The thirteen forms of truth: Yudhishthira’s question and Bhishma’s answer
Bhishma had been speaking of penance: that everything has it for a root, that the Creator made this universe by it. He had said that the rishis won the Vedas by it and the gods their high place. Yudhishthira let that teaching rest and turned to something else that is praised wherever the wise gather. “Brahmins and rishis, the ancestors and the gods all applaud the duty of truth,” he said. “I want to hear about truth, grandfather. Speak to me of it. What are the marks of truth? How is it to be acquired? What is gained by practicing it, and how? Tell me all of this.”
Bhishma said, “A confusion of the duties of the four orders is never praised. What is called truth lives pure and unmixed in every one of those four orders. For the good, truth is always a duty. It is an eternal duty. One should bow to truth with reverence. Truth is the highest refuge of all. Truth is duty, truth is penance, truth is yoga, and truth is the eternal Brahman. Truth has been called a sacrifice of a high order, and everything rests on truth. I will tell you now the forms of truth one after another, and its marks in their order, and you should hear as well how truth may be acquired.”
“Truth as it exists through all the world is of thirteen kinds. The forms it takes are impartiality, self-control, forgiveness, modesty, endurance, goodness, renunciation, contemplation, dignity, fortitude, compassion, and abstention from injury. These are the thirteen forms of truth. Truth is immutable, eternal, and unchangeable. It may be acquired through practices that are at war with none of the other virtues, and it may be acquired through yoga.”
“Suppose desire and aversion, and lust and anger, have been destroyed. Then a man can look with an unchanging eye on himself and on his enemy, on his own good and on his own harm. The quality by which he can look this way is called impartiality. Self-control lies in never wishing for what belongs to another man, and in gravity and patience. It lies in being able to quiet the fears that others have of oneself, and in freedom from disease. It may be acquired through knowledge. Devotion to the practice of generosity, together with the keeping of every duty, is what the wise call goodwill. A man comes to have goodwill toward all through constant devotion to truth.”
“The quality by which a good and esteemed man bears what is agreeable and what is disagreeable alike is called forgiveness. It is well acquired through the practice of truthfulness. The virtue by which an intelligent man, contented in mind and speech, does many good deeds and never draws the censure of others is called modesty. It is acquired with the help of righteousness. The virtue that forgives for the sake of dharma and profit is called endurance. It is a form of forgiveness, it is acquired through patience, and its purpose is to attach people to oneself. The casting off of affection, and of all earthly possessions with it, is called renunciation. Renunciation can never be acquired by anyone who has anger and malice still in him.”
“The virtue by which a man does good to all creatures, with watchfulness and care, is called goodness. It has no particular shape, and it consists in putting off all selfish attachments. The virtue by which a man stays unchanged in happiness and in misery is called fortitude. The wise man who wants his own good always practices it. One should always practice forgiveness and devotion to truth. The wise man who succeeds in casting off joy and fear and anger succeeds in acquiring fortitude. Abstention from injury toward all creatures in thought, word, and deed, and kindness, and gift, are the eternal duties of the good. These thirteen attributes look distinct from one another, and they have one and the same form, which is truth. All of them support truth and strengthen it.”
“It is impossible to exhaust the merits of truth, and it is for these reasons that the Brahmins, the ancestors, and the gods applaud it. There is no duty higher than truth, and no sin more heinous than untruth. Truth is the very foundation of righteousness, and for that reason one should never destroy it. From truth come gifts, and sacrifice with its presents, and the threefold agnihotra, and the Vedas, and everything else that leads to righteousness. Once a thousand horse sacrifices and truth were weighed against each other in the balance, and truth proved the heavier.”
The thirteen faults: anger, desire, and their kin
From the virtues Yudhishthira went to their enemies. “Tell me, grandfather, in your great wisdom, everything about the source of anger and of lust, of sorrow and loss of judgment, and of the inclination to do harm. Tell me of the source of jealousy and malice and pride, of envy, of slander, of the inability to bear another’s good, of unkindness, and of fear. Tell me about all of these, truly and in detail.”
Bhishma said, “These thirteen vices are held to be very powerful enemies of all creatures. They come at men and tempt them from every side. They goad and torment the man who is heedless or dull. The moment they see a person they fall on him with force, like wolves leaping on their prey. From them comes every kind of grief, and from them comes every kind of sin, and every mortal should know it always. I will tell you where they begin, what they rest on, and how they are destroyed. Listen first, with your whole attention, to the origin of anger.”
“Anger springs from covetousness. It is fed by the faults of others. Through forgiveness it lies dormant, and through forgiveness it disappears. Lust springs from resolve. Indulgence strengthens it, and when a wise man turns resolutely away from it, it disappears and dies. Envy of others comes from between anger and covetousness. It disappears through compassion and knowledge of the self, through compassion for all creatures and the disregard for worldly things that knowledge brings with it. It rises too from seeing the faults of other people, and in the intelligent it quickly disappears before true knowledge. Loss of judgment has its origin in ignorance and comes from sinful habit. When the man it has seized begins to take delight in the company of the wise, that vice hides its head at once.”
“Men see scriptures that conflict with one another, and from that springs the desire for many kinds of action. When true knowledge has been gained, that desire is quieted. The grief of an embodied creature comes from affection awakened by separation, and it subsides when a man learns that the dead do not return. The inability to bear another’s good comes from anger and covetousness. It is extinguished through compassion for every creature and a disregard for all earthly things. Malice comes from the abandonment of truth and from indulgence in wickedness. That vice disappears when a man waits on the wise and the good.”
“Pride in men springs from birth, from learning, and from prosperity. When those three are truly understood, the vice disappears instantly. Jealousy springs from lust and from delight in low and vulgar people, and wisdom destroys it. Slander takes its rise from errors of conduct that go against the ordinary course of men, and from disagreeable speeches that express aversion. It disappears on a survey of the whole world. When the one who injures is powerful and the injured one is unable to avenge the injury, hate shows itself, and kindliness makes it subside. Compassion comes from the sight of the helpless and miserable people of whom the world is full. That feeling too disappears when a man understands the strength of virtue. Covetousness in all creatures springs from ignorance, and it is destroyed by the sight of how unstable every object of enjoyment is. It has been said that tranquility of soul, and that alone, can subdue all thirteen of these faults. All thirteen stained the sons of Dhritarashtra. You have always desired truth, and through your regard for your elders you have conquered every one of them.”
The marks of the malevolent man
Yudhishthira said, “I know what benevolence is, because I have watched those who are good. The malevolent I do not know, grandfather, or the nature of what they do. People keep away from malevolent men of cruel deeds as they keep away from thorns and pitfalls and fire. And it is plain that the malevolent man is sure to burn with misery, here and hereafter. So tell me what, in truth, the acts of such a man are.”
Bhishma said, “Malevolent men always do wicked acts and feel an inclination to do them that they cannot resist. They slander others and bring disgrace on themselves. They always think they have been cheated of what is due to them. A malevolent man brags of his own acts of charity. He looks at others with malicious eyes. He is very mean. He is deceitful and full of cunning, and he never gives others what is theirs. He is arrogant. He keeps evil company and is always boasting. He fears and suspects everyone he comes into contact with. His understanding is foolish. He practices miserliness, and he praises his own associates. He cherishes a hatred beyond all measure for every recluse who has retired into the woods.”
