The conduct of a king without means: the question of subtle dharma
The question Yudhishthira, the newly crowned Pandava king, put next was about a king who has nothing left. “Grandfather,” he said, “what is a king to do when he has lost his friends and gained many enemies, when his treasury is spent and he has no troops? What is he to do when the ministers around him are wicked men? What when every plan he makes is carried out of the council chamber, when he cannot see his way in front of him? What when he has marched on another kingdom and is grinding it down, or when he is weak and finds himself at war with a ruler stronger than he is? Think of a king whose affairs are badly ordered, who pays no heed to what the place and the hour demand. He has pressed his own people so hard that he can neither make peace with his enemies nor set them against one another. Should such a man get wealth by evil means? Or should he lay down his life and leave the wealth unsought?”
Bhishma, the old grandsire of the Kurus, took his time with it. “You know the duties, Yudhishthira, and you have asked me about a part of them that is kept hidden,” he said. “Had you not asked, I would not have ventured to speak of it. Dharma is very subtle. A man comes to understand it through the words of the scriptures, and by remembering what he has heard and doing good acts someone, somewhere, becomes a righteous man. A king who uses his wits may succeed in getting wealth, or he may fail. Bring your own understanding to the question and consider what answer it ought to have. I will tell you the means by which kings have carried themselves through bad seasons, and those means bear great merit. For the sake of true dharma, though, I will not call them righteous. A treasury filled by oppression brings a king to the edge of ruin. Every thoughtful man who has gone into the matter has come to that conclusion. Whatever science a man studies all his life gives him the knowledge it has to give, and he grows fond of that knowledge. Ignorance leaves a man barren of means, and the means that knowledge contrives become a source of great happiness. So listen to this with no scruple and no malice in you. When the treasury shrinks, the king’s forces shrink with it. The king has to fill it, then, the way a man makes water in a wilderness that has none. By this half-dharma the ancients practiced he must show his people compassion again once the season for it returns. That is the eternal duty. For men who are able the duties are of one kind, and in a season of distress they are of another. A king with no wealth may still earn merit. Life, though, counts for much more than merit. A weak king who gathers merit and nothing else never finds a just and proper living. Since his best efforts cannot win him power through merit alone, the practices of a hard season are sometimes held to agree with dharma. The learned hold all the same that those practices lead to sin. And when the hard season is over, what should the Kshatriya do? He should carry himself so that his merit is kept whole and so that he never has to go under to his enemies. These too are named among his duties. He must never sink into despair. In such a season he should leave merit, his own and other men’s, to look after itself. The thing he has to rescue is himself. That is the settled conclusion. The shruti says that Brahmins, who know the duties, should be skilled in the duties. The Kshatriya’s skill is exertion, because the strength of his arms is his great possession. When his means of support are gone, what may a Kshatriya leave untaken, apart from what belongs to ascetics and what Brahmins own? A Brahmin in distress may officiate at the sacrifice of a man he would never serve in ordinary times, and may eat forbidden food. In the same way a Kshatriya in distress may take wealth from anyone except ascetics and Brahmins. For a man hard pressed, what way out is the wrong way out? For a man shut in a dungeon, what path is the wrong path? A man in that state escapes by whatever opening he finds. Suppose a Kshatriya is brought low by a weak treasury and a weak army. For him the scriptures have laid down neither a beggar’s life nor the trade of a Vaishya nor the work of a Shudra. The living ordained for him is wealth won by battle and victory, and he must never beg from a man of his own order. A man who lives in ordinary times by the practices laid down first for him may live in distress by the practices laid down as their alternative. When the ordinary ones cannot be followed a Kshatriya may live even by unjust and improper means. Brahmins themselves are seen to do so when their living is destroyed, and if Brahmins do it, what doubt can there be about Kshatriyas? Without sinking into despair and yielding to destruction, a Kshatriya may take by force what he can from those who are rich. Know that the Kshatriya is both the protector of the people and their destroyer. When he takes by force in distress, he takes so that he can protect them in the end. No one in this world keeps himself alive without injuring other creatures. The ascetic living alone in the depths of the forest is no exception. And a Kshatriya, above all one who wants to rule, should never live trusting to what the Ordainer has written on his forehead.”
How a Brahmin lives when robbers hold everything
Yudhishthira stayed with the hard season. “Suppose the king’s high dharma of guarding the whole world breaks down,” he said. “Suppose every means of living on this earth has fallen into the hands of robbers. When so low a time has come, grandfather, think of a Brahmin who out of tenderness cannot abandon his sons and his grandsons. By what means is he to live?”
“In such a time a Brahmin should live by the strength of his knowledge,” Bhishma said. “Everything in this world exists for the good. Nothing in it exists for the wicked. A man who makes a bridge of himself, who takes wealth from the wicked and gives it to the good, knows the dharma of distress. A king who wants to keep his kingdom may do the same. Without throwing the realm into disorder, and for the protection of his people, he may take what the rich have not offered him and say, ‘This is mine.’ Think of a steady king, made clean by true knowledge, who takes up work that men condemn so that his kingdom may come through its danger. Who can rightly blame him? Those who live by their strength care for no other way of living. The strong, Yudhishthira, act by their own fire.”
“While the common rule for hard times is in force, a king may live by it and fill his treasury from his own country and from his enemy’s. A king of real intelligence goes a step further. He takes only from those rich men, in either country, whose miserliness or bad conduct has earned them a penalty. However deep the distress, he must not hurt his sacrificial priests, his family priest, his teachers or any Brahmin by taking their wealth, even when they are rich. If he pains them so, the sin is his. What I have told you stands as the authority for all men. It is the eternal eye. Let a king go into his affairs with this as his measure, and by this let it be judged whether he is a good king or a bad one.”
“Many men of the villages, out of anger, come and speak against one another, or in one another’s praise. On their word alone the king should neither punish anyone nor honor anyone. No man should speak slander, and no man should listen to it. Where another is being run down, he should stop his ears or get up and go elsewhere. To blacken others and carry tales is the nature of the wicked. The good, when they sit among the good, speak of other men’s virtues. Think of a pair of young bulls, handsome, well broken and strong, that take the yoke on their shoulders and draw the load smoothly. A king should carry the weight of his kingdom as they do.”
“He should choose the conduct that wins him many helpers. Men who know dharma hold that good custom is its chief mark. There are others who do not accept the rule about priests and teachers. They follow the sage Shankha, who sent his own brother Likhita to the king to be punished. They say that even a teacher who has gone wrong must feel the rod. Neither envy nor greed makes them say it. They see the authority of the rishis behind it, and no authority anywhere equals the word of the rishis. The gods themselves send down to hell a base man who is set on wrong acts. So a king who gains wealth by fraud falls away from dharma.”
“The dharma to follow is the one that the best of men, the makers of prosperity, honor in every way, and that the heart itself approves. It is called fourfold when the Veda enjoins it, the remembered law agrees with it, the good practice it, and it sits well with a man’s own heart. The true track of dharma is as hard to find as the footprint of a snake. Yet a deer struck by an arrow leaves blood where its foot comes down, and the blood leads the hunter to the place where it lies. The fourfold dharma leads a man in the same way. Walk humbly on the road the good have walked, Yudhishthira. This was the conduct of the royal sages.”
The treasury, and the bounds that even robbers keep
“A king should fill his treasury with wealth drawn from his own kingdom and from the kingdoms of his enemies,” Bhishma said. “Out of the treasury his merit grows, son of Kunti, and by it the roots of his kingdom spread and hold. So let him gather a treasury, guard what he has gathered with care, and keep adding to what he guards. This has been the practice of kings from the beginning. A man of spotless ways never fills a treasury, and a man of utter cruelty never fills one either. It is filled by keeping to a middle road.”
“How can a weak king have a treasury? How can a king without a treasury have an army? How can a king without an army keep a kingdom, and how can a man without a kingdom keep fortune beside him? For one who stands high, the loss of his wealth is like death. So a king should always increase his treasury, his army and his friends. Men look down on a king whose treasury is empty. They are not content with the little he can give, and they show no eagerness in his work. It is wealth that wins a king great honor. As cloth covers the parts of a woman’s body that should not be seen, wealth covers every fault a king has.”
“Men he once slighted burn when they see him prosper. They come back and serve him with false hearts, though he would gladly see them dead, as dogs attend the chandala who will kill them. How can such a king be happy, Bharata? So a king should always exert himself and never bow to anyone, for exertion is manhood. Dry wood breaks where it has no joint, and it does not bend. A king may be broken in the same way, and still he should never stoop. Let him go to the forest and wander with the deer if he must. He should never live among robbers who have broken every bound.”
“Robbers find an army easily for their fierce work, Bharata. A man who keeps no bound at all makes every creature uneasy, and the robbers themselves are wary of one who knows no pity. So a king should set up bounds that gladden the hearts of his people. In this world a bound is honored even in a small matter. There are men who have settled it with themselves that this world is nothing and the next world is nothing. Such an unbeliever is a house where fear lives, and he should never be trusted.”
“Robbers too have their bounds. The better kind take a man’s goods and do him no other harm, and many creatures come to feel affection for robbers who hold to that. Some acts are condemned even among robbers. To kill a man who is not fighting is one, and to force another man’s wife, and to be ungrateful. So is taking the wealth of a Brahmin, or stripping a man of all he owns. So is carrying off a maiden, or seizing a village to sit in it as its lord. A robber should keep from every one of them, and from the touch of another man’s wife.”
“Men who have been stripped of everything set about winning the robbers’ friendship and trust. They learn where the robbers live and how they move, and then they destroy them to the last man. This is certain. So robbers who have the wealth of others in their hands should leave some of it behind and never take the whole. They should not turn cruel with the thought, ‘I am the strong one.’ Robbers who leave others a remnant find a remnant of their own left to them on every side. Those who leave nothing live in fear that nothing of theirs will be left.”
Strength, and the dharma that leans on it
“On this matter the men who know the old days recite a saying about dharma,” Bhishma said. “For a Kshatriya with knowledge, merit and wealth are the two things that stand plainly before his eyes. He should not let fine questions of right and wrong block his plain work, because the fruit of dharma is out of sight. A man sees a wolf’s track on the ground and cannot settle whether a tiger made it or a dog. Deciding what is dharma and what is its opposite is as hard. No one here has ever seen the fruit of either with his eyes.”
“So a king should strive for strength, for this whole world lies in the hand of the strong. A strong man comes by fortune, an army and ministers. A poor man is counted fallen, and a small store of wealth is looked on as the leavings of a meal. A strong man may have many faults, and out of fear no one opens his mouth about them. When strength and dharma both stand on truth, together they guard a man from great danger.”
“Of the two I hold strength the greater, because dharma goes forward by strength. Dharma stands on strength as every moving creature stands on the earth. As smoke goes where the wind takes it, dharma follows strength. As a creeper spreads by leaning on a tree, dharma, the weaker of the two, keeps its place by leaning on strength. As pleasure belongs to those who have the means of pleasure, dharma lies in the keeping of the strong. Nothing is beyond the strong. Whatever belongs to the strong is clean.”
“A man of evil ways whose strength is gone finds no protector when danger comes. Everyone shrinks from him as from a wolf. Thrown down from his wealth, despised and ignored, he lives a life of pain, and a life that men hold in contempt is the same as death. People say of him that his own kin have cast him off for his sins. Their words pierce him like arrows, and he burns.”
“For the sin of wealth wrongly gathered the teachers have named the remedy. Let such a king study the three Vedas. Let him wait on the Brahmins and please them with gentle speech and good acts. Let him make his mind large, and marry into a high family. Let him say, ‘I am your servant,’ and give his name, and tell the virtues of other men. Let him bathe each day and repeat his mantras, grow mild in temper, and speak little. When people call him a great sinner he should pay it no mind. After hard penance and many good works, let him take his place again among Brahmins and Kshatriyas. A man who lives so is soon free of his sin. He wins the regard of many and enjoys happiness of many kinds. He is honored everywhere, and he gains a great reward in this world and in the next.”
Kayavya, the robber who kept dharma
“A robber who keeps within bounds does not come to ruin after death,” Bhishma said. “On this the wise tell an old story. There was a man named Kayavya, born of a Kshatriya father and a Nishada mother, a woman of the forest hunters. He was a robber, and he kept the dharma of a Kshatriya without a break. He could strike hard. He was intelligent, brave and learned, he had no cruelty in him, he was devoted to Brahmins and he honored his teachers. He guarded the ascetics in their way of life. Robber as he was, he won the highest success.”
