The canon in time
Seen from high enough, the canon is a long shoreline, with marks set along it at intervals, some crowded together, some with centuries of open sand between them. Each mark is a text, composed or preserved in a century that can be named only roughly. The shore comes first, the whole length of it. Then the shelf’s own texts take their places on the same line.
A caution comes before the first date. Indian chronology is mostly relative. A text is placed after the one it quotes and before the one that quotes it. Its language dates the rest. Firm years stay in dispute, because these texts were carried by mouth for centuries before anyone wrote them down. The years that follow are the philologists’ working estimates. The philologists are Witzel, Jamison, and Brereton for the Veda, Olivelle for the Upanishads and for Manu, Brockington for the epics, Rocher for the Puranas. All of the estimates are approximate.
The rough order of composition
The oldest voices on the shore are the hymns. The Rigveda Samhita took shape around 1500 to 1200 BCE. The other Samhitas followed, about 1200 to 1000 BCE. Then the Brahmanas, the prose of the sacrifice, about 1000 to 700 BCE. In the Aranyakas and the older Upanishads, about 800 to 500 BCE, the questions move from the fire to the self, all of it before the Buddha. The Buddha and Mahavira teach in the fifth century BCE. The Vedangas, the limbs that kept the Veda’s sound and calendar exact, and the sutra literature, teaching compressed into threads for memory, belong to about 600 to 200 BCE. Then the epics, about 400 BCE to 400 CE, in which the Ramayana and the Mahabharata gathered their layers. Within that window the Gita took its shape, between about 200 BCE and 200 CE. Dharmashastra like Manu belongs to about the second to third century CE, the darshana sutras to about 200 BCE to 400 CE. The Puranas, composed and reworked across a long span, come to roughly 300 to 1000 CE, and the Agamas and Tantras to about 500 to 1200 CE. Then the commentators of Vedanta: Shankara in the eighth century, though scholars place him anywhere from about 700 to 820 CE, Ramanuja about 1100, and Madhva in the thirteenth century. Alongside them, from the sixth century to the seventeenth, bhakti found its voice in the spoken languages. And last, the Adi Granth, compiled in 1604, which in its final recension of about 1706 became the Guru Granth Sahib.
Four meanings of when
The word when carries four meanings here, and they refuse to collapse into one. There is the date of composition, the century in which a text settled into its form. Behind it runs the older oral stream, the generations of recitation the written text caught only at the end. Inside the text lies the story’s own time, counted by the tale itself in reigns and the ages of kings. And beyond all three stands the tradition’s yuga time, which seats the same events on a scale of its own. Each answers a different question, and none converts into another. The fourth is the clock that decides how many years Rama lived.
Our own shelf on this same line
- Purusha SuktaShrutiRigveda 10.90, a late hymn of the Samhita
- Sri RudramShrutiTaittiriya Samhita 4.5 and 4.7, about 1200 to 1000 BCE
- UpanishadsShrutiAbout 700 to 300 BCE
- Bhagavad GitaSmritiAbout 200 BCE to 200 CE
- MahavakyaShrutiFrom the Upanishads
- Yoga SutrasSmritiSecond to fourth century CE
- Vishnu SahasranamaSmritiIn the Mahabharata, first to fourth century CE
- Yaksha Prashna, Vidura Niti, AnugitaSmritiThe Mahabharata’s epic layer
- HarivamshaSmritiThe Mahabharata’s khila appendix, first to fourth century CE
- RamayanaSmritiCompiled about 400 BCE to 200 CE
- MahabharataSmritiCompiled about 400 BCE to 400 CE
- Brahma SutraSmritiAbout 200 BCE to 400 CE
- Vishnu PuranaSmritiAbout the fourth to fifth century CE
- Devi MahatmyaSmritiIn the Markandeya Purana, fifth to sixth century CE
- Saundarya LahariSmritiAttributed to Shankara, about the eighth century, authorship disputed
- VivekachudamaniSmritiAttributed to Shankara, date and authorship disputed
- Bhaja GovindamSmritiAttributed to Shankara and his disciples, about the eighth century
- Avadhuta GitaSmritiAttributed to Dattatreya, date uncertain
- Ashtavakra GitaSmritiDate disputed, commonly eighth to fourteenth century
- Stories of the BhagavataSmritiFrom the Bhagavata Purana, ninth to tenth century CE
- Yoga VasisthaSmritiThe Kashmiri Mokshopaya about 950 CE, recast later
- Narada Bhakti SutraSmritiDate uncertain
- Shiva PuranaSmritiCompiled about the tenth to fourteenth century
- Shrimad Devi BhagavataSmritiAbout the eleventh to twelfth century
- Lalita SahasranamaSmritiFrom the Brahmanda Purana, date uncertain
- Shiva Mahimna StotraSmritiMedieval, date uncertain
- Tripura RahasyaSmritiAttributed to Haritayana, date uncertain
- Rama GitaSmritiIf from the Adhyatma Ramayana, fourteenth to fifteenth century
- Japji SahibSikhGuru Nanak, about 1500 to 1539 CE
- Asa di VaarSikhGuru Nanak, with saloks of Guru Angad, sixteenth century
- Anand SahibSikhGuru Amar Das, sixteenth century
- RamcharitmanasSmritiTulsidas, in Awadhi, begun 1574 CE
- Vibhishana GitaSmritiAn episode of the Ramcharitmanas, about 1574 CE
- Hanuman ChalisaSmritiTulsidas, late sixteenth century
- Ganesha AtharvashirshaSmritiLate, about the sixteenth to seventeenth century
- Sukhmani SahibSikhGuru Arjan, about 1600 CE
- Adi GranthSikhCompiled 1604 CE
- Salok Mahalla 9SikhGuru Tegh Bahadur, seventeenth century, added to the Granth in 1706 CE
The shelf’s own texts now take their places on the same line, older to newer, each carrying its rank. There is shruti for what the seers heard, smriti for what the tradition remembered and wrote, and a third mark for the Sikh scriptures, a lineage of their own. Beside each stands the century the scholars assign it, or the word uncertain where they assign none.