“He takes delight in injuring others. He cares nothing for telling the merits of others from their faults. He is full of lies, he is discontented, he is greedy beyond measure, and he always acts cruelly. Such a man looks on a virtuous and accomplished person as a pest, and thinking everybody else is like himself he never trusts anyone. He proclaims the faults of other people, however little anyone had suspected them. Of faults like those that stain himself he says nothing, even from afar, for the sake of the advantage he gets from them. He takes the man who does him good for a simpleton he has cleverly deceived. And he is filled with regret that he ever made any gift of wealth, even to one who had helped him.”
“Know for a malevolent and wicked man the one who quietly and alone takes food and drink and other things that are counted choice. He takes them while people are standing by with longing eyes. Suppose a man gives the first portion to Brahmins, and takes what remains, and divides that with his friends and kinsmen. Then he comes to great happiness in the next world and to endless happiness here. I have told you now what the marks of the wicked and malevolent man are. A wise man should always keep away from him.”
The dharma of gift, of officiating, and of atonement
Bhishma went on without waiting for a question. “There are Brahmins who are pious and poor, who have been robbed of what they had, who are engaged in sacrifices. They know all the Vedas well, and they want the merit of righteousness. Wealth and knowledge should be given to them. That way such men can discharge what they owe to their teachers and to the ancestors, and pass their days in reciting and studying the scriptures. To Brahmins who are not poor, the dakshina alone should be given. To those who have fallen from the status of a Brahmin through their sinful deeds, uncooked food should be given outside the limits of the sacrificial altar. The Brahmins are the Vedas themselves, and they are all the sacrifices with their large presents. Wishing to excel one another, and moved by their virtuous inclinations, they are always performing sacrifices. So the king should make them presents of valuable wealth of many kinds.”
“The Brahmin who has stores enough to feed his family for three years or more deserves to drink the soma. Now suppose a virtuous king is on the throne. Suppose a sacrifice someone has begun, a Brahmin above all, cannot be completed for want of a mere fourth part of its estimated cost. To complete that sacrifice the king should take the wealth of a Vaishya who owns a large herd of cattle. That Vaishya is averse to sacrifices and never drinks the soma. The king should take it from the man’s kinsmen. The Shudra has no competence to perform a sacrifice, so for such a purpose the king should take wealth from a Shudra’s house. Without any scruple he should also take, from the kinsmen, the wealth of the man who owns a hundred cattle and performs no sacrifices. The king should take the wealth of the man who owns a thousand and abstains from them. The king should always take away, and take publicly, the wealth of a man who practices no charity, and by acting so he earns great merit.”
“Listen to me again. Suppose want has forced a Brahmin to go without six meals. Then he may take without permission, by the rule of one who cares for today and gives no thought to tomorrow, exactly what he needs for a single meal. He may take it from the husking tub, from the field, from the garden, or from any other place, even from a man of low pursuits. He should, though, asked or unasked, tell the king what he has done. A king who knows his duty should inflict no punishment on such a Brahmin. He should remember that a Brahmin comes to hunger only through the fault of the Kshatriya. Once he has learned the Brahmin’s learning and conduct, the king should make provision for him and protect him as a father protects the son of his own body. At the end of every year one should perform the Vaishvanara sacrifice. Those who know religion say that to follow an act laid down as the alternative does not destroy virtue. The Vishvedevas, the Sadhyas, the Brahmins, and the great rishis fear death in seasons of distress. They do not hesitate to fall back on the provisions the scriptures lay down as alternatives. The man who is able to live by the primary provision and takes to the alternative anyway comes to be counted a wicked man. He never wins any happiness in heaven.”
“A Brahmin who knows the Vedas should never speak to the king of his own energy and knowledge. Set the energy of a Brahmin beside that of a king. The Brahmin’s will always be found the greater. For that reason a king can hardly bear it or resist it. The Brahmin is said to be creator, ruler, ordainer, and god. No word of abuse and no dry speech should ever be addressed to him. The Kshatriya should cross all his difficulties by the might of his arms. The Vaishya and the Shudra should overcome theirs by wealth, and the Brahmin by mantras and by homa. A maiden, a young woman, a person who does not know the mantras, an ignorant person, or one who is impure: none of these is competent to pour libations on the sacrificial fire. If any of them does so, he or she is sure to fall into hell together with the one for whom the rite was done. So no one except a Brahmin who knows the Vedas and is skilled in all sacrifices should pour the sacrificial libations. Suppose a man kindles the sacrificial fire and does not give away the dedicated food as dakshina. Those who know the scriptures say that he has not kindled a sacrificial fire at all. A man should do every act of merit with his senses under control and with proper devotion. He should never worship the gods in sacrifices in which no dakshina is given. A sacrifice left incomplete for want of dakshina destroys a man’s children, his animals, and his heaven. It destroys his senses, his fame, his achievements, and the very span of his life.”
“Brahmins who lie with women in their season, or who never perform sacrifices, or whose families have no member who knows the Vedas, are counted Shudras in act. The Brahmin who marries a Shudra girl and lives for twelve unbroken years in a village that has a well alone for its water becomes a Shudra in act. Suppose a Brahmin calls an unmarried maiden to his bed, or lets a Shudra sit on the same carpet with him, thinking the man worthy of respect. Then he should sit on a bed of dry grass behind some Kshatriya or Vaishya and pay him respect in that fashion. So he is cleansed. A Brahmin may sin in a single night by respectfully serving a member of a lower order. Or he may sin by sporting with him in the same spot or on the same bed. That sin is cleansed by three unbroken years of sitting so, on dry grass, behind a Kshatriya or a Vaishya. A falsehood spoken in jest is no sin. No more is one spoken to a woman, or at a marriage, or for the benefit of one’s teacher, or to save one’s own life. These five kinds of falsehood, it is said, are sinless. Useful knowledge may be learned, with devotion and reverence, even from a person of low pursuits. Gold may be picked up without scruple even from an unclean place. A woman who is the ornament of her sex may be taken as a wife even from a base family. Nectar, if it can be drawn from poison, may be drunk. Women, jewels and other valuables, and water can never, by the scriptures, be impure or unclean. And for the benefit of Brahmins and of cattle, and when the castes are being confounded, even a Vaishya may take up weapons for his own safety.”
“Drinking liquor, killing a Brahmin, and the violation of a teacher’s bed are sins that, when committed knowingly, have no expiation. The one expiation laid down for them is death. The same may be said of stealing gold and of the theft of a Brahmin’s property. By drinking liquor, by union with one with whom union is forbidden, and by mingling with a fallen person, a man inevitably becomes fallen. A man of the other three orders becomes fallen by union with a Brahmin woman. A man becomes fallen by keeping company with a fallen person for one whole year in such matters as officiating at sacrifices, teaching, and sexual union. He does not become so by riding in the same vehicle, sitting on the same seat, or eating in the same line. Setting aside the five grave sins I have named, every other sin has an expiation provided for it. A man who has expiated his sins by the proper ordinance should never fall into them again. Suppose men guilty of the first three of those five die. Then their surviving kinsmen are under no restriction about taking food and wearing ornaments, even if the funeral rites remain unperformed. They need have no scruple about it. In keeping his own duties a virtuous man should cast off even his friends and his revered elders. Until such sinners perform their expiation, the virtuous should not so much as talk with them. A man who has acted sinfully destroys his sin by acting virtuously afterward and by penance. By calling a thief a thief, one incurs the sin of theft, and by calling a thief one who is no thief, one incurs a sin just double that. A maiden who lets her virginity be taken incurs three-fourths of the sin of killing a Brahmin. The man who takes it incurs a sin equal to a fourth part of that. By slandering Brahmins or striking them a man sinks in infamy for a hundred years. By killing a Brahmin he sinks into hell for a thousand. So no one should speak ill of a Brahmin or kill one. Suppose someone strikes a Brahmin with a weapon. Then he will have to live in hell for as many years as there are grains of dust soaked by the blood that flows from the wound.”