“Morning and evening he went into the forest and stirred up the herds of deer. He knew the ways of every kind of deer and the craft of bringing them down, and among the Nishadas no one was more skilled. He knew every stretch of the forest, and he ranged always over the Pariyatra mountain. He understood the nature of all creatures. His arrow never missed its mark and his weapons were strong. Alone he could beat an army of many hundreds. And in that great forest he served his old father and mother, who were blind and deaf, and honored them every day.”
“He fed them with honey and meat, with roots and fruit and food of many kinds, and he waited on other men who deserved honor. He revered the Brahmins who had left the world to live in the forest, and day after day he carried food to their huts. Some would take nothing from his hand, because they feared it was a robber’s food. To their houses he went before dawn, left grain and fruit and roots at the door, and was gone.”
“One day many thousands of robbers came to him. They were men who kept no bound and did cruel things of every kind, and they asked him to be their chief. ‘You know the place, the time and the right hour,’ they said. ‘You are wise and brave, and firm in what you undertake. Be our leader, the first among us, with the consent of us all. Whatever you order, we will do. Guard us as a mother and a father would.’”
“Kayavya answered them. ‘Never kill a woman, or a man who is afraid, or a child, or an ascetic. Never kill a man who is not fighting you. Never carry off women by force. Let none of you, whatever happens, kill a female of any living kind. Keep the good of the Brahmins always in mind, and fight for them when there is need. Never carry off the standing crops. Never hinder a marriage. Where the gods, the ancestors and guests are honored in a house, raise no trouble there.’”
“‘Of all creatures a Brahmin has the first right to go free from a robber’s hand. Honor them even if it costs you everything you have. The man with whom Brahmins are angry, the man whose defeat they wish for, finds no protector in the three worlds. The man who speaks ill of Brahmins and wants their ruin goes down as surely as darkness at sunrise. Stay here, and look here for the fruit of your trade. Whichever merchants refuse us our due, against them you shall go out in force.’”
“‘Punishment exists to hold down the wicked, and no man may use it to swell his own wealth. Those who torment good men earn death, and that is their punishment. Men who try to fatten themselves by wasting a kingdom perish as quickly as worms in a corpse. And those who are born among robbers and still live by the law of dharma soon win the highest success, robbers though they are.’”
“The robbers accepted every order Kayavya gave and kept to it,” Bhishma said. “They all prospered, and they turned away from sinful acts. By that good work Kayavya won great success, because he had done good to honest men and had held robbers back from sin. A man who thinks every day on this story of Kayavya has nothing at all to fear from the creatures of the forest. He has no fear from any living being, Bharata, and none from a wicked man. He lives in the forest as its lord.”
Brahma’s verses on whose wealth a king may take
“On the way a king fills his treasury, the men who know the old days recite verses that Brahma himself sang,” Bhishma said. “A king must not take the wealth of the twice-born who perform sacrifices, and he must not lay a hand on what belongs to the gods. He may take the wealth of robbers and of men who do no rites. All these people belong to the Kshatriya, Bharata, and the enjoyments of rule are his. All the wealth of the earth is his and no one else’s. That wealth is meant for his army and for sacrifice.”
“Men cut down plants that cannot be eaten and burn them to cook the plants that can. In the same way, those who know dharma have called that man’s wealth useless who does not honor the gods, the ancestors and men with offerings. A righteous king may take such wealth. With it he can satisfy many good people, and he should not lay it up in his own treasury. A king who takes from the wicked and gives to the good makes a bridge of himself and carries them all across. Know him for a man who understands the whole of dharma.”
“Let a righteous king win the worlds by the measure of his strength, step by step, as plants push up by the strength that is in them. Small biting insects come into being from no cause that anyone can see. Men who do no sacrifice and oppose every duty appear in a kingdom in the same way. Flies, gnats and ants are driven off the body of a cow. A king should deal so with those enemies of good works, and dharma will spread. Take dust from the ground and grind it on a stone, and it grows finer and finer. Dharma is the same. The more it is thought over, the finer it is found to be.”
The three fishes
“Two kinds of creature live and thrive in happiness,” Bhishma said. “One provides against what has not yet come. The other has a wit that wakes at the moment of need. The one who puts everything off is lost. Listen with care to a story about one who delayed when he should have settled what to do.”
“In a pool of no great depth, full of fish, there lived three fishes who were friends and went everywhere together. The first of them looked far ahead and liked to be ready for what was coming. The second had a mind that served him the instant he needed it. The third put things off. One day some fishermen came to that pool and began to drain it. They cut channels on every side and let the water run out to the low ground around it.”
“The far-seeing fish watched the water going down and spoke to his two companions. ‘Friends, danger has come on every creature that lives in this water. Let us go quickly to some other place while the way out is still open. One who meets a trouble with good policy before it arrives is never brought into peril of his life. If what I say seems right to you, let us leave now.’”
“The one who put things off answered him. ‘You have spoken well, friend. Still, it is my settled opinion that we need not hurry.’ Then the quick-witted one said to the far-seeing one, ‘When the time comes, friend, my mind never fails to find a way that fits it.’ The far-seeing fish heard them both. He was wise, and he set out at once along one of the running channels. It brought him to another pool, a deep one.”
“When the fishermen saw that the water was nearly gone, they closed in on the fish that were left by one means and another. They churned up the little water that remained, and the fish who put things off was caught with many others. Then the men began to gather their catch on cords. The quick-witted fish pushed in among the bound fish, took the cord in his mouth and held on to it, so that he looked as fast as the rest. The fishermen saw every fish held on the line and were satisfied.”
“They carried the catch to a place of deep clear water to wash it. At that moment the quick-witted fish let go of the cord and was gone into the depths. The one who put things off, dull and slow and without sense, could not get away, and he died.”
“So it is with any man who is too clouded to see that his hour has come upon him. He perishes quickly, like the fish who delayed. And a man who thinks, ‘I am clever enough,’ and does not see to his own good in time, comes into danger of his life like the quick-witted fish. So I say again that these two prosper in happiness, the one who provides beforehand and the one whose wit is ready. The one who delays is destroyed.”
“There are the small measures called kashtha, kala, lava and muhurta. There are the day and the night, the fortnight and the month, the six seasons, the year and the kalpa. All these are called time. The earth is called place. Place can be seen, and time cannot be seen. Whatever a man aims at succeeds as he rightly judges the place and the time that suit it. In the treatises on dharma, on profit and on liberation, the rishis have named these two, place and time, as the chief means to success. A man who acts after thought, who stays alert and uses the right place and the right time, gains the fruit he wants.”
The tale of the cat and the mouse, and Bhishma’s maxim
Bhishma had already praised the mind that provides against the future and the mind that meets the emergency in front of it, and had said that delay destroys a man. Yudhishthira now asked for that mind itself. “I want to hear of that understanding,” he said. “By it a king who knows the scriptures, and knows dharma and profit, keeps his head when enemies stand all around him. When a king falls into distress, the many enemies his past acts have made range themselves against him and try to bring him down. How does a king who is weak and alone hold up his head when powerful kings in league challenge him from every side? How does he make friends and enemies in such an hour, and how should he behave toward both? When men who carry every mark of a friend turn out to be his enemies, what must he do if he is to be happy? With whom should he make war, and with whom peace? And if he is strong, how should he carry himself among enemies? I hold this the highest of all questions about the duties of a king. Few men will sit to hear its answer. No one can give that answer except Shantanu’s son, Bhishma, who is wedded to truth and has every sense under control.” The old man lying on the arrows told him the question was worthy of him and that its answer held great happiness. An enemy becomes a friend, he said, and a friend becomes an enemy. As circumstances combine, the course of human affairs grows very uncertain. So a man has to look to the time and the place and then either trust his enemies or make war on them. He should work as hard as he can to make friends of intelligent, knowing men who wish him well. He should make peace even with enemies when his life cannot be saved any other way. The fool who never makes peace with an enemy never wins any of the gains other men strive for. But the man who weighs the circumstances and then makes peace with enemies, or quarrels even with friends, wins great rewards. On this, Bhishma said, they tell the old story of what passed between a cat and a mouse at the foot of a banyan. The banyan stood in the middle of a wide forest. Creepers of many kinds covered it, and birds of every sort roosted in it. From its great trunk the branches ran out in all directions and laid a cool shade on the ground. A mouse of great wisdom named Palita lived at the foot of that tree, in a hole he had dug with a hundred outlets. In the branches lived a cat named Lomasha, very content, eating a great many birds every day. After some time a chandala, a hunter from a people held unclean, came into the forest and built himself a hut. Every evening after sunset he spread his snares, nets made of leather cords, and went back to the hut and slept soundly, and at daybreak he came again. Every night animals of one kind or another fell into his nets. One day the cat, in a careless moment, was caught. With the old enemy of all mice tangled in the cords, Palita came out of his hole and wandered about without fear, looking for food. Soon he saw the meat the chandala had set out as bait. He climbed onto the trap and began to eat. Laughing to himself, he even climbed onto his enemy, who lay helpless in the net. Palita was so intent on the meat that he never marked his own danger. When at last he looked up, a terrible enemy had arrived: a restless mongoose named Harita, copper-eyed, his body the color of a reed flower. Harita was a creature of holes in the ground who had caught the scent of the mouse and come fast. He stood on his haunches with his head raised, licking the corners of his mouth. And on a branch of the banyan above sat another enemy, a night-prowling owl with a sharp beak, whose name was Chandraka. Both of them had seen him. The mouse was badly frightened, and he thought it through all the same. Death was staring at him and there was fear on every side. What does a creature do then, if it wishes itself well? A life has to be saved, he told himself, through a hundred dangers and by a hundred means. If he climbed down from the trap without care, the mongoose would seize him. If he stayed where he was, the owl would take him. And if the cat worked himself loose from the net, the cat would eat him. A creature of his intelligence had no business losing its wits. One who knows the science of policy never goes under, however great the danger. He could see only one refuge, and it was the cat. The cat was an enemy, and the cat was in distress, and the service a mouse could do him was very great. Hunted by three enemies, he would seek the protection of one of them.
A creature pressed by a stronger one, he reasoned, should make peace even with an enemy. The teachers of policy say so. They say too that a learned enemy is better than a fool for a friend. Perhaps this once the cat could be taken for an intelligent and learned enemy. So Palita, who knew when war should be declared and when peace should be made, spoke gently. “I speak to you in friendship, cat. Are you alive? I want you to live. I want the good of us both. You have nothing to fear. You will live happily. I will rescue you, if you do not kill me. I have thought hard and found a way by which you may escape and I may gain a great deal. The mongoose and the owl are waiting there, and they mean me harm. My life is safe only as long as they hold off. That wretched owl with its restless eyes and its horrid cries is watching me from the branch, and I am terribly afraid of it. Among the good, friendship takes seven steps to make. You are wise, and you are my friend, and I will act toward you as a friend. Without my help you will never tear this net. I will cut it for you if you keep from killing me. You have lived in this tree and I at its foot for many long years, and you know it. The wise praise neither the one whom nobody trusts nor the one who trusts nobody. Both are unhappy. So let our affection grow, and let there be a union between us two. Wise men never praise an effort made after its hour has gone, and this is the hour for our understanding. I want you to live, and you want me to live. A man crosses a deep, wide river on a piece of wood: he carries the wood to the other side, and the wood carries him. Our compact will be like that. I will rescue you, and you will rescue me.” Then he waited for his answer. Lomasha, with his sharp front teeth and his eyes like lapis lazuli, looked at the mouse mildly, considered his own position, and praised the speaker. “I am delighted with you. Bless you for wishing me to live. Do without hesitating whatever you think will turn out well. I am in great distress, and you, if that is possible, are in greater. Let us make our compact without delay. I put myself in your hands. I am devoted to you. I will wait on you and serve you like a disciple, and do whatever you command.” Palita, who now had the cat entirely in his power, laid out his plan. “I will crouch under your body. I am terribly afraid of the mongoose. Save me from him, and do not kill me. Protect me from the owl too, for he also wants me for his prey. I will cut the noose that holds you. I swear it by Truth, my friend.” Lomasha welcomed him with glad cries. “Come quickly! You are a friend as dear to me as life. Through your kindness I have almost got my life back. Let there be peace between us. Once I am out of this, I and all my friends and relatives will do whatever pleases and serves you, and honor you on every occasion. Whoever repays a kindness, however richly, never draws level with the one who was kind first. The first acted for no return at all, and the second is only answering him.” So the mouse made the cat see where his own interest lay. Then he crept in and lay down under the breast of his enemy as trustingly as if it were the lap of his father or his mother. Harita and Chandraka, strong and clever hunters both, saw him settled there and were astonished at this sudden closeness between a mouse and a cat. They gave up hope of their prey, could find no way to pry the two apart, and went off each to his own home. Lying under the cat’s body, Palita began to cut the cords of the noose. He cut them slowly, waiting for the right moment to finish. The cords hurt, and the cat grew impatient watching him. “Why do you not hurry, my friend? Now that you have what you wanted, do you care nothing for me? Cut these strings quickly. The hunter will soon be here.” The mouse answered a cat who did not seem to him to have much wisdom. “Wait quietly. There is no need for haste. Put away your fears. I know what the hour requires, and I am wasting no time. An act begun at the wrong moment never pays when it is finished, and an act begun at the right moment always bears splendid fruit. If you are freed at the wrong moment, I will have to stand in great fear of you. So wait for the right one, friend, and be patient. When I see the hunter coming toward this place with his weapons, in that moment of fear for both of us, I will cut the strings. Freed then, you will think of nothing except saving your life, and while you, Lomasha, run up your tree in terror, I will go into my hole.”
