reputation. People of virtue, when pleased with someone, had the power to bring him happiness. Vidura compared someone who willingly abandoned even a great prize because its pursuit involved wrongdoing to a snake shedding its old skin. He could leave sorrow behind and live happily. Three offenses each carried the weight of killing a Brahmin: a victory secured through falsehood, deceit toward the king, and intentions dishonestly represented to a teacher. Excessive envy, death, and boasting destroyed prosperity. Carelessness in serving a teacher, haste, and boasting were the three enemies of knowledge. For students, he named laziness, inattention, confusion, restlessness, gatherings that merely wasted time, haughtiness, pride, and greed as obstacles to learning. A student who wanted knowledge had to surrender the insistence on comfort and pleasure. Someone committed to pleasure would have to relinquish the pursuit of knowledge. Fire remained hungry however much fuel it received. The ocean could receive every river and still take more. Death could consume all living beings and continue its work. A beautiful woman’s desire for men was as insatiable. Hope destroyed patience, Yama destroyed growth, anger destroyed prosperity, miserliness destroyed reputation, and neglect destroyed cattle. One angry Brahmin could destroy an entire kingdom.

The king’s household should always contain goats, brass, silver, honey, medicines against poison, birds, Brahmins learned in the Vedas, elderly relatives, and people of high birth reduced to poverty. Vidura also cited Manu’s prescription for a home prepared to honor gods, Brahmins, and guests. It should hold goats, bulls, sandalwood, lyres, mirrors, honey, and clarified butter. It should also hold iron, copper, conch shells, a shalagrama stone, and gorochana, a bright yellow pigment. These were auspicious objects suited to worship and hospitality. From the household, Vidura turned to what he called the highest teaching, a sacred lesson capable of yielding immense benefit. Desire, fear, temptation, and even the need to preserve life could never justify abandoning righteousness. Righteousness endured. Pleasure and pain passed away. Life itself was everlasting, while each particular condition in which it appeared was temporary. Dhritarashtra should turn toward what endured and cultivate contentment, the greatest thing a person could acquire. Mighty, illustrious kings had governed lands rich in grain and wealth. The destroyer of all had taken those rulers too, leaving their kingdoms and their abundant means of pleasure behind.

“Think of the son brought up with anxious care. When he dies, men lift him and carry him away to the burning ground. With disheveled hair and piteous cries they cast his body onto the funeral pyre as if it were a piece of wood. Others enjoy his wealth, and birds and fire feast on the elements of his body. Two things only go with him to the other world: his merits and his sins. Relatives, friends, and sons throw down the body and turn back, like birds abandoning a tree without blossoms or fruit. The man cast onto the pyre is followed only by his own acts. So earn the merit of righteousness carefully, little by little. Above this world and below it lie regions of deep gloom, where the senses of men suffer terribly. Avoid every such place. Listen to this and act on it, and you will win fame among men and be free of fear both here and hereafter.”

The soul could be understood as a river. Religious merit formed its sacred bathing places. Truth was its water, self-restraint its banks, and kindness its waves. A righteous person purified himself by bathing in that river. The soul was sacred, and freedom from desire was the highest merit. Vidura offered another river image for life: the five senses supplied its water, desire and anger were its crocodiles and sharks, and repeated births formed its whirlpools. Dhritarashtra should make self-control his boat and cross. Friends distinguished by wisdom, virtue, learning, and age deserved honor and attentive care. A person who pleased them and sought their counsel about what he should and should not do would avoid going astray. Patience should govern sexual appetite and the stomach, and the eyes should guide the hands and feet. The mind should govern the eyes and ears, and conduct should govern the mind and speech. Vidura then set out the duties he assigned to the four social orders. Suppose a Brahmin maintained ritual bathing, wore the sacred thread, studied the Vedas, avoided impure food, spoke truth, and acted in honor of his teacher. Then he would retain his place in Brahma’s realm. A Kshatriya, a member of the ruling and warrior order, should study the Vedas, pour offerings into the fire, perform sacrifices, and protect his subjects. Purified through taking up weapons to defend cattle and Brahmins, he would reach heaven upon dying in battle. A Vaishya should study the Vedas, distribute wealth at the proper times among Brahmins, Kshatriyas, and his dependents, and receive the sacred smoke of the three ritual fires. Heavenly happiness would follow him into the next world. A Shudra should honor Brahmins, Kshatriyas, and Vaishyas in their due order. By pleasing them, burning away his sins, and peacefully leaving his body, he too would attain the happiness of heaven.

“The duties of the four orders are now set before you,” Vidura said. “Listen to the reason for my speech. Yudhishthira, the son of Pandu, is falling away from the duties of the Kshatriya order. Place him in a position to discharge the duties of kings.” “It is just as you always teach me,” Dhritarashtra said. “My heart too inclines the way you tell me. Yet though my mind leans toward the Pandavas as you teach, as soon as I come into Duryodhana’s company it turns another way. No creature can avert fate. Destiny, I think, is certain to take its course. A man’s own effort is futile.”