“One guilty of the killing of an unborn child is cleansed if he dies of wounds received in a battle fought for the sake of cattle and Brahmins. Or he may be cleansed by casting himself on a blazing fire. A drinker of liquor is cleansed by drinking liquor boiling hot. His body is burned by that drink, and through his death he is cleansed in the other world. For the violation of a teacher’s bed the sinner is cleansed by the death that comes of embracing a heated female figure of iron. Or, having mutilated himself, he should walk in a straight line toward the southwest until he casts off his life. Or he may wash off his sin by meeting death for the benefit of a Brahmin. Or, after performing a horse sacrifice, or a cow sacrifice, or an agnishtoma, he may regain esteem here and hereafter. The killer of a Brahmin should keep the vow of brahmacharya for twelve years and wander as an ascetic, devoted to penance. He should hold the skull of the slain in his hands all that time and proclaim his sin to everyone. The same is laid down for the man who kills a woman with child, knowing her condition, and such a man incurs double the sin of killing a Brahmin. A drinker of liquor should live on frugal fare, keep the vows of brahmacharya, and sleep on the bare ground. He should perform for more than three years the sacrifice next to the agnishtoma. Then he should give away a thousand cattle with one bull. One who has killed a Vaishya should perform such a sacrifice for two years and give a hundred cattle with one bull. One who has killed a Shudra should perform it for one year, with the same gift. The killing of a dog, a bear, or a camel carries the Shudra’s penance. For killing a cat, a chasa, a frog, a crow, a reptile, or a rat, it is said, one incurs the sin of animal slaughter. For every minor sin a man should repent, or keep some vow for one year. For union with the wife of a Brahmin who knows the Vedas, three years of brahmacharya, eating a little at the fourth part of the day. For union with any other woman who is not his wife, two years. For taking pleasure in a woman’s company on the same spot or the same seat, three days on water alone. The same for one who fouls a blazing fire. Whoever casts off his father or mother or teacher without good cause surely becomes fallen. To a wife guilty of adultery, or to one confined in prison, food and clothes alone should be given. The vows laid down for a man guilty of adultery should be laid on a woman guilty of the same. Suppose a woman abandons a husband of higher caste for a man of a lower order. The king should have her devoured by dogs in a public place before a great crowd. A wise king should have the man burned on a heated bed of iron. The sinner who performs no expiation within a year of his sin incurs double its demerit. One who keeps company with such a person for two years must wander the earth in penance, living on alms. One who does so for four years must live that way for five. If a younger brother weds before his elder, the younger brother, the elder, and the woman all become fallen. All three should keep the vows prescribed for one who has neglected his sacrificial fire, or the chandrayana vow for a month, or some other painful vow. The younger should give his wife to the unmarried elder, and afterward, with the elder’s permission, take her back, and so all three are cleansed. The slayer of animals, the cow excepted, is not stained, for the learned know that man has dominion over the lower animals. A sinner should go about holding a yak tail and a clay pot, proclaiming his sin, and beg each day of seven families alone and live on what they give. In twelve days he is cleansed. One unable to carry the yak tail should keep that vow of begging for a whole year. Among men this is the best expiation. For those who are able, charity is laid down in all such cases. Those who have faith and virtue may cleanse themselves by giving away a single cow. Suppose someone eats or drinks the flesh, ordure, or urine of a dog, a boar, a man, a cock, or a camel. Then he must have his investiture with the sacred thread performed again. Suppose a soma-drinking Brahmin breathes the smell of liquor from the mouth of one who has drunk it. Then he should drink warm water for three days, or warm milk for the same time. Or he should drink warm water for three days and then live for as long on air alone. These are the eternal injunctions for the expiation of sin. They are meant above all for a Brahmin who has committed these sins through ignorance and want of judgment.”
Nakula’s question: the origin of the sword and the tale of the Asi
When that discourse was finished it was Nakula, Yudhishthira’s younger brother and a son of Madri, who spoke, and Nakula was an accomplished swordsman. He put his question to the Kuru grandsire where he lay on his bed of arrows. “The bow, grandfather, is held to be the first of weapons in this world. My own mind leans toward the sword. Suppose the bow is cut or broken, and the horses are dead or spent. Then a good warrior who has been well trained in the sword can still protect himself with it. A hero with a sword in his hand can stand alone against many bowmen, and against many who come at him with maces and darts. I have this doubt, and I am curious to know the truth. Which is really the first of weapons in all battles? How was the sword first created, and for what purpose? And who was the first teacher of the weapon? Tell me all of this.”
Bhishma was a complete master of the science of the bow. It was a pupil of Drona, a skillfully trained fighter, who had asked him. He answered Madri’s clever son from the arrows in graceful and well-chosen words, every vowel in its place. “Hear the truth of what you have asked me, Nakula. Your question has stirred me, and I am like a hill of red chalk. In ancient times the universe was one vast expanse of water, motionless and skyless, with no earth holding any place in it. It was wrapped in darkness, it could not be touched, and its look was dreadful. Utter silence lay over all of it, and it stretched beyond measure. In his own proper time the Grandsire of the universe took birth. He created the wind and fire, and the blazing sun. He created the sky, the heavens, the nether regions, the earth, the directions, and the firmament with its moon and stars. He created the constellations, the planets, the year, the seasons, the months, the two fortnights, bright and dark, and the smaller divisions of time.”
“Then the divine Grandsire took a visible form and by the power of his will begot powerful sons. They were the sages Marichi, Atri, Pulastya, Pulaha, Kratu, Vasishtha, and Angiras, and the mighty lord Rudra, and Prachetas. Prachetas begot Daksha, and Daksha in his turn begot sixty daughters, and the Brahmin sages took all those daughters to raise children by them. From them sprang all the creatures of the universe: the gods, the ancestors, Gandharvas, Apsaras, and Rakshasas of many kinds. From them sprang birds and beasts and fishes, monkeys, great snakes, and the many sorts of fowl that range the air or sport on the water. From them sprang the plants, and every being born from an egg, from a womb, or from filth. So the whole universe of moving and unmoving creatures came into existence. When he had called them all into being, the universal Grandsire proclaimed the eternal religion laid down in the Vedas. It was accepted by the gods with their teachers and priests, by the Adityas, the Vasus, the Rudras, the Sadhyas, the Maruts, and the Ashvins. It was accepted by Bhrigu, Atri, and Angiras, by the Siddhas, by Kashyapa rich in penances, by Vasishtha, Gautama, Agastya, Narada, and Parvata. It was accepted by the Valikhilya rishis, and by those other rishis known as the Prabhasas, the Sikatas, the Ghritapas, and the Somavayavyas. It was accepted by the Vaishvanaras, the Marichipas, the Akrishtas, the Hamsas, those born of fire, the Vanaprasthas, and the Prashnis. All of them lived in obedience to Brahma.”
“The chiefs of the Danavas, though, set the Grandsire’s commands at naught. Giving way to anger and covetousness, they began to bring about the destruction of righteousness. They were Hiranyakashipu and Hiranyaksha, Virochana and Shambara, Viprachitti, Prahlada, Namuchi, and Bali. These and many other Daityas and Danavas overstepped every restraint of duty and religion and amused themselves with wicked acts of all kinds. Holding themselves equal to the gods in birth, they began to challenge the gods and the sages of pure conduct. They never did any good to the other creatures of the universe and never showed compassion for any of them. Passing over the three well-known means, they set about persecuting and afflicting all creatures with the rod of punishment alone. Swollen with pride, those Asuras gave up every friendly dealing with other beings.”