The cat, who had done his share of the bargain quickly and properly, reproached the mouse for his slowness. “I saved you from a great danger, and I did it promptly. Honest people never do a friend’s business in this fashion. They do it gladly and they do it fast. Work a little harder, so that good comes to us both. If you are remembering our old hostility and only letting the time slip by, know that your own life will be the shorter for it. And if I ever did you some wrong without knowing it, do not hold it against me. I ask your forgiveness. Be pleased with me.” Palita, who knew the scriptures, gave him this reply. “I have heard what you say for your own ends, cat. Now hear what suits mine. A friendship that has fear in it, that cannot be kept up without fear, has to be handled the way a snake charmer keeps his hand from the fangs. The one who makes a compact with someone stronger and then fails to guard himself finds the compact brings him injury where he looked for benefit. Nobody is anybody’s friend, and nobody is anybody’s well-wisher. Interest alone makes friends and enemies. Interest enlists interest, the way tame elephants are used to catch wild ones of their kind. And once a thing is done, the doer is hardly thought of again, which is why every act should be done so that something is still left to do. When I set you free, the hunter will be upon you and you will run for your life with no thought of catching me. Look: I have cut every string of this net except one, and I will cut that one quickly. Be comforted, Lomasha.” While the two of them talked, both in serious danger, the night slowly wore away. A great fear worked its way into the cat’s heart. At last morning came, and with it the chandala, whose name was Parigha. His face was frightful. His hair was black and tawny, his hips were huge, his look was fierce. His mouth ran from ear to ear, his ears were very long, and he was filthy. He came armed, with a pack of dogs around him, and to the cat he looked like a messenger of Yama. Sick with fright, Lomasha said to Palita, “What will you do now?” The mouse cut the last string at once. The cat sprang free and raced up the banyan. Palita, delivered in the same instant from the trap and from a terrible enemy, ran into his hole. The hunter, who had seen all of it, picked up his net. His hopes had come to nothing, and he went back to his hut. From high in the branches, his life his own again, the cat called down to the mouse in his hole. “You ran off without a word to me. I hope you do not suspect me of anything. I am grateful, and you did me a great service. You gave me trust and you gave me my life. Why do you stay away now, at the very hour when friends should taste the sweetness of friendship? Whoever makes friends and then forgets them is counted a wicked creature and finds no friends in his hour of danger. You honored me and served me as well as you could. Now enjoy the company of a poor friend. My friends and my kinsmen will honor you the way disciples honor a teacher, and so will I. Who would refuse to worship the giver of his life? Be master of my body and my home. Dispose of everything I own. Be my honored counselor and rule me as a father would. I swear by my life that you have nothing to fear from us. In intelligence you are Ushanas himself. You conquered us by your understanding, and by the strength of your policy you gave us our lives.” Palita answered him sweetly, and every word served his own safety. “I have heard you, Lomasha. Now hear how it looks to me. Friends must be examined well and enemies studied well, and even the learned call that a hard task that wants a sharp mind. Friends put on the look of enemies, and enemies the look of friends. There is no such thing as an enemy, and no such thing as a friend. Circumstances make both. A creature whose interests are safe while another lives, and in danger once that other dies, calls him a friend for exactly as long as those interests hold. No state of things deserves the name of friendship or of enmity forever. In time friendship turns into enmity and an enemy turns into a friend, for self-interest is very powerful. The one who trusts friends blindly, or mistrusts enemies always, with no regard for policy, finds his life unsafe. So does the one who sets his heart on a loving union with either. Never trust the one who deserves no trust, and never trust too far the one who does. The danger that grows from blind trust cuts a creature off at the roots. Father, mother, son, the mother’s brother, the sister’s son, every relative and kinsman is guided by interest and profit. A father and a mother can be seen casting off a dear son who has fallen.
“Everyone looks after himself. See how strong self-interest is. And the creature who, the moment he is free of danger, looks for ways to make his enemy happy will find his own escape very hard. You came down from the top of the tree to this very spot and, light of mind, never saw that a net was spread here. One who cannot protect himself protects no one else and ruins everything he does. You tell me in sweet words that I am dear to you. Hear my reasons. One becomes dear for a cause, and one becomes an enemy for a cause. This whole world of creatures moves from desire for gain. The friendship of two brothers born of one mother and the love of husband and wife both rest on interest. I know of no affection anywhere that rests on anything else. Brothers, or a husband and wife, who have quarreled are sometimes seen to come together again from natural affection. Nothing of the kind is seen between those who have no tie. One is loved for his generosity, another for his sweet words, a third for his religious acts. A creature is loved for the purpose he serves. The affection between us had a cause, and the cause is gone. What reason is left for me to be so dear to you, besides your wish to make me your prey? Time spoils reasons. You are powerful, and this fondness of yours is badly timed. Peace and war are unstable things, and the circumstances that call for one or the other change as fast as clouds change their shapes. This very day you were my enemy. This very day you were my friend. This very day you have become my enemy again. You are my enemy by nature. Circumstances made you my friend. That state of things has passed, and the old natural enmity has come back. Knowing policy as I do, why should I walk today, for your sake, into the net that is spread for me? Your power freed me from a great danger, and my power freed you from one like it. Each of us has served the other, and there is no need for us to meet again. You have no use for me now except as a meal. I am the food and you are the eater. I am weak and you are strong. There can be no friendly union between two placed so unequally. You were caught in that net for the sake of food. You are out of it, and you are hungry, and I know this is your hour for eating. You are looking for prey with your eyes on me. You have sons and wives. If they saw me beside you, why would your dear wife and your loving children not eat me up cheerfully? Who with any sense puts himself in the power of an enemy who is no pattern of righteousness, who is hungry, and who is hunting? Be happy, then. I am leaving you. I am filled with alarm when I see you even from a distance. If you believe I did you a service, keep the rules of friendship on the day you find me wandering careless and off my guard. That will be gratitude enough. To live near the strong is never praised, even after the danger seems past. Ask of me anything else and I will give it, everything except my life. To protect himself a creature should give up his children, his kingdom, his jewels, and his wealth. If he lives, he can win back all he gave.” The cat flushed with shame. “I swear to you, I hold it a great wrong to injure a friend,” he said. “I know your wisdom, and I know you wish me well. Do not take me for what I am not. You gave me my life and I bear you great friendship for it. I know my duties, I value merit in others, I am grateful, I am devoted to my friends and to you above all. At your command I and all my kinsmen would lay down our lives. You have no cause to suspect me.” Palita thought for a moment. “You are very good, and I am glad to have heard you. For all that, I cannot trust you. No praise and no gift of wealth will bring me to you again. A weak creature who makes a compact with a stronger one while enemies threaten them both must walk carefully once the danger is over. Having gained his end he must never trust the stronger again. He should always try to make others trust him, and he should place no trust in enemies himself. Possessions and children and everything else have value only while one is alive. In brief, the highest truth in all the treatises on policy is mistrust. However weak a creature is, if he mistrusts his enemies they never get him in their power, strong as they are. One like me, cat, must always guard his life from one like you. And you, guard yours from the chandala, whose anger has been roused.” At the mention of the hunter the cat left his branch in terror and fled at great speed. Palita, having shown what understanding can do, went into another hole.
Yudhishthira’s doubt, and the beginning of the tale of Pujani
Yudhishthira had followed the story to its end, and the end troubled him. “You have laid it down that no trust is to be placed in enemies,” he said. “How is a king to keep himself standing if he trusts no one at all? You have said that out of trust great danger comes to kings. How, then, is a king to conquer his enemies without trusting others? Take this doubt from me, grandfather. What I have heard you say about mistrust has left my mind confused.”
Bhishma answered with another story. “Listen, then, to what happened in the house of Brahmadatta, and to what was said there between the king and Pujani. Pujani was a bird, and she had lived a long time with King Brahmadatta in the inner apartments of his palace at Kampilya, among the women of the household. She could mimic the cry of every animal, as the bird called the jivajivaka does. She was a bird by birth and nothing more, and yet she had great knowledge, and there was no truth she did not understand.”
“While she lived there she hatched a chick, a splendid little creature, and at that very same time the queen bore the king a son. Pujani was grateful for the shelter of the king’s roof, and she showed it. Every day she flew to the shore of the ocean and came back with two fruits, one for her own young one and one for the infant prince. She gave the first to her chick and the second to the king’s child. The fruits were as sweet as nectar, and they built strength and energy in whoever ate them. Day after day she brought them, and day after day she divided them in the same way. The little prince grew very strong on the fruit that came to him from Pujani.”
One day the prince, carried in his nurse’s arms, caught sight of Pujani’s chick. He got down from the nurse and ran to it, and with a small child’s eagerness he began to play with the bird and was delighted with the game. The two were of an age, born on the same day under the same roof. At last he lifted the chick in his hands and squeezed, and pressed the young life out of it. Then he went back to his nurse.
The mother was away, out after the fruit she fetched every day. She came back to the palace and saw her young one lying on the ground, killed by the prince. She looked at her son, who had no life left in him. The tears poured down her cheeks. Her heart burned, and she wept bitterly. “No one should live with a Kshatriya,” she said, “or make a friend of one, or take pleasure in any dealings with him. While they have some purpose to serve they are all courtesy. Once the purpose is served they throw the instrument away. Kshatriyas do harm to everyone, and they are never to be trusted. Even after they have done an injury they come to the injured with soothing words and assurances that are worth nothing.”
Then she spoke to herself. She would take a full revenge for this act of enmity on the cruel and ungrateful child who had betrayed her confidence. “He is guilty three times over,” she said. “He has taken the life of one who was born on the same day as himself and was being reared in the same place with him. He has taken the life of one who ate with him, and of one who depended on him for protection.” With that Pujani flew at the prince and drove her talons into his eyes. The act gave her some comfort, and she spoke again. “A sin done deliberately falls on the doer without any loss of time. Those who avenge an injury lose none of their merit by it. Suppose the fruit of a sinful act does not show in the one who did it. Then it will surely show in his sons, or in his sons’ sons, or in his daughters’ sons.”
Brahmadatta saw his son blinded by the bird. He judged what she had done a fitting return for what the boy had done, and he turned to Pujani and spoke to her.
The talk of Pujani and Brahmadatta: why there is no trust after injury
Brahmadatta said, “We did you an injury, and you have avenged it by doing one in return. The account is squared. Do not leave the home you have here, Pujani. Stay on with us.”
Pujani answered, “When someone has injured another and still goes on living beside him, the learned never praise it. In such a case it is always better for the one who did the injury to leave the old place. Nobody should put faith in the soothing assurances of a party he has injured. The fool who trusts them soon meets his destruction. Enmity does not cool quickly. The very sons and grandsons of those who have injured one another are destroyed by it, because the quarrel comes down to them like an inheritance. With their offspring destroyed the first parties lose the next world as well. Between those who have injured each other, mistrust is what brings happiness. One who has betrayed a confidence should never be trusted again, even a little.”