The shape that emerges
A shape forms out of the list. At the far end stand two hymns of the Samhitas, the Purusha Sukta and the Sri Rudram, the only points reaching back into the age of the fire altar. Then the two old anchors of reflection, the Upanishads and the Gita. After them comes a steady line through the first millennium CE. There are the epics with the teachings folded inside them, the Yoga Sutras, the Brahma Sutra, the Vishnu Purana, the Devi Mahatmya, and the texts that carry Shankara’s name. Then, in the second millennium, the dense thicket: the Puranas of Shiva and of the Devi, the later texts of Advaita, the hymns of bhakti, the Sikh Gurus, and Tulsidas. Even so, the ritual layers reach the shelf only through those two Samhita hymns. There is nothing from the Brahmanas or Aranyakas, nothing from the Vedangas, nothing from Dharmashastra, nothing from Agama-Tantra. This is the tradition’s spine of reflection and devotion.
The second clock
The line laid so far is the clock of ink: it tells when a text was written down. The tradition keeps a second clock, on a scale that turns the first into a single tide mark on the sand. Time in it sits nested, one measure inside the next. A kalpa is one day of Brahma, a thousand mahayugas, which works out to 4.32 billion years. Within a kalpa run fourteen manvantaras, each of seventy-one mahayugas, about 300 million years apiece. The seventh, Vaivasvata, is running now. Each mahayuga is 4.32 million years. Inside it sit the four yugas, Satya, Treta, Dvapara, and Kali, in the proportion four, three, two, one, each shorter than the last. By this reckoning the present falls in the Kali yuga of the twenty-eighth mahayuga of the Vaivasvata manvantara.
Lives measured in yugas
The people of the stories live on this second clock, and their years follow its scale. Valmiki gives Rama a reign of eleven thousand years, at the opening of the Bala Kanda and again at the close of the Yuddha Kanda. Dasharatha, in the second sarga of the Ayodhya Kanda, calls himself sixty thousand years old. These are Treta’s numbers, the tradition’s own count. One figure stretches further than any king. Jambavan, the king of the bears, serves Rama in Treta in Valmiki’s telling. Then, in Dvapara, the same Jambavan grapples with Krishna over the Syamantaka jewel, as the Bhagavata tells it. When the fight ends he gives Krishna the jewel and his daughter Jambavati. One life, by that count, runs from Treta into Dvapara, a stretch the tradition reckons in hundreds of thousands of years.
Beyond the long-lived stand the chiranjivis, whom the tradition holds alive across the yugas: Hanuman, Parashurama, Markandeya, and a few others. Parashurama appears in both epics, in Treta and again in Dvapara. Markandeya saw the dissolution itself, the drowning of the worlds at a kalpa’s end. The Mahabharata tells it in the Vana Parva, in the sections that carry his name, and the Bhagavata again, so his one life touches kalpas. And above them all are Devi, Shiva, and Vishnu, whose age lies outside the count altogether: sanatana, the tradition’s word for what has no beginning and no end.
So how old is the original
Put the question of the original’s age to the clock of ink and it falls silent. It dates the writing, and the writing came last. The second clock answers in the tradition’s own count. Krishna and the Mahabharata war sit a little over five thousand years back, at the mouth of the Kali yuga. Rama sits far behind, in Treta, hundreds of thousands of years deeper. Jambavan’s single life stretches like a bridge across the distance between them. The events these texts tell, by that count, happened in that deep time, long before the ink dried on them.
The two clocks answer different questions and cannot be exchanged for one another, like the four meanings of when. The clock of ink asks when a text was written. The clock of story asks when the events it tells took place. The first runs on the scholars’ philology, the second on the tradition’s yuga arithmetic. One caution holds. Seating events in named yugas is itself a later arrangement. Devdutt Pattanaik says as much. Luis González-Reimann’s The Mahabharata and the Yugas, published by Peter Lang in 2002, traces how the yuga scheme was fitted onto the epic. So read these deep numbers as the tradition’s way of counting, and leave the dates of history to the first clock. The full yuga arithmetic sits with the reckoning of Rama’s years.
Frequently asked questions
Why are these dates not firm?
Because the texts traveled by mouth for centuries before anyone wrote them down. The dates are pieced together from the language and from what the texts say of one another. So every year stays approximate.
Which texts sit at the old and new ends of the shelf?
At the old end, two Samhita hymns, the Purusha Sukta and the Sri Rudram, with the Upanishads close behind. At the new end, the Adi Granth of 1604 and the saloks of Guru Tegh Bahadur, added to the Granth in 1706. Between them the second millennium packs its dense thicket of bhakti and Advaita.
Why do the four meanings of when matter?
Because each answers a different question: when the text was composed, how long it was recited before that, when its own story says its events took place. And the fourth is where the tradition seats those events on the yuga clock. Mix them, and a date of composition starts to look like a verdict on the story, or a yuga number like a date in history.
Keep two clocks in mind together, and before any text ask which one you are consulting. The clock of ink tells when a text was written. On it the shelf runs from a late hymn of the Rigveda to the saloks added to the Guru Granth Sahib in 1706. The clock of story runs on the tradition’s yuga arithmetic. On it the same events sit hundreds of thousands of years back, in deep time. Each is true to its own question, and neither converts into the other.