“Then the divine Brahma, with the Brahmin sages around him, went to a delightful summit of Himavat. It stretched a hundred yojanas, it was adorned with jewels and gems of many kinds. The stars seemed to rest on its surface like lotuses on a lake. On that prince of mountains, covered with forests of flowering trees, he stayed for a time to attend to the business of the world. When a thousand years had passed, the lord made ready a grand sacrifice by the ordinances of the scriptures. The altar was crowded with rishis skilled in sacrifice and able to perform every part of it, with bundles of sacrificial fuel, and with blazing fires. It shone with plates and vessels that were all of gold. The first among the gods took their seats on it, and the members of the assembly who sat about the platform were all high rishis. I have heard from the rishis that something very dreadful soon happened in that sacrifice. A creature sprang up out of the sacrificial fire, they say, scattering the flames around him. His splendor was that of the moon when it rises in a sky strewn with stars. His color was dark, like the petals of the blue lotus. His teeth were sharp, his belly was lean, his stature was tall, and he seemed irresistible and full of exceeding energy. When that being appeared, the earth trembled. The ocean was stirred into high waves and dreadful whirlpools. Meteors that foretold great disasters shot through the sky, and the branches of trees began to fall. Every quarter of the compass grew unquiet, ill-omened winds began to blow, and all creatures quaked with fear from moment to moment. Seeing that dreadful agitation of the universe, and the being who had sprung from the fire, the Grandsire spoke to the great rishis, the gods, and the Gandharvas. ‘I thought of this being. He has great energy, and his name is Asi. I have created him for the protection of the world and the destruction of the enemies of the gods.’”
“Then that being put off the form he had first taken and became a sword, splendid, highly polished, sharp-edged, risen like the all-destroying one at the end of the yuga. Brahma made that sharp weapon over to Rudra of the blue throat, who carries the bull on his banner, so that he could put down irreligion and sin. The divine Rudra, while the great rishis praised him, took up the sword and assumed a different shape. He put out four arms. He grew so tall that, standing on the earth, he touched the very sun with his head. With his eyes turned upward and every limb stretched wide he began to pour flames of fire from his mouth. He took on many colors, blue and white and red. He wore a black deerskin studded with stars of gold. On his forehead he bore a third eye that shone like the sun, while his two other eyes, one black and one tawny, blazed very brightly. So Mahadeva, bearer of the trident, who tore out the eyes of Bhaga, lifted the sword whose splendor was that of the fire at the end of the yuga. With it he lifted a great shield with three high bosses, like a mass of dark cloud lit by flashes of lightning. He began to go through the figures of the swordsman. He whirled the blade in the sky, wanting an encounter. His roars were loud and the sound of his laughter was dreadful. The Danavas heard that Rudra had taken that form to do fierce deeds, and they were filled with joy. They came at him at great speed. They showered huge rocks on him as they came, and blazing brands of wood, and terrible weapons of iron, each with the sharpness of a razor. And then the Danava host saw him, the indestructible Rudra swelling with might, and it was stupefied and began to tremble.”
“Rudra was alone, and he moved over the field so quickly, sword in hand, that the Asuras believed a thousand Rudras were fighting them. Tearing, piercing, cutting, lopping, and grinding down, the great god went through the thick masses of his enemies like a forest fire through heaps of dry grass. The mighty Asuras, broken by the whirling of his sword, fell to the earth with arms and thighs and chests cut through and heads struck from their trunks. Others broke under the strokes and fled in every direction, calling out to hearten one another as they ran. Some went down into the bowels of the earth. Some got under the cover of mountains. Some went upward, and some entered the depths of the sea. As that fierce battle went on, the earth turned to a mire of flesh and blood, and horrible sights lay on every side. Strewn with the fallen bodies of Danavas covered in blood, the ground looked as though mountain peaks overgrown with kinshuka trees had been scattered across it. Drenched with gore, the earth looked like a fair woman, flushed with wine, dressed in crimson robes. When he had killed the Danavas and set righteousness up again on earth, Rudra put off his dreadful form and took his own kindly shape. All the rishis and all the gods adored that god of gods with loud shouts wishing him victory.”
“After this the divine Rudra gave the sword, that protector of religion, still dyed with the blood of the Danavas, to Vishnu, with due reverence. Vishnu gave it to Marichi. The divine Marichi gave it to all the great rishis. They gave it to Vasava, and Vasava gave it to the Regents of the world. The Regents gave that great sword to Manu, the son of Surya, and when they gave it they said to him, ‘You are the lord of all men. Protect all creatures with this sword, which holds religion in its womb. Those who break through the barriers of virtue, for the sake of the body or of the mind, are to be duly punished. Protection is to be given by the ordinances and never by caprice. Some should be punished with rebukes in words, and with fines and forfeitures. Loss of limb or death should never be inflicted for slight reasons. These punishments, with the rebuke in words as their first, are counted so many forms of the sword. They are the shapes the sword takes in answer to the transgressions of those under the king’s protection.’”
“In time Manu installed his own son Kshupa in the sovereignty of all creatures and gave him the sword for their protection. From Kshupa it was taken by Ikshvaku, and from Ikshvaku by Pururavas. From Pururavas it was taken by Ayus, and from Ayus by Nahusha. From Nahusha it was taken by Yayati, and from Yayati by Puru. From Puru it was taken by Amurtaraya, and from Amurtaraya it came down to the royal Bhumishaya. From Bhumishaya it was taken by Bharata, the son of Dushyanta, and from Bharata by the righteous Ailavila. From Ailavila it was taken by King Dhundhumara, from Dhundhumara by Kamboja, and from Kamboja by Muchukunda. From Muchukunda it was taken by Marutta, and from Marutta by Raivata. From Raivata it was taken by Yuvanashva, and from Yuvanashva by Raghu. From Raghu it was taken by the valiant Harinashva, from Harinashva by Shunaka, and from Shunaka by the righteous Ushinara. From Ushinara it was taken by the Bhojas and the Yadavas. From the Yadus it was taken by Shibi, and from Shibi it came down to Pratardana. From Pratardana it was received by Ashtaka, and from Ashtaka by Prishadashva. From Prishadashva it was received by Bharadvaja, and from Bharadvaja by Drona. After Drona it was taken by Kripa. And from Kripa that sword, the finest there is, has come to you and to your brothers.”
“The constellation under which the sword was born is Krittika. Agni is its deity, Rohini is its family, and Rudra is its high teacher. The sword has eight names that are not generally known. I will tell them to you. They are Asi, Vaishasana, Khadga, the sharp-edged, the hard to win, Shrigarbha, victory, and protector of righteousness. Of all weapons, Nakula, the sword stands first, and the Puranas truly declare that Mahadeva was the first to wield it. As for the bow, it was Prithu who first made it. With that weapon the son of Vena, who governed the earth virtuously for many years, milked her of crops and grain in abundance. You should take what the rishis have said as conclusive proof. Everyone skilled in battle should worship the sword. I have told you truly and in detail the first part of what you asked, the origin and creation of the sword.”
Dharma, wealth, and pleasure: the brothers’ debate
Bhishma fell silent after that, and Yudhishthira and the others went home. There the king turned to his four brothers, and to Vidura, their wise uncle, who made a fifth among them, and gave them a question of his own. “The course of the world rests on dharma, wealth, and pleasure. Of these three, which stands first in importance, which second, and which last? And to master the other three, lust, anger, and covetousness, on which of the first three should the mind be fixed? I want each of you to answer gladly, and in words that are true.”