“The one who deserves no trust should have none, and the one who deserves it should never have too much,” she said. “The danger that comes of blind confidence brings a destruction that is complete. Try to make others trust you, and place no confidence in others yourself. A father and a mother are the first of friends, and the only ones. A wife is a vessel that receives the seed. A son is one’s own seed and nothing more. A brother is an enemy. A friend or a companion stays one only while his palm is oiled. It is one’s own self that tastes one’s happiness and one’s misery. Between those who have injured each other there can be no real peace, and the reason I had for living here no longer exists. When someone who has done an injury sees the injured party honoring him with gifts and attentions, his mind naturally fills with mistrust. When the one paying those honors is the stronger of the two, the weak grow afraid. An intelligent creature leaves the place where honor came first and dishonor and injury came after it, and leaves whatever honor the enemy may offer from then on. I have lived in your house a long time, and you have honored me through all of it. A cause of enmity has arisen at last. I ought to leave this place without hesitation.”
Brahmadatta would not let it go. “Whoever returns an injury for an injury received is never held to have offended,” he said. “The avenger squares his account by it. So stay here, Pujani, and do not leave this place.”
Pujani said, “No friendship can be cemented a second time between the one who gave an injury and the one who gave an injury back. Neither heart can forget what has happened.”
Brahmadatta said, “The one who injured and the one who avenged the injury must come together again. Where they have done so, their enmity has been seen to cool, and no fresh injury has followed.”
Pujani answered, “Enmity that springs from injuries given and returned can never die. The injured one should never trust his enemy, telling himself that he has been soothed with assurances of goodwill. In this world men meet their destruction again and again through misplaced confidence, and for that reason you and I should meet no more. Those whom force and sharp weapons cannot subdue are conquered by an insincere gentleness, the way wild elephants are taken by means of a tame she-elephant.”
Brahmadatta tried the argument from daily life. “When two live together,” he said, “even if one has done the other a deadly injury, affection grows up between them naturally, and trust with it, as it does between the chandala and the dog. Between those who have injured each other, living side by side blunts the edge of enmity. It never lasts long. It runs off quickly, like water poured on a lotus leaf.”
Pujani gave him the whole of her reasoning. “Enmity springs from five causes, and the learned know them: woman, land, harsh words, natural incompatibility, and injury. When the enemy is a generous man he should never be killed, least of all by a Kshatriya, either openly or by hidden means. In such a case his fault ought to be weighed with care. And once enmity has arisen, even with a friend, no further confidence should be placed in him. The feeling lies hidden, like fire in wood. Like the Aurva fire inside the waters of the ocean, the fire of enmity can never be put out by gifts of wealth, by a show of valor, by conciliation, or by learning in the scriptures. Once it has been lit by an injury, it never goes out until it has burned up one of the two parties. One who has injured another should never trust him again as a friend, however much wealth and honor he may have paid him since. For the fact of the injury fills the one who did it with fear. I never injured you, and you never injured me, and that is why I lived in your house. All of that is changed, and now I cannot trust you.”
The argument from Time, and Pujani’s refutation
Brahmadatta reached then for the largest argument he had. “It is Time that does every act,” he said. “Acts are of many kinds, and all of them proceed from Time. Who, then, injures whom? Birth and death come about in the same way. Creatures are born and live because of Time, and because of Time they cease to live. Some are seen to die all at once. Some die one by one. Some are seen to live for long ages. As fire consumes its fuel, Time consumes all creatures. So I am no cause of your sorrow, and you are no cause of mine. It is Time that always ordains the happiness and the misery of everything that has a body. Stay here, then, as long as you please, with affection for me and with no fear of any harm from me. What you did, I have forgiven. Forgive me too, Pujani.”
Pujani took his doctrine and turned it over in front of him. “If Time, as you say, is the cause of all acts, then of course nobody on earth can bear enmity toward anybody. I ask you, though, why friends and kinsmen seek to avenge their dead. Why did the gods and the Asuras strike at each other in battle in the old days? If it is Time that causes happiness and misery and birth and death, why do physicians try to give medicine to the sick? If Time is shaping everything, what need is there of medicine? Why do people who have lost their senses to grief pour themselves out in such wild laments? And if Time, as you say, is the cause of acts, how can anyone gain merit by doing the acts religion asks of him?”
Then she put her own case, and she did not spare herself. “Your son killed my child, and I injured him for it. By that act I have made myself liable to be killed by you. Grief for my son drove me to it. Hear now why I am liable. Men want birds for one of two things, to kill them for food or to keep them in cages for sport. There is no third reason for which men seek out my kind. And birds, for fear of being killed or caged, look for their safety in flight. Those who know the Vedas have said that death and the cage are both painful. Life is dear to all. All creatures are made miserable by grief and pain, and all creatures wish for happiness. Misery has many sources. Old age is misery, Brahmadatta. The loss of wealth is misery. To have near you anything disagreeable or evil is misery, and so is separation from friends and from the things you love. Misery comes from death and from the cage. It comes from causes that have to do with women, and from other causes that lie in nature. And the misery that comes from the death of a child changes every creature and wounds it terribly. Some foolish people say that there is no misery in another’s misery. Only one who has never felt any himself can say that among men. One who has felt sorrow would never dare. Whoever has known the pain of every kind of misery feels the misery of others as his own. What I have done to you, and what you have done to me, a hundred years will never wash away. After what has passed between us there can be no reconciliation. As often as you happen to think of your son, your enmity toward me will be fresh again. When one who has taken revenge for an injury wants peace afterward with the one he injured, the two can no more be joined than the pieces of a broken clay pot.”
She had authority to bring, and she brought it. “Men who know the scriptures have laid it down that trust never produces happiness. Ushanas himself sang two verses to Prahlada in the old days. Whoever trusts the words of an enemy, be they true or false, comes to destruction like a seeker of honey in a pit covered over with dry grass. And enmities are seen to outlive the very death of the enemies, for people go on telling the surviving children about the old quarrels of their dead fathers. Kings put out enmities by conciliation. Then, when the opportunity comes, they break their enemies to pieces like clay jars full of water dashed on a stone. If a king has injured anyone, he should never trust that one again. Great misery comes of trusting those one has wronged.”
Pujani’s parting words: the dharma of country, king, and the care of the people
Brahmadatta had one argument left. “No man gets the fruit of anything he wants by withholding his trust,” he said. “And one who lives always in fear is obliged to live like a man already dead.”
Pujani answered him out of plain experience. “One whose feet are sore will fall if he tries to walk, however carefully he goes. One whose eyes are sore, if he opens them against the wind, finds the wind hurts them cruelly. One who sets foot on an evil road without knowing his own strength, and keeps walking, soon loses his life for it. The man who puts no effort into his land and pays no heed to the season of the rains never brings in a harvest. The one who eats nourishing food every day, be it bitter or sharp or savory or sweet, enjoys a long life. The one who neglects what is wholesome and eats what harms him, with no eye to what follows, soon meets his death. Destiny and exertion depend on each other. Great souls achieve good and great things, and only the unmanly pay court to destiny. An act that does a man good should be done, be it harsh or mild. The unlucky man of no action is always overwhelmed by calamity of every kind. So one should leave everything else aside and put out his energy, and do what brings good to himself. Knowledge, courage, cleverness, strength, and patience are called a man’s natural friends. The wise pass their lives in this world with the help of those five. Houses, precious metals, land, a wife, and friends are called by the learned his secondary sources of good. Those a man may come by anywhere. The wise are content anywhere, and anywhere they shine. Such a man frightens no one, and when others try to frighten him he does not give way to fear. Whatever wealth he has, however small, is sure to grow, for he does every act with skill, and through his self-restraint he wins great fame.”
She turned to her own leaving. “Men of small understanding who cling to home put up with shrewish wives who eat away their flesh the way the young of a crab eat their mother. Some lose all heart at the very thought of leaving. ‘These are our friends,’ they say to themselves, ‘this is our country. How can we leave them?’ A man should certainly leave the country of his birth when plague or famine has fallen on it. He should live in his own country respected by all, or else go and live in another. So I will go to some other region. I dare not live in this place any longer, for I have done your child a great wrong. From a distance one should abandon a bad wife, a bad son, a bad king, a bad friend, a bad alliance, and a bad country. No trust can be put in a bad son. What joy is there in a bad wife? There is no happiness in a bad kingdom, and in a bad country no hope of a living. With a bad friend, whose attachment is never certain, there is no lasting companionship, and in a bad alliance made without need there is disgrace. She is a wife who speaks only what is pleasant. He is a son who makes his father happy. He is a friend in whom one can trust. That is one’s country where one earns one’s living. And he is a king of firm rule who does not oppress, who cherishes the poor, and in whose lands there is no fear.”
From her own case Pujani had come to his, and she spoke now of what a king is. “Wife, country, friends, sons, kinsmen, and relatives: a man can have all of these when the king is accomplished and looks on his people with a righteous eye. When the king is sinful, his subjects are destroyed by his oppressions. The king is the root of the three things a man lives for, dharma, wealth, and pleasure. He should protect his subjects with care. Taking from them a sixth share of their wealth, he should protect them all. A king who does not protect his subjects is truly a thief. Suppose a king gives his assurance of protection and then, out of greed, fails to make it good. That ruler of sinful soul takes on himself the sins of all his subjects and sinks at last into hell. The king who gives the assurance and keeps it, protecting every one of his subjects, comes to be looked on as the benefactor of all.”
“Manu, the lord of all creatures, has said that a king has seven attributes. He is mother, father, teacher, protector, fire, Vaishravana, and Yama. By behaving with compassion toward his people he is called their father. The subject who deals falsely with him is born in his next life as an animal or a bird. By doing them good and cherishing the poor he becomes a mother to them. By scorching the wicked he comes to be regarded as fire, and by restraining the sinful he is called Yama. By giving wealth to those who are dear to him he is regarded as Kubera, the granter of wishes. By giving instruction in dharma and virtue he becomes a teacher, and by carrying out the duty of protection he becomes the protector.”
“The king who delights the people of his cities and his provinces by his merits is never stripped of his kingdom, since he has kept his duty. The king who knows how to honor his subjects never suffers misery here or hereafter. The king whose subjects are always full of anxiety, or loaded with taxes, or overwhelmed by evils of every kind, meets defeat at the hands of his enemies. And the king whose subjects grow like a great lotus in a lake wins every reward in this world and at last is honored in heaven. Enmity with one who is powerful is never praised. The ruler who has drawn on himself the enmity of one stronger than he is loses his kingdom and his happiness both.” Having said this to King Brahmadatta, Bhishma told Yudhishthira, the bird took her leave of him and flew away to the region she had chosen. “That is the conversation between Brahmadatta and Pujani,” the grandsire said. “What else do you want to hear?”
The king’s dharma in the decline of the age and the time of robbers: Bharadvaja and Shatrunjaya
Yudhishthira asked about the age itself. “When dharma and men both decay as the yuga slowly runs down, grandfather, and when the world is harried by robbers, how should a king carry himself then?”
“I will tell you the policy a king should follow in such miserable times,” Bhishma said, “and how he should bear himself when he has put compassion aside. On this they tell the old story of what passed between Bharadvaja and King Shatrunjaya. There was a king among the Sauviras named Shatrunjaya, a great chariot warrior. He went to the rishi Bharadvaja and asked him for the truths of the science of profit. How is a thing not yet gained to be gained? Once gained, how is it to be increased? Once increased, how is it to be protected? And once protected, how is it to be used? Those were his four questions, and the Brahmin rishi answered them with reasons, to make those truths plain to the ruler.”
“A king should always stand with the rod of punishment lifted in his hand,” the rishi said. “He should always show his strength. He should leave no weak place in himself and should mark every weak place in his enemies. The king should keep his eyes at that work always. At the sight of a king whose rod is always lifted, everyone is struck with fear. So the king should rule all creatures with the rod. Men of learning who know the truth praise punishment. Of the four requisites of rule, conciliation, gift, disunion, and punishment, punishment is said to stand first. When the foundation of a refuge is cut away, all who sheltered in it perish. When the roots of a tree are cut, how will the branches live? A wise king cuts away the very roots of his enemy. Then he wins over the allies and partisans of that enemy and brings them under his own sway. When calamity overtakes him he should lose no time: he should take wise counsel, show his strength properly, fight with skill, and even retreat with wisdom.”
