A map of the canon
Seen from a little height, the canon is a library of palm-leaf bundles laid on stepped shelves, tier above tier, and easy to be lost in. One line, drawn first, sets the whole pile into two parts. Then the territories take their names one by one.
One big line, that first
The line runs between two words. Shruti, that which was heard, is the name of the Veda, which the tradition holds to be eternal and apauruseya, authored by no person, and so the highest authority. Smriti, that which was remembered, is everything the tradition counts as human-made, paurusheya. It keeps what shruti gave and puts it to use. The schools that accept the Veda’s authority are called astika. Those that set it aside are nastika.
Inside the Veda
The Veda is one light divided into four collections. They are the Rigveda, the Samaveda, the Yajurveda, in two branches, the Krishna and the Shukla, each kept in more than one recension, and the Atharvaveda. All four were kept alive in shakhas, the branches of reciters. Most of those branches are now lost, as Witzel shows in The Development of the Vedic Canon and its Schools. Each Veda carries four layers, and they run nearly in order of time: the Samhita, the collection of sukta and mantra. The Brahmana, the prose of the ritual. The Aranyaka, the forest text. And the Upanishad, called Vedanta because it stands at the end of the Veda. The road from rite to liberating knowledge is traveled whole within shruti itself.
The spread of smriti
Smriti is large and open, and each of its families does a different work. The six Vedangas, the limbs of the Veda, include the Kalpa Sutras, which come in four kinds. They are Shrauta for the public sacrifice, Grihya for the rites of the household, Dharma for conduct, Shulba for the geometry of the altar. Itihasa tells what happened: the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, with the Bhagavad Gita seated inside the Mahabharata. The Puranas number eighteen Mahapuranas and eighteen Upapuranas by the tradition’s count. And the Padma Purana, in its Uttara Khanda, sorts the Mahapuranas as sattvika, rajasa and tamasa by whether Vishnu, Brahma or Shiva stands foremost. The codes of Dharmashastra, Manu and Yajnavalkya, set out the law of a life and of a kingdom. The six darshanas each rest on a root text: the sutras of Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Yoga, Mimamsa and Vedanta, and for Samkhya the Samkhya Karika of Ishvarakrishna. Last comes the bhakti of the spoken languages: the Tamil Divya Prabandham, the Ramcharitmanas of Tulsidas, and the Hanuman Chalisa attributed to him.
The parallel stream
A second stream runs beside the first: the Agamas and Tantras, which the tradition pairs with the Vedic Nigama under the name Agama. The temple draws its living liturgy from here: the consecration of images, the daily rite, the festival. The Shaiva Agamas serve the worship of Shiva. The Vaishnava Samhitas of the Pancharatra and Vaikhanasa lines serve Vishnu. The Shakta Tantras serve the Goddess. Two Vedic hymns still sound inside that temple worship, though they are shruti, parts of the Veda itself: the Sri Rudram and Chamakam and the Purusha Sukta.
Separate canons
Some canons stand outside this house altogether. The Buddhist canon is the Tripitaka, with the Mahayana sutras beside it. The Jain canon is its own set of Agamas, sharing only a name with the temple texts. The Sikh canon is the Guru Granth Sahib, first compiled by Guru Arjan as the Adi Granth in 1604.
What makes it one system
Three relationships turn the pile into a system. The first is the four-layer build inside the Veda, Samhita to Upanishad. The second is the Prasthana-trayi, the three points of departure: the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutra and the Gita. It is the shared base from which the classical schools of Vedanta, Shankara’s, Ramanuja’s, Madhva’s, Nimbarka’s and Vallabha’s, argue their readings. It is the bridge by which the Gita, a text of smriti, is read with an authority close to shruti’s own. The third is the pairing of Nigama and Agama, by which the temple’s daily worship runs on the Agama while the Veda stands above it. When each of these was composed is the matter of the canon in time.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between shruti and smriti?
Shruti is the Veda, which the tradition holds to have been heard by the rishis and authored by no person, and so to carry the highest authority. Smriti is everything the tradition counts as human-made, which keeps shruti’s gift and puts it to use.
Is the Gita shruti or smriti?
Smriti. It sits inside the Mahabharata. The Prasthana-trayi then seats it beside the Upanishads and the Brahma Sutra, and the classical schools of Vedanta read it with an authority close to shruti’s own.
What is the relation between the Agamas and the Veda?
The Agamas give the temple its living liturgy, and the tradition pairs them with the Veda as Agama and Nigama. Worship runs on the Agama, and the Veda stays above it as the final authority.
Which are the eighteen Puranas?
The eighteen Mahapuranas are the Vishnu, Bhagavata, Narada, Garuda, Padma, Varaha, Brahma, Brahmanda, Brahmavaivarta, Markandeya, Bhavishya, Vamana, Shiva, Linga, Skanda, Agni, Matsya and Kurma. The Padma Purana, in its Uttara Khanda, sorts them as sattvika, rajasa and tamasa by whether Vishnu, Brahma or Shiva stands foremost. Some lists, such as the Matsya Purana, count the Vayu Purana in place of the Shiva. The tradition counts eighteen Upapuranas as well.
Pick any bundle from those shelves, and two questions place it. Which stream does it belong to: shruti, smriti, agama, or a canon of its own? And from which layer or family within that stream does it come? Answer both, and the text’s rank, its authority and the company it keeps come into view together, before a line of it is read.