Vidura spoke first. He knew the science of profit and the way the world goes. He knew the truth of things. His mind was brilliant, and he answered out of his memory of the scriptures. “Study of the various scriptures, austerity, gift, faith, the performance of sacrifices, forgiveness, sincerity, compassion, truth, and self-restraint: these are the possessions of dharma. Take dharma for your own, and never let your heart turn away from it. Dharma and profit both have their roots in these, and I think all of them can be gathered under the one word. It is by dharma that the rishis crossed the world and its difficulties. It is on dharma that all the worlds depend. It is by dharma that the gods came to their high position, and it is on dharma that profit rests. Dharma stands first in merit. Profit is said to be the middle one. Pleasure, the wise say, is the lowest of the three. So a man should live with his soul restrained and give his attention to dharma most. He should behave toward all creatures as he would toward himself.”
When Vidura had finished, Arjuna took it up. Pritha’s son was well versed in the science of profit and knew the truths of dharma as well. The drift of the king’s question carried him. “This world is the field of action, and so action is what is praised here. Farming, trade, the keeping of cattle, and the many arts make up what is called profit, and profit is the end of all such acts. Without profit neither dharma nor the objects of desire can be won. This is the declaration of the shruti. Even men of uncleansed soul, once they have wealth of many kinds, can perform the highest acts of dharma and satisfy desires that look impossible to satisfy. Dharma and pleasure are the limbs of wealth, as the shruti declares, and when wealth is won, both can be won. As all creatures worship Brahma, men of high birth themselves wait on a man who has wealth. There are those who dress in deerskins and wear matted locks, who are self-restrained, who smear their bodies with mud and keep their senses under complete control. There are those with shaven heads who are devoted celibates and live apart from one another. All of them cherish a desire for wealth. Others in yellow robes, with long beards, graced with modesty, learned, contented, and freed from all attachments, come to desire wealth. Others who follow the practices of their ancestors and keep their own duties, and others who want heaven, do the same. Believers and unbelievers, and those who are strict practitioners of the highest yoga, all testify to the excellence of wealth. That man is said to be truly wealthy who cherishes his dependents with things to enjoy and afflicts his enemies with punishments. This is truly my opinion. Listen now to these two, who are about to speak.”
The two were Madri’s sons, Nakula and Sahadeva, and they spoke together. “Sitting or lying, walking or standing, a man should strive for wealth, even by the most vigorous means. Wealth is hard to get and very pleasant to have, and once it is earned the one who earned it is seen, without doubt, to obtain everything he desires. Wealth that is joined to dharma, and dharma that is joined to wealth, are certainly like nectar. So our opinion is this. A man with no wealth cannot satisfy any desire, and in the same way no wealth comes to one who has no dharma. The man who stands outside both dharma and wealth is therefore an object of fear to the world. A man should seek wealth with a devoted mind, then, and never disregard what dharma requires. Those who believe this saying get whatever they desire. One should first practice dharma. Next one should acquire wealth without sacrificing dharma. Then one should seek the satisfaction of desire, for that is the last act of a man who has succeeded in getting wealth.”
The twin sons of the Ashvins fell silent, and Bhimasena began. “A man without desire never wishes for wealth. A man without desire never wishes for dharma. One who has no desire in him cannot feel any wish at all, and for that reason desire is the first of the three. It is under the sway of desire that the rishis themselves give their lives to penance, living on fruits, or on roots, or on air alone. Others who have Vedic learning are busy with the Vedas and their branches, or with rites of faith and acts of sacrifice, or with making gifts and accepting them. Traders, farmers, keepers of cattle, artists and artisans, and those who are employed in rites of propitiation all act from desire. There are some who dive to the depths of the ocean, and desire sends them. Desire takes many forms, and everything is pervaded by it. A man outside the reach of desire is not seen in this world, never was, and never will be. This is the truth. Dharma and wealth are both founded on desire. As butter is the essence of curds, desire is the essence of profit and dharma. Oil is better than oil seeds. Ghee is better than sour milk. Flowers and fruits are better than wood. In the same way desire is better than dharma and profit. As honey is drawn out of flowers, desire is said to be drawn out of those two. Desire is the parent of dharma and profit, and desire is their soul. Without desire the Brahmins would never give sweets or wealth to Brahmins. Without desire the many kinds of action seen in the world would never have been seen.”
“For these reasons desire is seen to be the first of the three,” he said, and he went further. “Go to beautiful women dressed in fine robes, wearing every ornament, and merry with sweet wines, and take your pleasure with them. Desire should be the first of the three with us. I have thought the question through to its roots and this is where I have come out, so do not hesitate to accept it, Yudhishthira. These words of mine are no hollow thing. There is righteousness in them, and all good men will accept them. Dharma, profit, and desire should all be attended to equally. The man who gives himself to one of them alone is certainly no superior person. The one who gives himself to two is called middling. And the one who attends to all three stands highest of his kind.” Bhima said this to those heroes in brief and at length. Wise, with his friends around him, his body smeared with sandal paste, garlands and ornaments on him, he fell silent.
King Yudhishthira the just, a man of great learning, thought for a while about what each of them had said. He judged all of it false philosophy. Then he spoke. “There is no doubt that all of you have settled conclusions about the scriptures, and all of you know the authorities. I have heard what you said, and you said it with certainty. Now listen to me with your whole attention. Suppose a man is engaged neither in merit nor in sin, and attends to neither profit nor dharma nor desire. Suppose he is above all faults, and looks on gold and on a lump of brick with the same eye. Then he is freed from pleasure and pain and from the need to accomplish his purposes. All creatures are subject to birth and death. All of them are liable to waste and change. Awakened again and again by the benefits and the evils of life, every one of them praises liberation. We do not know, though, what liberation is.”
“The self-born and divine Brahma has said that there is no liberation for the one who is bound by ties of attachment and affection. Those who have learning seek nirvana. For that reason one should never look on anything as agreeable or as disagreeable, and this view seems the best. No one in this world can act as he pleases. I act exactly as I am made to act. The great Ordainer makes all creatures go as he wills. The Ordainer is supreme. Know this, all of you. No one can obtain by his acts what is not to be obtained, and what is to be, comes to pass. Know this too. And since the one who has withdrawn himself from the three aims may succeed in winning liberation, it seems that liberation produces the highest good.” Bhima and the others heard these words, full of reason and welcome to the heart, and they were delighted. They joined their hands and bowed to that prince of the Kurus. They praised a speech so well made, sweet in its letters and syllables and free of any harsh sound. Yudhishthira, the son of Dharma, praised his listeners, now convinced, in return. And then once more the king went to the son of Ganga, to ask about duties.
The dharma of friendship: with whom to be friends, with whom not
Back beside the grandsire, Yudhishthira asked about friends. “Grandfather, you who have such wisdom, I have a question, and I ask you to speak on it fully. What kind of men are said to be of gentle disposition? With whom may the most delightful friendship exist? Tell us too who are able to do us good now and in the end. It is my opinion that swelling wealth, relatives, and kinsmen do not hold the place that well-wishing friends hold. A friend who can listen to good counsel, and who can also do good, is exceedingly rare. Speak to me fully on all of this.”