“Let his humility be in his speech alone, and at heart let him be as sharp as a razor. He should put away lust and anger and speak sweetly and mildly. When the occasion comes for dealings with an enemy, a king with foresight makes peace and keeps his trust to himself. When the business is finished he turns quickly away from the new ally. He should soothe an enemy with sweet assurances as though the man were a friend. The king should fear that enemy always, as one fears to live in a room that has a snake in it. The man whose mind you mean to master is comforted with assurances drawn from the past. The man of wicked understanding is assured with promises of good to come. The wise man is assured with services done now. One who wants prosperity should join his hands, swear oaths, use sweet words, bow his head in worship, and shed tears. He should carry his enemy on his shoulders as long as the time is against him. When the opportunity comes he should break him to pieces like a clay jar on a stone. It is better for a king to blaze up for a moment like charcoal of ebony wood than to smolder and smoke like chaff for many years. A man with many purposes to serve should not shrink from dealing even with an ungrateful person. If he succeeds he has his happiness, and if he fails he loses esteem. So in doing the business of such people he should never finish it, and should always leave something undone. And a king should do what is for his own good by imitating a cuckoo, a boar, Mount Meru, an empty chamber, an actor, and a devoted friend.”
“He should go often and attentively to the houses of his enemies, and even when calamities fall on them he should ask after their welfare. Prosperity is never won by the idle, or by those with no manliness and no exertion in them, or by those stained with vanity. It is never won by those who fear to be unpopular, or by those who are always putting things off. A king should act so that his enemy never finds his weak places, and he should mark the enemy’s. He should imitate the tortoise, which hides its limbs, and keep his own openings always concealed. He should think over every matter of wealth as the crane does, waiting patiently for hours at the water’s edge for its fish. He should show his valor like a lion. He should lie in wait like a wolf, and fall on his enemies and pierce them like an arrow. Drink, dice, women, hunting, and music he should enjoy with judgment, for addiction to them brings evil. He should make his bows of bamboo and of other things. The king should sleep as lightly as the deer. He should be blind when it is necessary to be blind, and even deaf when it is necessary to be deaf. A wise king uses his strength with regard to time and place, since where those are against him strength is wasted. He should mark what is timely and untimely, reflect on his own strength and weakness, build his strength by measuring it against the enemy’s, and then address himself to action. The king who fails to crush an enemy his army has already brought to submission provides for his own death, like the crab when she conceives. A tree with beautiful blossoms may have no strength in it. A tree heavy with fruit may be hard to climb. And sometimes trees with unripe fruit look like trees whose fruit is ripe. A king who sees all this should never let himself be cast down, and if he conducts himself so he will hold his own against every enemy. With those who come to him asking, he should first strengthen their hopes. Then he should put obstacles in the way of those hopes. He should say the obstacles are only a matter of the occasion, and afterward he should explain that the occasion itself has grave causes behind it.”
“As long as the cause of fear has not actually come, a king should make all his arrangements like a man who is afraid. When it does come upon him, he should strike without fear. No man reaps any good without running into danger, and if he comes through the danger with his life he is sure to earn great benefits. A king should find out every danger that lies ahead. When dangers are present he should conquer them. For fear they grow again, even after he has conquered them, he should think of them as unconquered. To give up the happiness in hand and chase the happiness that is to come is never the policy of an intelligent man. The king who makes peace with an enemy and then sleeps happily in his trust is like a man asleep at the top of a tree, who wakes after he has fallen. When a man falls into distress he should raise himself by every means in his power, mild or stern. After he has risen, when he is able, he should practice righteousness.”
The guarding of counsel, spies, and the hard policy of destroying enemies
The rishi came next to the hidden side of rule. “A king should always honor the enemies of his enemies. He should look on his own spies as though they were agents in his enemy’s pay. The king should see to it that the enemy never recognizes them. He should make spies of atheists and of ascetics and send them into the territories of his enemies.”
“Sinful thieves, who offend against the laws of righteousness and are thorns in everyone’s side, find their way into gardens and places of amusement. They find their way into the sheds set up to give drinking water to thirsty travelers, into public inns and drinking places. They find their way into houses of ill fame, and into holy places and public assemblies. They should be recognized, arrested, and put down. A king should give no trust to the man who deserves none, and he should never trust too far the man who does deserve it. Danger springs from trust, and trust should never be given before the man has been examined. Having won the enemy’s confidence with plausible reasons, the king should strike him when he makes a false step.”
“He should fear the one from whom there seems nothing to fear, and he should always fear those who ought to be feared. The danger that rises from a quarter nobody feared can end in total destruction. By attention to pious works, by silence, by the reddish cloth of ascetics, by matted locks and skins, one should win the confidence of an enemy. Then, when the chance comes, one should spring on him like a wolf. A king who wants prosperity should not shrink from killing a son or a brother or a father or a friend, if any of them tries to thwart his aims. Suppose the teacher himself is arrogant, cannot tell what should be done from what should never be done, and walks unrighteous paths. Then he deserves to be restrained by punishment. As certain insects with sharp stings cut off every flower and fruit of the tree they settle on, the king, after winning his enemy’s confidence with honors and salutations and gifts, should turn on him and shear him of everything. Without piercing the vitals of others, without doing many stern deeds, without killing living creatures as the fisherman kills, no one comes to great prosperity.”
“There is no separate species of creature called enemy or friend. Men become friends or enemies according to the force of circumstances. A king should never let his enemy escape, even if the enemy breaks into piteous lamentation. The king should stay unmoved by it. For it is his duty to destroy the man who has done him an injury. A king who wants prosperity should take care to attach to himself as many men as he can, and to do them good. In his dealings with his subjects he should always be free of malice, and with great care he should punish and check the wicked and the disaffected. When he means to take wealth he should say what is pleasant, and when he has taken it he should say the same. Having struck off a man’s head with his sword, he should grieve and shed tears. He should draw others to himself with sweet words and honors and gifts, and so bind men to his service. He should never enter into fruitless disputes, and he should never cross a river with nothing to help him except his two arms. To chew on the horns of a cow is fruitless and gives no strength: the teeth are broken and the taste goes unsatisfied. Dharma, wealth, and pleasure carry three disadvantages, each of them bound up with something that cannot be parted from it. A king should study those attachments carefully and so avoid the disadvantages.”
“The unpaid balance of a debt, the unquenched remnant of a fire, and the unkilled remnant of one’s enemies grow and increase again and again. So all three should be completely extinguished and rooted out. A debt, which always grows, is sure to remain unless it is wiped out whole. The same is true of defeated enemies and of neglected diseases. These always breed great fear. Every act should be done thoroughly, and one should be heedful always. So small a thing as a thorn, if it is badly drawn, leads to a stubborn gangrene. By killing its people, by tearing up its roads and damaging them in other ways, and by burning and pulling down its houses, a king should destroy a hostile kingdom.”
A king, Bharadvaja said, should be far-sighted like the vulture, motionless like the crane, and vigilant like the dog. He should be valiant like the lion, and fearful like the crow. He should make his way into the territories of his enemies like the snake, with ease and without anxiety.
“A king should win over a hero by joining his palms to him, a coward by putting him in fear, and a greedy man by gifts of wealth. With an equal he should make war. He should be mindful to sow disunion among the leaders of sects and to conciliate those who are dear to him. The king should protect his ministers from disunion and from destruction. If a king becomes mild, the people disregard him. If he becomes stern, the people feel it as an affliction. The rule is that he should be stern when the occasion requires sternness and mild when it requires mildness. By mildness the mild are cut down, and by mildness one may destroy what is fierce. There is nothing mildness cannot bring about, and for that reason mildness is said to be sharper than fierceness. The king who turns mild when mildness is called for and stern when sternness is called for accomplishes all his aims and puts his enemies down.”
“Having drawn on yourself the enmity of a man of knowledge and wisdom, take no comfort from the thought that you are far away from him. The arms of an intelligent man reach far, and with them he injures those who have injured him. Never try to cross what truly cannot be crossed. Never snatch from an enemy what the enemy will be able to take back. Never start to dig if digging will not bring you to the root of the thing you dig for. Never strike a man whose head you will not cut off.” There the rishi stopped, and before he let the king go he set a boundary around everything he had said. “A king should not always act in this way. The course of conduct I have laid down is to be followed in seasons of distress alone. I have said all this out of a wish to do you good, to teach you how to bear yourself when enemies assail you.”
“The ruler of the Sauviras heard those words from a Brahmin who wished him well,” Bhishma said. “He obeyed the instructions cheerfully, and with his kinsmen and his friends he came to a blazing prosperity.”
Vishvamitra and the chandala: the dharma of saving life in a terrible famine
Yudhishthira’s next question was the darkest he had asked. “Think of a time,” he said, “when the high dharma decays and everyone oversteps it, when unrighteousness passes for righteousness and righteousness takes the shape of its opposite. Every wholesome restraint is gone, and every truth about dharma is shaken and confused. The people are ground down by kings and by robbers. Men of all four stages of life have lost their bearings in their duties, and acts have lost their merit. Out of lust and greed and folly men see cause for fear in every direction. No creature trusts another. They kill each other by deceit and cheat each other in their dealings. Houses are burned down across the whole country. The Brahmins are in great suffering. The clouds do not pour a single drop. Every man’s hand is turned against his neighbor, and everything needed for life has fallen into the hands of robbers. When such a season of terrible distress sets in, grandfather, how is a Brahmin to live, a man unwilling to cast off compassion or his children? How does he keep himself alive? And how should the king live in such a time, when sin has overtaken the world, so that he falls away neither from dharma nor from profit?”
Bhishma said, “The peace and prosperity of the subjects, rain enough and rain in season, disease, death, and every other fear, all depend on the king. I have no doubt of this either, that the setting in of Krita, Treta, Dvapara, and Kali depends on the king’s conduct. When a season of misery such as you describe does set in, the righteous should keep themselves alive by the help of judgment. On this they tell the old story of what passed between Vishvamitra and a chandala, in a hamlet where chandalas lived.”
“Toward the end of Treta and the beginning of Dvapara, by what the gods had ordained, a frightful drought came and lasted twelve years. It was the time for many creatures worn out with age to lay down their lives, and the thousand-eyed god of heaven poured no rain. The planet Brihaspati began to move backward in its course, and Soma left his own orbit and drew away to the south. No dewdrop could be seen anywhere, much less a gathering of clouds. The rivers all shrank to narrow streams. Lakes and wells and springs dried up everywhere and lost their beauty. With water grown scarce, the sheds that charity had set up to give it out stood deserted. The Brahmins left off their sacrifices and their recitation of the Vedas. They no longer uttered the vashat or performed their rites of propitiation. Farming and the keeping of cattle were given up. Markets and shops were abandoned. The stakes for tethering sacrificial animals disappeared, and people gathered nothing for sacrifices any longer. Every festival and amusement died out. Heaps of bones lay everywhere, and every place rang with the shrill cries of fierce creatures. The cities and towns of the earth emptied of people, and villages and hamlets were burned down. Men fled, some harried by robbers, some by weapons, some by bad kings, all in fear of one another. Temples and places of worship stood desolate. The old were turned out of their houses by force. Cattle and goats and sheep and buffaloes fought over food and died in great numbers. Brahmins began to die on every side, and protection was at an end. Herbs and plants dried up, and the earth lost all her beauty and grew as dreadful as the trees of a cremation ground. In that time of terror, Yudhishthira, when righteousness was nowhere, men lost their senses from hunger and began to eat one another. The rishis themselves gave up their vows, abandoned their fires and their gods, left their retreats in the woods, and wandered here and there.”
“Among them wandered the great rishi Vishvamitra, a holy man of great intelligence, homeless and wasted with hunger. He had left his wife and his son in some place of shelter. He had given up his sacred fire, he had no roof, and he no longer cared whether food was clean or unclean. One day, deep in a forest, he came on a hamlet of cruel hunters who lived by killing. Broken jars and clay pots lay all over the little place. Dog skins were spread here and there. Bones and skulls of boars and asses were heaped in several spots. Cloths stripped from the dead lay about, and the huts were decorated with garlands of flowers already used in worship. Many of the dwellings were full of the cast skins of snakes. The place rang with the crowing of cocks and hens and the harsh braying of asses, and here and there the people quarreled with each other in shrill voices. There were temples of gods that bore the emblems of owls and other birds. Iron bells tinkled, and packs of dogs stood or lay on every side.”
“Driven by the pain of his hunger, Vishvamitra went into that hamlet and did his best to find something to eat. The son of Kushika begged again and again, and he got no meat, no rice, no fruit, no root, no food of any kind. ‘Alas, great is the distress that has overtaken me!’ he cried, and he fell down from weakness there in the hamlet of the chandalas. Lying there the sage asked himself what was best for him to do, and his one thought was of how to keep off immediate death. Then he saw it. On the floor of a chandala’s hut a large piece of flesh was spread out, the haunch of a dog that had lately been killed with a weapon. He considered it, and he came to the conclusion that he would steal that meat.”
“He argued it out with himself. ‘I have no means of keeping alive now. In a season of distress theft is allowed even to an eminent man, and it takes nothing from his glory. Even a Brahmin may do it to save his life. That is certain. One should steal first from a low person. Failing that, one may steal from an equal, and failing an equal, even from an eminent and righteous man. My life itself is ebbing away, and I will steal this meat. I see no fault in such a theft. I will take this haunch of dog’s meat.’ With that resolved, the great sage lay down to sleep in the place where the chandala was. After a while, when the night was far gone and the whole hamlet had fallen asleep, he got up quietly and went into the hut. The chandala who owned it lay like one asleep, his eyes crusted with phlegm. He was an ugly man, and he spoke in a harsh, cracked voice. ‘Who is there, undoing the latch? The whole chandala hamlet is asleep. I am awake, though. I am not asleep. Whoever you are, you are about to be killed.’”
“Those were the words that met the sage. Fear went through him. His face burned with shame and his heart shook at the theft he had attempted. ‘Long life to you,’ he said. ‘I am Vishvamitra. I have come here crushed by hunger. If your sight is clear and your mind is righteous, do not kill me.’ The chandala rose from his bed in terror and came to him. He joined his palms in reverence, and with his eyes full of tears he asked, ‘What are you looking for here in the night, Brahmin?’ Vishvamitra spoke to him gently. ‘I am very hungry and about to die of starvation. I want to take away that haunch of dog’s meat. Hunger has made a sinner of me. A man desperate for food has no shame. My breath is failing. Hunger has destroyed my Vedic learning. I am weak, I have lost my senses, and I have no scruple left about clean food and unclean. I know it is a sin, and still I wish to take that haunch away. I went from house to house in this hamlet of yours and got no alms, and only then did I set my heart on this sinful act. Fire is the mouth of the gods. He is their priest as well. So he ought to take nothing except what is pure and clean. And yet there are times when that great god becomes a devourer of everything. Know that I have become like him.’”
“The chandala answered him. ‘Listen to me. Hear the truth I tell you, and then act so that your merit does not perish. Hear what I have to say about your duty. The wise say a dog is more unclean than a jackal. The haunch of a dog is a far worse part than the other parts of its body. This was not wisely resolved by you. It goes against righteousness, it is the theft of what belongs to a chandala, and it is the theft of unclean food besides. Bless you, look for some other way of keeping yourself alive. Do not let your penances be destroyed by this strong desire for dog’s meat. You know the duties laid down in the scriptures, and you should not do a thing that ends in a confusion of duties. Do not cast righteousness away, you who stand first among all who keep it.’”
“Vishvamitra, with hunger tearing at him, spoke again. ‘A long time has gone by and I have eaten nothing, and I see no other means of keeping alive. A dying man should save his life by whatever means he has, without judging the means. Afterward, when he is able, he should seek merit. Kshatriyas should follow the way of Indra, and it is the duty of Brahmins to behave like Agni. The Vedas are fire, and they are my strength. So I will eat even this unclean food to quiet my hunger. Whatever preserves life should be done without scruple. Life is better than death. A living man can gain virtue. I want to save my life, and with my understanding fully awake I mean to eat this unclean food. Give me your permission. If I go on living I will seek virtue. By penance and by knowledge I will destroy the evils that follow from what I do now, as the lights of the sky destroy even the thickest darkness.’”
“So the two of them argued it in the night, the starving sage and the man whose meat it was. ‘One such as you cannot get long life from eating this food,’ the chandala said, ‘or strength, or the satisfaction that nectar gives. Look for some other alms. Do not let your heart lean toward dog’s meat. To the twice-born orders the dog is certainly unclean food.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘No other meat is easily had in a famine like this. I have no wealth, chandala. I am starving and I cannot move any farther. I am past hope. I think all six kinds of taste are in that piece of dog’s meat.’ The chandala said, ‘The scriptures lay it down that only the five kinds of five-clawed animals are clean food for Brahmins and Kshatriyas and Vaishyas. Do not set your heart on what is unclean.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘The great rishi Agastya, when he was hungry, ate up the Asura named Vatapi. I have fallen into distress and I am hungry, and I will eat that haunch.’ The chandala said, ‘Seek some other alms. You should not do such a thing. Truly it should never be done by you. All the same, if it pleases you, you may take this piece of dog’s meat.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘Those who are called good are the authorities in matters of duty, and I am following their example. I now hold this dog’s haunch to be better food than anything that is highly pure.’ The chandala said, ‘What an unrighteous person does can never be counted an eternal practice, and an improper act can never be a proper one. Do not commit a sin through deception.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘A man who is a rishi cannot do what is sinful. A deer and a dog, as I see it here, are the same. So I will eat this haunch.’ The chandala said, ‘The Brahmins asked that rishi to do what he did. In those circumstances it could not be a sin. That is righteousness in which there is no sin. And Brahmins, who are the teachers of the three other orders, are to be protected and preserved by every means.’”
“Vishvamitra said, ‘I am a Brahmin. This body of mine is my friend. It is very dear to me and deserves my highest reverence. It is from the wish to sustain it that I want to carry off that haunch. I am so eager for it that I no longer have any fear of you and your fierce brothers.’ The chandala said, ‘Men lay down their lives and still do not set their hearts on unclean food. By conquering hunger they win the fruit of all their wishes even in this world. Conquer your hunger and win those rewards.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘I keep hard vows and my heart is set on peace. To preserve the root of all merit I will eat food that is unclean. In a man of cleansed soul such an act is plainly righteous, though to one whose soul is uncleansed the eating of dog’s flesh would look like sin. And if my conclusion is wrong, I still will not become one like you for having eaten it.’ The chandala said, ‘It is my settled conclusion that I must try my hardest to hold you back from this sin. A Brahmin who does a wicked act falls from his high state. That is why I am reproving you.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘Cattle go on drinking and take no notice of the croaking of the frogs. You have no claim to say what righteousness is. Do not praise yourself.’ The chandala said, ‘I have become your friend, and it is for that reason alone that I preach to you. Do what is good for you. Do not do a sinful thing out of temptation.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘If you are a friend who wants my happiness, then raise me out of this distress. Then I could give up the dog’s haunch and count myself saved by righteousness.’ The chandala said, ‘I dare not make you a present of this meat, and I cannot quietly let you rob me of my own food. If I give it and you, a Brahmin, take it, both of us will sink into places of misery in the next world.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘By this sinful act today I will certainly save my life, which is very sacred. Having saved it, I will practice virtue afterward and cleanse my soul. Tell me which of the two is to be preferred.’ The chandala said, ‘In carrying out the duties of his own order and race, a man’s own self is the best judge. You know yourself which of those two acts is sinful. Whoever would count dog’s meat clean food, I think, would hold back from nothing in the matter of food.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘There is sin in accepting an unclean gift and in eating unclean food. When a man’s life is in danger, there is none. The eating of unclean food, where no killing and no deception go with it and where the act will draw only a mild rebuke, is a matter of small consequence.’ The chandala said, ‘If that is your reason for eating unclean food, it is clear that you have no regard for the Veda and for Arya morality. Taught by what you are about to do, I see that there is no sin in ignoring the difference between clean food and unclean.’ Vishvamitra said, ‘Nobody is seen to incur a grave sin by eating. That a man falls by drinking wine is only a precept of words. The other forbidden acts of that kind, whatever they are, indeed every sin, cannot destroy a man’s merit.’ The chandala said, ‘Suppose a learned man carries dog’s meat away from an unworthy place, from an unclean man like me, from one who leads so wicked a life. Then he does a thing opposed to the conduct of those who are called good. And for his part in such a deed he is certain to suffer the pangs of repentance.’ Having said that to the son of Kushika, the chandala fell silent.”
“Then Vishvamitra took the haunch of dog’s meat,” Bhishma went on. “Having got possession of it to save his life, the great ascetic carried it off into the woods, meaning to eat it with his wife. He resolved that he would first satisfy the gods with the proper rites and only then eat the haunch at his ease. He lit a fire by the Brahma rites, and following the rites that go by the name Aindragneya he began to cook the meat himself into the sacrificial charu. Then he began the ceremonies in honor of the gods and the ancestors. Vishvamitra divided the charu into as many portions as were needed, as the scriptures enjoin. He called on the gods, with Indra at their head, to come and take their shares.”
“And while he did so the chief of the gods began to pour down rain. Reviving all creatures with those showers, he made the plants and herbs grow once more. Vishvamitra finished the rites to the gods and the ancestors, satisfied them duly, and then ate the meat himself. Afterward he burned away all his sins by his penances, and after a long time the sage came to a most wonderful ascetic success. Suppose the end in view is the saving of life itself. Then, in this way, a learned man who knows the means should pull his sinking self out of distress by everything in his power. Relying on such understanding he should always keep himself alive, for a man who lives can win merit and enjoy happiness and prosperity. So, Yudhishthira, a learned man of cleansed soul should live and act in this world trusting to his own intelligence to tell righteousness from its opposite.”
Yudhishthira recoils, and Bhishma answers him
The tale of the sage and the dog’s meat left Yudhishthira shaken. “So dreadful a thing has been held up as duty, and for a great man,” he said. “What is left, then, of a robber’s work that I am bound to shun? I am dazed, grandfather, and my heart has sunk. You have loosened my hold on dharma. I reason with my mind again and again, and I cannot find in it any will to act this way.”
“Child, what I have taught you did not come from hearing the scriptures alone,” Bhishma said. “Bees bring the juice of many flowers from many places and store it as honey. The wise have gathered these many kinds of understanding in the same way. A king should learn understanding of every kind, from men on every side. He cannot make his way with a dharma that has only one branch. When this understanding wakes in a king at the hour of danger, he finds a way to save himself. Dharma and the conduct of the good are born of understanding, son of Kuru, and are always known by it. Mark what I say. Kings of the highest understanding rule with their eyes on victory. A weak-minded king who learned only a one-sided dharma in his years of study has no full wisdom to draw on when he needs it.”
“The same act is dharma at one hour and its opposite at another. A man who does not know this double nature comes to the fork in the road and stands there in doubt. Understand the fork before you reach it, Bharata. Then, when the hour comes, a wise king acts on what he knows with his judgment to help him, and ordinary people take his acts for something else. Some men have true knowledge and some have false. A king sorts the one from the other and takes his knowledge from the good who truly know.”
“Those who hate dharma rob the scriptures of their authority and call them unsound. Men with no grasp of profit cry up the contradictions in the science of profit. Some seek learning only to make a living by it, king, and to get fame and whatever they crave in every quarter. They are sinners all and enemies of dharma. Dull men of unripe mind never know a thing as it is. Unskilled in the scriptures, they lean everywhere on reasoning that does not hold. With their eyes fixed on faults in the scriptures they strip the scriptures of honor. Words are their weapons, and their speech strikes like arrows. They run down the knowledge of other men to cry up their own. Know them, Bharata, for traders in learning and for rakshasas among men. With their pretexts they would have you throw away the dharma that the good have laid down and lived by.”