Bhishma said, “Listen, Yudhishthira, and I will tell you in detail of the men with whom friendships may be formed and those with whom they may never be. One who is covetous, one who is pitiless, one who has given up the duties of his order, one who is dishonest, and a knave: all these should be avoided. So should a mean man, a man of sinful practices, one who suspects everybody, one who is idle, one who puts things off, and one of crooked disposition. The same is true of one whom everybody reviles, one who dishonors his teacher, one given to the seven well-known vices, and one who casts off friends in their distress. There is also one with a wicked soul, one who is shameless, one whose eyes are always on sin, an atheist, and a slanderer of the Vedas. Then come one whose senses are unrestrained, one who gives free rein to lust, one who is untruthful, one whom all have deserted, and one who breaks through every restraint. Next come one who is deceitful, one who has no wisdom, one who is envious, one who is wedded to sin, and one whose conduct is bad. After them come one whose soul is uncleansed, one who is cruel, and a gambler. So should one who is always trying to injure his friends, and one who covets wealth that belongs to others. So should the wicked man who is never satisfied with what another gives him to the limit of his means, and the man who is never pleased with his friends. The same holds for the man who grows angry when nothing justifies anger, the man of restless mind, and the man who quarrels without cause. There is also the sinner who feels no scruple about deserting friends who mean him well. So should the man who thinks always of his own interest. He quarrels with his friends when they do him some very slight injury or wrong him without knowing it. The same is true of the man who acts like an enemy and speaks like a friend, and the man whose perceptions are perverse. Then there is the man who is blind to his own good, and the man who never takes delight in what is good for himself or for others. One who drinks liquor, one who hates others, one who is wrathful, and one who has no compassion should be avoided. So should one who is pained by the sight of another’s happiness, one who injures friends, and one who is always taking the lives of living creatures. The same holds for one who is ungrateful, and one who is base. No alliance of friendship should ever be formed with any of them. And none should be formed with the man who is forever intent on marking the faults of others.”
“Hear now of those with whom friendship may be formed. Men who are well born, who have eloquence and courtesy of speech, and who are gifted with knowledge and science: kings should accept such men for alliances of friendship. Kings should accept those who have merit and other accomplishments, who are free from covetousness, who are never worn out by labor, and who are good to their friends. The same holds for those who are grateful, who have wide information and knowledge, who have no avarice in them, and who have agreeable qualities. So too with those who are firm in truth, who have subdued their senses, and who are devoted to athletic and other exercises. They should also accept those who come of good families, who carry their families on with wives and children, who are free of faults, and who have fame. So too with those who are pleased and contented when one does for them the best that is in one’s power, and who never grow angry when nothing justifies anger. The same holds for those who are never displeased without sufficient cause, who know the science of profit well and keep their minds calm even when they are annoyed. Kings should accept those who give themselves to the service of their friends at a cost to themselves. They should accept those who are never estranged from a friend and stay as they were, like a red woolen blanket that holds its color. So too with those who never slight the poor out of anger, and who never dishonor young women by giving way to lust and loss of judgment. The same is true of those who never point out wrong paths to their friends, who can be trusted, and who are devoted to the practice of righteousness. Kings should accept those who look on gold and a lump of brick with the same eye, and who hold fast to friends and well-wishers. They should also accept those who gather their own people and work at a friend’s business with no thought for their own dignity. They put off every mark of their own rank. Such are the men with whom alliances of friendship should be made. The dominions of a king who makes his friends among men of that stamp spread in every direction, like the light of the lord of the stars.”
“Alliances should be formed with men who are well practiced in weapons, and who have completely subdued their anger. They should be men who are always strong in battle, and who have high birth, good conduct, and varied accomplishments. And among all the vicious men I named, the lowest are those who are ungrateful and those who injure friends. Men who behave so should be avoided by everyone. This is a settled conclusion.”
Yudhishthira said, “I want to hear this described in full. Tell me who they are that are called injurers of friends and ungrateful men.”
The tale of Gautama and Rajadharma: the example of ingratitude (beginning)
Bhishma said, “I will tell you an old story. The things in it happened in the country of the Mlechchhas that lies to the north. There was a certain Brahmin who belonged to the Middle Country, a man with no Vedic learning at all. One day he saw a prosperous village and went into it, hoping for charity. A robber lived in that village, a man of great wealth, who knew the marks that distinguish all the orders of men. The robber was devoted to Brahmins, firm in truth, and always busy making gifts. The Brahmin went to that robber’s house and begged. He asked for a house to live in, and for the necessaries of life for one year.”
“The robber gave him what he asked, and a piece of new cloth with both its ends whole, and a widowed woman who was still young. The Brahmin, whose name was Gautama, was filled with delight at getting all this. He settled happily into the roomy house the robber assigned him. He took up the support of the relatives and kinsmen of the slave woman the robber chief had given him. He lived on in that prosperous village of hunters. He began to practice archery with great devotion. Every day, like the other robbers who lived there, Gautama went into the woods and killed wild cranes in great numbers. Always at the work of killing living creatures, he grew skilled in it, and soon he said farewell to compassion. From keeping close company with robbers he became like one of them.”
“He lived happily in that robber village for many months, and the number of wild cranes he killed was large. Then one day another Brahmin came to the village. He was dressed in rags and deerskins and wore his hair in matted locks. His conduct was very pure, and he was devoted to the study of the Vedas. He was humble, frugal in what he ate, devoted to Brahmins, deeply versed in the Vedas, and a keeper of the vows of brahmacharya. That Brahmin had been a dear friend of Gautama’s, and he came from the same part of the country Gautama had left. He never accepted food from the hand of a Shudra. He arrived in the course of his wanderings at that village crowded with robber families. So he began to look for the house of a Brahmin where he might be a guest. He searched it in every direction. At last he came to the house that belonged to Gautama.”
“It happened that Gautama was coming back from the woods at that very moment and was just entering his door. The two friends met. Gautama was armed with a bow and a sword. He carried a load of slaughtered cranes on his shoulders, and his body was smeared with the blood that trickled down from the bag. The new arrival looked at this man who had the appearance of a cannibal, who had fallen away from the pure practices of the order he was born in. He knew him. ‘What is this you are doing here in your folly?’ he said. ‘You are a Brahmin, and you carry a Brahmin family forward. You were born in a respectable family of the Middle Country. How have you come to live like a robber? Remember your famous kinsmen of earlier days, every one of them well versed in the Vedas. You were born in their line, and you have become a stain on it. Wake yourself by your own effort. Remember the energy, the conduct, the learning, the self-restraint, and the compassion that are yours by birth, and leave this place where you are living.’”
“Gautama answered that well-meaning friend with real pain in his heart. ‘I am poor,’ he said. ‘I have no knowledge of the Vedas. I took up my home here for the sake of wealth alone. Know that. Seeing you today, though, I am blessed. We will set out from this place together tomorrow. Spend the night here with me.’ The newcomer was a compassionate man and he stayed the night. He touched nothing in that house. He was hungry, and Gautama pressed him again and again, and still the guest refused to touch any food there.”
The meeting with the crane Rajadharma, and the wealth from Virupaksha
Bhishma said, “When that night had passed and the good Brahmin had left the house, Gautama came out too and set off toward the sea. On the way he saw some merchants who made voyages by sea, and he joined their caravan and went on with it toward the ocean. But as that large caravan was passing through a valley, a maddened elephant attacked it, and almost every person in it was killed. The Brahmin escaped somehow from that great danger and ran for his life toward the north, with no idea where he was going. Cut off from the caravan and carried far from that place, he wandered alone in a forest like a kimpurusha.”
“At last he came on a road that led toward the ocean. He followed it until he reached a delightful, heavenly forest full of flowering trees. Mango trees stood in it that put out flowers and fruit the whole year round. It was like the very woods of Nandana, and Yakshas and Kinnaras lived there. There were shala trees and palmyras and tamalas, clusters of black aloe, and many great sandal trees. On the pleasant tablelands, fragrant with scents of many kinds, the finest birds could always be heard pouring out their songs. The birds called bharundas, whose faces are like the faces of human beings, sang there, and those called bhulingas, and others that belong to the mountains and to the sea. Gautama walked through that forest listening to them. On his way he saw a level piece of ground, very lovely, covered with golden sand and as beautiful as heaven. On it stood a large and handsome banyan with a rounded top. Its many branches matched the parent trunk in beauty and size, and the tree looked like an umbrella set over the plain. The ground under it had been sprinkled with water scented with the most fragrant sandal. Flowers lay all around, and the place looked like the court of the Grandsire himself.”
“Gautama was delighted with that charming and sacred spot, which looked like the home of a god. He sat down there with a contented heart. As he sat, a soft and pleasant breeze began to blow, carrying the perfume of many kinds of flowers. It cooled his limbs and filled him with a heavenly ease, and refreshed by it he soon fell asleep. The sun went down behind the Asta hills. That shining body had entered his chambers in the west, and the evening twilight had come. Then a bird who stood first among his kind came back to that spot, which was his home, from the regions of Brahma. His name was Nadijangha, and he was a dear friend of the creator. He was a prince of cranes, a bird of great wisdom, and a son of the sage Kashyapa. He was widely known on earth by another name too, Rajadharma. Indeed he surpassed everyone on earth in fame and in wisdom. He was the child of a celestial maiden, beautiful and learned, and he shone like a god. The many ornaments he wore were as bright as the sun, and that child of a celestial girl seemed to blaze with beauty.”
“Gautama saw that bird arrive and was filled with wonder. He was also worn out with hunger and thirst, and he began to look the bird over with the wish to kill him. Rajadharma spoke first. ‘Welcome, Brahmin. It is my good luck that I find you in my home today. The sun has set and the evening twilight is here. Having come to my home, you are my dear and honored guest for today. Receive my worship by the rites laid down in the scriptures, and tomorrow morning go wherever you wish.’”
“Those sweet words astonished Gautama, and a great curiosity came over him. He stared at Rajadharma and could not take his eyes away. ‘Brahmin,’ the bird said, ‘I am the son of Kashyapa by one of the daughters of the sage Daksha. You are a man of great merit and you are my guest today. You are welcome.’ He offered him hospitality by the rites the scriptures lay down. He made him an excellent bed of the shala flowers that lay all around. He brought him several large fish caught in the deep waters of the Bhagirathi, and with the fish the son of Kashyapa set a blazing fire before his guest. When the Brahmin had eaten and was content, the bird, who was rich in penance, began to fan him with his wings to drive off his weariness.”
“Seeing his guest seated at his ease, he asked him about his lineage. ‘I am a Brahmin, and I am known by the name Gautama,’ the man said, and he said nothing more. The bird gave him a soft bed made of leaves and scented with many fragrant flowers. Gautama lay down on it and felt great happiness. When he had lain down, the eloquent son of Kashyapa, who was like Yama himself in his knowledge of duties, asked him what had brought him there. ‘I am very poor,’ Gautama answered. ‘I want to go to the sea to earn wealth.’ The son of Kashyapa answered him cheerfully. ‘You need feel no anxiety. You will succeed, and you will go home with property. The sage Brihaspati has spoken of four ways of acquiring wealth. They are by inheritance, by a sudden accession that comes of luck or the favor of the gods, by labor, and through the aid and kindness of friends. I have become your friend. I have good feelings toward you. So I will exert myself in such a way that you succeed in acquiring wealth.’”
“The night passed and morning came. Seeing his guest rise cheerfully from his bed, the bird said, ‘Go along this very road, my friend, and you are sure to succeed. About three yojanas from this place there is a mighty king of the rakshasas. He has great strength, his name is Virupaksha, and he is a friend of mine. Go to him. At my request that chief will without doubt give you as much wealth as you desire.’ Gautama set out gladly, eating his fill on the way of fruits as sweet as nectar. He looked at the sandal and aloe and birch trees that stood along the road, enjoyed their cool shade, and went quickly. So he reached the city known by the name Meruvraja. It had great gateways made of stone and high walls of stone. A trench ran around it on every side, and large pieces of rock and engines of many kinds were kept ready on the ramparts. The rakshasa chief, a being of great intelligence, soon learned of him as a dear guest sent by his friend. He received the news gladly and commanded his attendants, ‘Let Gautama be brought here from the gate at once.’ At the king’s command certain men, as quick as hawks, came out of their ruler’s splendid palace, went to the gate, and addressed Gautama. ‘Come quickly. The king desires to see you. You may have heard of the king of the rakshasas, Virupaksha by name, a king of great courage. He himself is impatient to see you. Come quickly, and do not linger.’ The Brahmin forgot his tiredness in his surprise and ran along with the messengers. He saw the great wealth of the city and was filled with wonder, and soon, eager for a sight of the rakshasa king, he entered the palace in their company.”
“He was led into a spacious room and presented to the king of the rakshasas, who honored him with the usual offerings. He took his place on an excellent seat. The king asked him about the family of his birth and his practices, about his study of the Vedas and his keeping of the vow of brahmacharya. The Brahmin left the other questions unanswered and stated his name and his family, nothing more. The king had learned so much and no more. He saw that his guest had neither the splendor of a Brahmin nor Vedic study, and asked next about the country he lived in. ‘Where is your home, and to what family does your wife belong? Tell us truly, and do not be afraid. Trust us, and have no anxiety.’ Gautama said, ‘I belong by birth to the Middle Country. I live in a village of hunters. I have married a Shudra wife who had been a widow. All this that I tell you is the truth.’”
“The king began to consider what he should do, and how he might win merit in the matter. He said to himself, ‘This man is a Brahmin by birth. He is also a friend of Rajadharma, and that son of Kashyapa has sent him to me. I must do what is pleasing to my friend. Rajadharma is very close to me. He is my brother and my dear kinsman, truly a friend of my heart. On this day of the month of Kartika a thousand Brahmins of the first rank are to be entertained in my house. This Gautama shall be entertained with them, and I will give wealth to him as well. This is a sacred day. Gautama has come here as a guest. The wealth that is to be given away is ready. What is there left to think about?’”
“Just about then a thousand Brahmins of great learning came to the palace, bathed and purified, adorned with sandal paste and flowers, and dressed in long robes of linen. The rakshasa king Virupaksha received his guests as they came, duly and by the rites of the scriptures. At his command skins were spread out for them, and the royal servants laid mats of kusha grass on the ground. When the king had honored them, those Brahmins sat down on the seats. The rakshasa chief worshiped his guests once more, as the ordinance provides, with sesame seeds, green blades of grass, and water. Some among them were chosen to represent the Vishvedevas, the ancestors, and the deities of fire. These were smeared with sandal paste, flowers were offered to them. They were adored with other costly offerings, and after that worship every one of them looked as radiant as the moon in the sky. Then bright, polished plates of gold, adorned with engravings and filled with excellent food prepared with ghee and honey, were set before the Brahmins. Every year there were the days of the full moon in the months of Ashadha and Magha. On those days a great number of Brahmins used to receive from the rakshasa chief, after proper honors, the best kinds of food they could desire. On the day of the full moon in the month of Kartika above all, when autumn had gone, the king used to give the Brahmins much wealth of many kinds. There was gold, silver, jewels, gems, pearls, diamonds of great value, stones of lapis lazuli, deerskins, and skins of the ranku deer.”