“We have heard that neither the word alone nor reasoning alone settles what dharma is. It is settled when the two are joined. That is the teaching of Brihaspati, and Indra himself declared it. The wise say nothing without a reason, and many other men, though they have learned the scriptures well, make no effort to act by them. Some thinkers say that dharma is simply the custom the good keep up in the world. A learned man should still reason out for himself the dharma the scriptures lay down for the good. When a clever man who has not rightly understood the scriptures expounds them in heat and confusion, his words leave no mark on those who hear him. What is said from an understanding that the scriptures support, with reasoning to carry it, wins honor for the scriptures.”
“Others hold that bare reasoning is the best guide to what is unknown. They say, ‘This argument cuts down that text, so the text is worthless.’ That too is ignorance. Long ago Ushanas, the teacher of the Daityas, said as much to them, and it ends the doubt. Knowledge tangled with doubt is no better than none. Tear that doubt up by the root and throw it away.”
“If you will not accept this counsel of mine, you do wrong, for you were made for fierce work and you are not looking at that. Look at me, child. Kings of the warrior order wanted to rule the earth, and I dealt with them so that they were set free. I sent them to heaven in battle. There were those who took no joy in me for it. Brahma made the goat, the horse and the Kshatriya alike. Through each of them, again and again, the life of all creatures is carried forward. The guilt of killing one who should not be killed is the same guilt as sparing one who should. That guilt is the boundary a Kshatriya king must never cross.”
“So only a king of sharp temper can hold his people each to their own duty. Without him they would roam like wolves and eat one another. Think of a king in whose country bands of robbers carry off other men’s goods as herons lift fish from the water. He is the disgrace of the Kshatriya order. Make men of good family and Vedic learning your ministers, king, and rule the earth, guarding your people by dharma. A king who takes for his minister a man without good works, without justice and without knowledge of ways and means is a eunuch among Kshatriyas.”
“The dharma of kings praises neither fierceness alone nor mildness alone, Yudhishthira. Give up neither. Be fierce first, and be mild when the time for it comes. This duty of the Kshatriya is hard and painful, child. I say it because I love you. The Ordainer made you for fierce work, so stand in your own dharma and rule your kingdom. Indra, the wise one, has said that in a time of distress too the wicked must always be put down and the good protected.”
Yudhishthira asked one thing more. “Best of the good, is there any bound that no one may cross, whatever the season? Tell me that, grandfather.”
“Serve the Brahmins who are great in learning and penance, who know the scriptures and are rich in good conduct,” Bhishma said. “That is the highest and holiest work. Let your bearing toward the Brahmins be always what it is toward the gods, for Brahmins in their anger have done many astonishing things. If they are pleased with you, the highest fame will be yours. If they are not, you have the greatest of fears before you. Pleased, Brahmins are like nectar and give life. Angered, they are as deadly as poison.”
The fowler in the storm
Then Yudhishthira asked about another duty. “Grandfather, you are wise and you know every scripture. Tell me what a creature gains who protects one that has come to him for refuge.”
“Great is the merit in protecting one who comes for refuge, king, and you are fit to ask about it,” Bhishma said. “Shibi and other great-souled kings of old won the highest success by protecting those who sought their shelter. It is told, too, that a dove received an enemy who had come to him for refuge. He honored him with the proper rites and invited him to eat his own flesh.”
“How did a dove in the old days feed an enemy with his own flesh?” Yudhishthira asked. “And what end did he come to by it?”
“Listen, king, to a sacred story that wipes away every sin,” Bhishma said. “Parashurama, of Bhrigu’s line, told it to King Muchukunda. Muchukunda had come to him humbly with this same question, and the sage told him how a dove once won the highest success. ‘Strong-armed king,’ he said, ‘this story settles a point of dharma, and it touches profit and pleasure as well. Give me your whole mind and hear it.’”
“Once a fowler roamed a great forest, a cruel man of evil ways who went about the earth like Death himself. His body was black as a raven’s and his eyes were red. He had long shanks and small feet, a great mouth and a long jaw. He had no friend, no relative and no kinsman. They had all cast him off for the savage work he did. A man of sinful ways should be shunned from far off by the wise, for one who cheats his own self will do no good to another. Cruel, evil-hearted men who take the lives of other creatures are a terror to every living thing, as snakes are.”
“Every day he took his nets into the forest, killed birds and sold them. That was his whole work. He lived by it for a long time, and in all that time the wrong of it never came home to him. He went about so with his wife year after year, and fate had so dulled him that no other living pleased him.”
“One day, while he was wandering in the forest, a great wind rose on every side, so strong that it seemed about to tear the trees out of the ground. Clouds massed over the sky and lightning played all through them. In a moment the sky was covered as the sea is covered by a crowd of boats. Indra came into the clouds with his streams of rain, and within a moment the earth was under water.”
“The rain came down in torrents. The fowler, numb with cold and almost out of his senses with fear, stumbled on through the forest. The path he had been following was drowned, and he could no longer tell high ground from low. Many birds had been killed by the force of the rain and lay on the earth, and others hid in their nests. Deer, lions and boars had found raised ground and lay down on it. The creatures of the forest, terrified by the wind and the rain and hungry besides, wandered together in herds.”
“The fowler’s limbs were stiff with cold. He could neither walk nor stand still. In that state he saw a she-dove lying on the ground, helpless with the cold. He was in the same misery himself, and still the sinful man picked her up and shut her in his cage. In pain himself, he gave pain to another creature. Sin had been his habit so long that he sinned even then.”
“Then, among the trees, he saw one great tree, dark as a rain cloud. Flocks of birds lived in it for its shade, its shelter and its fruit. It stood there like a good man in the world, as if the Creator had made it only to do good to others. In a little while the sky cleared and filled with stars. It shone like a wide lake of clear water covered with white lilies in bloom.”
“Still shaking with cold, the fowler looked at the cloudless sky and then all around him. He saw that the night was thick and dark. ‘My house is a long way from here,’ he thought, and he made up his mind to spend the night under that tree. He joined his palms and bowed to it. ‘Whatever gods live in this tree,’ he said, ‘I come to them all for refuge.’ Then he spread leaves on the ground and lay down with his head on a stone. Wretched as he was, he fell asleep.”
The dove’s lament, and what his wife asked of him
“On a branch of that tree a dove with speckled feathers had lived for a long time with his kin,” Bhishma said. “His wife had gone out in the morning to look for food, and she had not come back. When he saw that night had fallen, the bird grieved aloud.”
“‘The wind was terrible today and so was the rain, and my dear one has not come home. What can have kept her so long? Is all well with her out there in the forest? Without her this home of mine is empty. A householder’s house may be full of sons and grandsons, daughters-in-law and servants, and without his wife it is still empty. A house is not a home. The wife is the home. A house without her is the same as a wilderness.’”
“‘The corners of her eyes are red, her feathers are many-colored, her voice is sweet. If she does not come back today, I have no use for my life. She keeps her vows and is true to me. She does not eat until I have eaten, or bathe until I have bathed. She does not sit until I am seated, and she lies down only when I have lain down. When I am glad she is glad, and when I am troubled she is troubled. When I go away her face falls, and when I am angry she speaks sweetly.’”
“‘Her husband is her only refuge, and she is always busy with what pleases him and does him good. A man who has such a wife is blessed on this earth. That poor creature knows that I am tired and hungry. She loves me, her mind is steady, and she is devoted to me, my wife of good name. Even the foot of a tree is a home to a man whose wife is with him there. A palace without her is a wild and trackless forest.’”
“‘In dharma, in profit and in pleasure a man’s wife is his partner. When he goes to a strange country she is the friend he can trust. A wife is called a man’s greatest wealth. A man with no one else in this world has his wife beside him on the journey of life. For a man worn down by sickness or caught long in trouble, there is no medicine like a wife. No kinsman is equal to a wife, and no refuge. In the gathering of merit the world holds no helper like her. A man who has no good and sweet-spoken wife in his house should go to the forest. To him the house and the forest are the same.’”
“The she-dove in the fowler’s cage heard her husband’s pitiful words. ‘How fortunate I am,’ she said to herself, ‘that my dear lord speaks of me so, whether I have these virtues or have none of them. A woman whose husband is not content with her does not deserve the name of wife. When a husband is pleased, all the gods are pleased with his wife. Fire was the witness when we were joined, and the husband is the wife’s highest god. A wife whose husband is not pleased with her is burned to ash, like a flowering creeper in a forest fire.’”
“So she thought, and then from the cage, in her distress, she called to her grieving husband. ‘Listen, and I will tell you what is good for you. Hear me and do it. Dear one, be the savior of someone who has come for refuge. This fowler has reached your dwelling and lies here, worn down by cold and hunger. Give him a guest’s welcome. One who kills a Brahmin, one who kills a cow, the mother of the world, and one who lets a suppliant perish all carry the same guilt.’”
“‘By our birth as doves a way of life has been given to us, and one who knows the self, as you do, should always keep to it. We have heard that a householder who follows dharma as far as his strength allows goes after death to worlds that never fail. You have sons now, and you have descendants. So have no tenderness for your own body. Keep your eyes on dharma and profit, and honor this fowler so that his heart is glad. And do not grieve on my account, bird. You can take other wives and go on living.’ So the poor she-dove spoke from the cage, looking at her husband in great sorrow.”
The dove gives himself to the fire
“The dove heard his wife’s words, full of dharma and good sense, and great joy came over him,” Bhishma said. “Tears of gladness stood in his eyes. He looked at the fowler, the man who lived by killing birds, and honored him with care, as the rule for a guest lays down.”
“‘You are welcome here today,’ he said. ‘Tell me what I can do for you. Do not be troubled. You are in your own home. Say quickly what you want and how I may serve you. I ask it out of affection, because you have come to our house for shelter. Even an enemy who comes to the door must be given a fitting welcome. A tree does not draw back its shade from the man who has come to cut it down. Everyone owes careful hospitality to one who seeks shelter, and a householder who keeps the five great sacrifices owes it most of all. A man who lives in a house and in his folly fails to keep those five loses this world and the next, as dharma teaches. So speak to me freely. Whatever you say, I will do it all. Do not let your mind dwell on sorrow.’”
“The fowler answered him. ‘The cold is hurting me. Find me some way to get warm.’ At that the bird heaped dry leaves on the ground, as many as he could, and flew off quickly to fetch fire. He went to a blacksmith’s house, brought fire back, set it to the dry leaves and soon had them blazing. ‘Warm your limbs now,’ he said to his guest. ‘Be easy. You have nothing to fear.’ The fowler said, ‘So be it,’ and warmed himself at the flames.”
“The warmth brought the life back into him, and he turned to the dove again. ‘Hunger is tormenting me now. I would like you to give me something to eat.’ The bird answered, ‘I have no store with which to quiet your hunger. We birds of the forest live on what we pick up each day. Like the sages of the woods, we keep nothing laid by.’ As he said it his face lost its color. He sat thinking what he ought to do, Bharata, and he blamed his own way of living, the dove’s way, that gathers nothing.”
“After a little while his mind cleared. ‘Wait a moment,’ he said to the killer of birds. ‘I will satisfy you.’ He fed the fire with dry leaves until it blazed again, and he spoke with great joy. ‘I have heard from rishis, from gods, from the ancestors and from great-souled men that there is high merit in honoring a guest. Gentle friend, I have resolved to honor my guest in the best way there is. Do me this kindness and accept me. I am telling you the truth.’ Having made that vow, the bird walked three times around the fire, as one walks around a god. Then, as if he were smiling, he went into the flames.”
“The fowler saw the bird enter the fire, and he began to think. ‘What have I done? I am a cruel man, and my own work has made me vile. This will be the darkest and heaviest sin of my life. There is no doubt of it.’ So he grieved aloud at the sight, Yudhishthira, and cursed what he had done.”
The fowler turns from his trade, and all three reach heaven
“The fowler was hungry still. Yet when he saw the dove fall into the fire, pity filled him,” Bhishma said. “‘What a sin I have done,’ he cried, ‘cruel and witless as I am. I have shaped my life so that sin will come of it every day.’ He blamed himself again and again. ‘My mind is foul. No one should trust me. Deceit and cruelty have been my whole life. I gave up every honest trade and took to catching and killing birds. And to such a man the great-souled dove has given his own flesh, burning his body for me. By that gift he has shamed me and shown me dharma.’”