“The mighty Virupaksha threw down a heap of wealth of many kinds to be given away as dakshina. Then he said to those Brahmins, ‘Take from these jewels and gems as much as you wish and can hope to carry away.’ And he used to tell them, ‘Take the plates of gold and the vessels you have used for your dinner, and go.’ When the rakshasa king spoke those words at that feast, the Brahmins took as much wealth as each of them desired. Honored with costly jewels and gems, and dressed in excellent robes, they were filled with delight. Then the king held back the rakshasas who had come to his palace from many lands, and he spoke to the Brahmins once more. ‘For this one day, Brahmins, you need have no fear of the rakshasas here. Enjoy yourselves as you wish, and then go away with speed.’ The Brahmins left that place and went off in all directions as fast as they could. Gautama too lost no time. He took up a heavy quantity of gold and went away.”
The dire sin of ingratitude: Gautama kills Rajadharma
Bhishma said, “He could hardly carry the load. He got as far as the same banyan under which he had met the crane. There he sat down, tired, worn with the road, and hungry. While he rested, Rajadharma came. The bird was devoted to his friends, and he gladdened Gautama by bidding him welcome. He beat his wings to fan his guest and drive away his weariness, he did him honor, and he saw to his food. When Gautama had eaten and was refreshed he began to think. ‘This load of bright gold I have taken up is heavy. Greed and folly made me take so much. I have a long way to travel. I have no food to keep me alive on the way. What am I to do to stay alive?’”
“Those were his thoughts, and think as he might, he could see no food he might eat on the road. Then this ungrateful man conceived a thought. ‘This prince of cranes is so large, and there is a heap of flesh on him, and he stays right beside me. I will kill him and put him in my bag, and leave this spot, and travel fast.’”
“There under the banyan the prince of birds had lit a fire for the protection of his guest and kept it burning with high, blazing flames. On one side of that fire the bird slept, in complete trust. The ungrateful man made ready to kill his sleeping host. With the help of that blazing fire he killed the trusting bird, and when he had finished him he was filled with delight. It never came to him that there was sin in what he had done. He stripped off the feathers and the down and roasted the flesh on the fire. Then he took it up, together with the gold he had brought, and fled quickly from that spot.”
“The next day the rakshasa king Virupaksha said to his son, ‘Alas, my son, I do not see Rajadharma today. Every morning he goes to the regions of Brahma to adore the Grandsire, and on his way back he never goes home without paying me a visit. Two mornings and two nights have now passed without his coming to my house, and my mind is uneasy. Let inquiry be made after my friend. That Gautama who came here has no Vedic study and none of a Brahmin’s splendor, and he has found his way to my friend’s home. I greatly fear that this worst of Brahmins has killed Rajadharma. I read him through by the signs he showed: evil in his practices, wicked in his understanding, without compassion. He was cruel and grim of face, the lowest of men, and like a robber. That Gautama has gone to the home of my friend, and my heart is very anxious. Go from here at full speed, my son, to the home of Rajadharma, and find out if that pure-souled bird is still alive. Do not delay.’”
“The prince set out at once with other rakshasas, traveling fast. At the foot of the banyan he saw what was left of Rajadharma. The son of the rakshasa king wept with grief, and then he ran, as fast and as hard as he could, to seize Gautama. The rakshasas had not far to go before they caught the Brahmin, and with him they found the body of Rajadharma, stripped of its wings, its bones, and its feet. Taking their captive with them, they went back at great speed to Meruvraja and showed the king the mangled body of Rajadharma and that ungrateful, sinning wretch, Gautama.”
“When the king saw the remains of his friend, he and his counselors and his priest began to weep aloud. The sound of lamentation in his house was loud, and the whole city of the rakshasa king, men, women, and children, was plunged in grief. Then the king said to his son, ‘Let this sinner be killed. Let these rakshasas here feast merrily on his flesh. Sinful in his deeds, sinful in his habits, sinful in his soul, and hardened in sin, this man, I think, should die at your hands.’ But the rakshasas, fierce and strong as they were, said they were unwilling to eat the flesh of that sinner. Those wanderers of the night bent their heads to their king. ‘Let this lowest of men be given away to the robbers,’ they said. ‘You should not give us such a sinner for our food.’ The king said, ‘Let it be so. Let this ungrateful creature be given to the robbers, then, without delay.’”
“So the rakshasas, armed with lances and battle-axes, hacked the man into pieces and gave the pieces to the robbers. And it turned out that the robbers themselves refused to eat his flesh. They were eaters of men, and still they would not eat an ungrateful person. For one who kills a Brahmin, for one who drinks liquor, for one who steals, for one who has fallen away from a vow, there is expiation. For an ungrateful person there is none. The cruel man who injures a friend and turns ungrateful is left uneaten by the very cannibals, and by the worms that feed on carrion.”
Surabhi’s nectar, Rajadharma’s revival, and the heart of the tale
Bhishma said, “Then the rakshasa king had a funeral pyre built for that prince of cranes. He adorned it with jewels and gems and perfumes and costly robes. He set fire to it with the body of the prince of birds on it and had the last rites of his friend performed by the ordinance. At that moment the auspicious goddess Surabhi, the daughter of Daksha, appeared in the sky above the place where the pyre had been raised. Her udder was full of milk. From her mouth froth mixed with milk fell on the funeral pyre of Rajadharma, and at its touch the prince of cranes came back to life. He rose up and went to his friend Virupaksha, the king of the rakshasas.”
“At that very time the chief of the gods himself came to the city of Virupaksha. ‘By good luck you have revived the prince of cranes,’ Indra said to the rakshasa king. He went on to tell him the old story of a curse that the Grandsire had once pronounced on Rajadharma. ‘Once this prince of cranes stayed away from the region of Brahma when his presence was expected. In his anger the Grandsire said of him. “Since this worthless crane has failed to present himself in my assembly today, that wicked-souled one shall not soon die and leave the earth.” Because of those words of the Grandsire, the prince of cranes, though Gautama killed him, has come back to life. It was through the power of the nectar with which his body was drenched.’”
“When Indra had finished, Rajadharma bowed to the chief of the gods. He said, ‘If your heart is inclined to show me grace, then let my dear friend Gautama be restored to life.’ Vasava heard him, sprinkled nectar over the Brahmin Gautama, and restored him to life. The prince of cranes went up to his friend Gautama, who still had the load of gold on his shoulders, and embraced him, and felt great joy. Then Rajadharma sent Gautama of the sinful deeds on his way, together with his wealth, and went back to his own home. At the proper hour the next day he went to the Grandsire’s region. The Grandsire honored that great-hearted bird with the attentions that are shown to a guest.”
“Gautama went back to his home in the village of the hunters and begot many sinful children on his Shudra wife. The gods pronounced a heavy curse on him. Having begotten many children within a few years on the body of his remarried wife, that ungrateful sinner was to sink into a terrible hell for many years. All of this, Yudhishthira, Narada recited to me in former days. I have called this grave story back to mind and told you every part of it in order.”
“Where can an ungrateful person find fame? Where is his place? Where can he find happiness? An ungrateful person does not deserve to be trusted, and one who is ungrateful can never escape. No one should injure a friend. He who injures a friend sinks into a terrible and everlasting hell. Everyone should be grateful, and everyone should try to benefit his friends. Everything may be had from a friend. Honors may be had from friends. Through friends a man may enjoy the many things there are to enjoy, and through the exertions of friends he may escape from danger and distress of many kinds. A wise man honors his friend with his best attentions. The wise should shun an ungrateful, shameless, and sinful creature. One who injures his friends is the disgrace of his family, and such a sinner is the lowest of men. So I have told you the marks of the sinner who is stained by ingratitude and who injures his friend. What else do you wish to hear?” Yudhishthira had heard the grandsire through to the end, and he was well pleased.