“‘I will leave my wife and my sons, and I will give up my own dear life. The great-souled dove has taught me that duty. From today I will deny this body every comfort and dry it up as a small pond dries in summer. I will bear hunger and thirst and the heat of the sun. I will grow so thin that the veins stand out all over me, and by fast after fast I will work for the world to come. By giving up his body the dove has shown how a guest is to be honored. So I too will live by dharma, for dharma is the highest refuge. The dharma I saw in that righteous bird, the best of all that fly, is the dharma I will follow.’”
“With that resolve the fowler, who had done such fierce work, took up a hard vow and set out on the great journey from which no one returns. He threw away his staff and his iron spike, his nets and his cage. He let the she-dove out, the one he had caught and caged, and he went.”
“When the fowler had gone, the she-dove remembered her husband, and grief broke her. She wept and cried out. ‘My love, I cannot remember that you ever did one thing to hurt me. Any woman is plunged in sorrow when her husband is gone, though she has many sons. A wife without her husband is pitied even by her own kin. You always cherished me. You honored me with words that were sweet and gentle and went to the heart. With you I took my joy in mountain caves and on the banks of rivers, beside waterfalls and on the lovely tops of trees. I flew across the sky with you in happiness. All that delight I had with you, my love, and now nothing of it is left to me.’”
“‘What a father gives is measured, and what a brother gives, and what a son gives. Only a husband gives without measure. What woman would not honor him? A woman has no protector like her husband and no happiness like him. She should leave her wealth and everything she has and take him for her only refuge. My lord, life here is nothing to me without you. What good wife could bear to live when her husband is gone?’ So she mourned for a long time in her misery. Then that faithful wife went into the blazing fire.”
“And there she saw her husband. He wore bright armlets and sat in a heavenly chariot, and great-souled beings of good deeds were praising him. He was dressed in fine garlands and robes and adorned with every ornament. A thousand million heavenly chariots stood around him, each carrying those who had done good on earth. Seated in that chariot, the bird went up to heaven with his wife. There he was honored for what he had done, and there he lived in joy with her.”
“The fowler saw the two of them, king, seated in the heavenly chariot and crossing the sky. The sight of that radiant pair filled him with sorrow for his own state, and he thought about how he might reach the same end. ‘By penance like the dove’s I too will go the highest way,’ he resolved. So the man who had lived by killing birds went on along the road of no return. He made no effort for food and lived on air. Out of longing for heaven he let go of every attachment.”
“Farther on he came to a wide and lovely lake. Its water was cool and clear, lotuses covered it, and waterbirds of many kinds were calling on it. The mere sight of that lake would have eased any man’s thirst, however great. The fowler was wasted with fasting, king, and he did not turn his eyes toward it. With a glad heart he went on into a forest full of beasts of prey, his mind fixed on the great goal. Thorn bushes caught him as soon as he was inside. The thorns tore him all over, and with his body running blood he wandered on through that lonely forest crowded with wild animals.”
“Then a strong wind set the great trees grinding against each other, and a fire sprang up. It grew and spread through the forest, raging like the fire at the end of an age. With flames fanned by the wind and sparks flying in every direction, it burned that forest of tall trees, thick with bushes and creepers and full of birds and beasts. The fowler wanted to be rid of his body. With joy in his heart he ran toward the spreading fire.”
“The fire burned him, and every sin he had was burned away with his body. He reached the highest success, best of the Bharatas. In a little while, the fever of his heart gone, he saw himself in heaven. He shone there like Indra among yakshas, gandharvas and perfected beings. So the righteous dove, his faithful wife and the fowler all went to heaven together by the merit of what they had done. A woman who follows her husband as she did soon reaches heaven and shines there like that she-dove.”
“This is the old story, and it happened so. By their good work the fowler and the great-souled dove reached the end that the righteous reach. Whoever hears this story every day, and whoever tells it, comes to no harm, even from a careless slip of the mind. Yudhishthira, best of those who keep dharma, to protect one who comes for refuge is a great duty. Even a man who has killed a cow can be cleansed by keeping it. For one who kills a suppliant there is no cleansing at all. A man who hears this holy story, which destroys sin, is freed from distress and goes to heaven.”
Indrota turns Janamejaya away
Yudhishthira asked, “Best of the Bharatas, suppose a man commits a sin without meaning to. How can he be free of it? Tell me all of this.”
“On this I will tell you an old account that the rishis have praised,” Bhishma said. “It is what the Brahmin Indrota, of Shunaka’s line, said to Janamejaya. In former times there was a king of great power named Janamejaya, the son of Parikshit. Without knowing what he did, that lord of the earth incurred the guilt of killing a Brahmin. When it was known, all the Brahmins abandoned him, and his family priest with them. His own people put him off the throne. He went to the forest, and there, burning day and night with remorse, he gave himself to works of great merit and to the hardest penance.”
“To be rid of that guilt he went from country to country over the whole earth and asked many Brahmins what he should do. I will tell you how he was cleansed, king, and the telling adds to dharma. Burning at the memory of his deed, Janamejaya wandered until he came one day to Indrota of Shunaka’s line, a sage of strict vows. He went up to him, took hold of both his feet and pressed them gently.”
“The rishi saw the king before him and rebuked him harshly. ‘You are a great sinner and the killer of a Brahmin. Why have you come here? What do you want with us? Do not touch me, whatever you do. Go. Go away. We take no pleasure in having you stand here. The smell of blood comes from you, and to look at you is to look at a corpse. You seem fair and you are foul. You are a dead man, and you walk about like one alive. Dead within and unclean of soul, you think of nothing except sin. You sleep and you wake, and you think yourself happy, and your life is misery.’”
“‘Your life is useless, king, and full of pain. You were born for sin. You were made for the lowest work. Fathers and mothers long for sons. By penance, by worship of the gods, by bowing down and by patience they seek them, and from the sons they win they hope for every blessing. Look at what you have done to that hope. The whole line of your fathers has fallen into hell because of you. Every expectation they fastened on you has come to nothing.’”
“‘Men who honor the Brahmins gain heaven, long life, fame and children. You have always hated those same Brahmins, and so your life is wasted. When you leave this world you will fall head downward for your sin and hang so for years past counting. Vultures and peacocks with beaks of iron will tear at you there. When you come back from that hell, you will be born in some vile womb. You think, king, that since this world shows you no fruit of sin, the next world cannot exist. In Yama’s house his messengers will remind you that it does.’”
Janamejaya’s plea, and his oath
“Janamejaya answered the sage,” Bhishma said. “‘I deserve contempt, and so you treat me with contempt. I deserve blame, and so you blame me again and again. I am fit to be reviled and driven off, and that is what I have from you. Even so, I beg you to be gracious to me. All this sin is in me, and I burn with it as if I stood in the middle of a fire. When I remember what I did, my mind has no light in it. A terrible fear of Yama lies ahead of me, and it is lodged in my heart like a dart. How can I go on living until I have drawn it out? Put aside your anger, Shaunaka, and teach me.’”
“‘I was once a great servant of the Brahmins, and I say it to you again now. Let some part of this line of mine remain. Let the whole house not go down into the dust. If the Brahmins lay their curse on us, nothing of our line will be left. Because of our sin we win no praise among men, and our own kind will not stand with us. So in my despair I say again to Brahmins like you, who know the settled meaning of the Vedas. Yogis who live in lonely places protect even sinful men. Protect me in the same way, wretched as I am, out of your mercy. Kshatriyas who lose the right to sacrifice through their own sin never reach a good end in the next world. They lie in hell like the wild Pulindas and Shabaras. You are learned and I am a fool. Do not weigh my childish mind. Be pleased with me, Shaunaka, as a father is pleased with his son.’”
“Shaunaka said, ‘Is it any wonder that a man without wisdom does many things he should not? A wise man who understands this is not angry with any creature. He climbs to the high terrace of wisdom, and from there, free of grief himself, he grieves for others who suffer. He sees them all as a man standing on a mountain peak sees the people on the ground below. One who turns from the good men of old, who keeps out of their sight and earns their rebuke, gains no knowledge. No one is surprised at what becomes of him.’”
“‘You know the power of the Brahmins, and their greatness as the Vedas and the scriptures tell it. Act now in such a way that peace comes to you, and let the Brahmins be your refuge. Whatever is done in the service of Brahmins who have laid down their anger brings good in the next world. And if you truly repent of your sin, keep your eyes always on dharma.’”
“Janamejaya said, ‘I do repent of my sin, Shaunaka, bitterly. I will never again let dharma be lost. I long for what is good. Be pleased with me.’”
“Shaunaka said, ‘I mean to break your pride and your conceit, king, and then to do what is good for you. Work for the welfare of all creatures and keep dharma always in mind. Neither fear nor meanness nor greed makes me call you to my side. Listen now, with these Brahmins, to what I say, for it is true as a voice from heaven. I want nothing from you. All creatures may abuse me, and cry out, and say shame on me. I will disregard them and teach you dharma. They will call me unrighteous. My friends and well-wishers will leave me for it. Yet when those same friends and kinsmen hear what I teach, they will cross over great difficulties. Some men of deep wisdom will understand it truly.’”
“‘Know, child of Bharata, that all I am doing is done for the good of the Brahmins. See to it that through me they come to no harm. And give me your word, king, that you will never again do violence to a Brahmin.’ Janamejaya said, ‘I touch both your feet, best of Brahmins, and I swear it. Never again, in thought or word or act, will I do violence to the Brahmins.’”
Shaunaka’s teaching, and the horse sacrifice
“Shaunaka said, ‘You have made this vow, and it tells me that your mind has turned away from sin. So I will teach you dharma,’” Bhishma went on. “‘You have fortune, great strength and a contented heart, and of your own will you look toward dharma. A king who was harsh at first and who then turns kind, and does good to all creatures by his conduct, is a very great wonder. People hold that a king who has been cruel burns up the whole world. You were such a king, and you now fix your eyes on dharma. That is no small marvel. For a long time you have given up rich food and every comfort, Janamejaya, and kept to penance. To men sunk in sin this will seem astonishing.’”
“‘No one wonders when a wealthy man is generous, or when a poor man is rich in penance. Those things lie close to each other. A work begun without thinking through what comes before and after is a wretched thing. A work begun after full thought has that for its virtue. Sacrifice, giving, compassion, the Vedas and truth, lord of the earth, these five cleanse a man. Penance well performed is the sixth. For kings, Janamejaya, these six are the great cleansers. Take them up in the right way and you will come to the highest good.’”
“‘To visit the holy fords is also a great cleansing. On this the wise repeat a verse that King Yayati sang. A mortal who wants long life should perform sacrifices with care and then leave them, and give himself to penance. The field of Kuru is called holy. The river Sarasvati is holier than the field of Kuru. The fords of the Sarasvati are holier than the river, and Prithudaka is the holiest of all those fords. A man who has bathed there and drunk its water does not grieve, though death should come for him tomorrow.’”
“‘Go to the great lake of Pushkara, to Prabhasa, to northern Manasa and to Kalodaka. Go to the meeting of the Drishadvati and the Sarasvati, and to Lake Manasa. Bathe in them, and you will win life again, and long life. A man should bathe at every holy place with the Veda on his lips. Manu has said that renunciation, the giving up of all things, is the highest of all the pure duties.’”
“‘On this they also repeat verses that Satyavan made. A child is free of love and hate, and so he is always true. He does neither good nor evil. The best of men should be like him. Where there is no real sorrow for any creature in this world, how can there be joy? Sorrow and joy both belong to creatures held in nature, who take on every tie and go where the ties lead. Those who have given up all things, with the sense of I and mine, and are done with both merit and sin, live the blessed life.’”
“‘Now I will tell you what is best among the works of a king. Win heaven by strength joined to steadiness, and by giving. A man who has strength and vigor is able to follow dharma. Rule the whole earth, king, for the happiness of the Brahmins. You once spoke against them. Now make them glad by your good conduct. They may cry shame on you and drive you off again and again. See your own self in them all the same, and hold to your resolve never to strike a Brahmin. Do your own work with all your might and reach for the highest good.’”
“‘One king is cool as snow. Another burns like fire, and another is dreadful as Yama. One is like a plough that tears out weeds by the root, and one falls on evildoers as suddenly as a thunderbolt. A king who does not wish to come to nothing should never keep company with the wicked. He should not be drawn by some one merit in them, or bind himself to them for long, or grow fond of them.’”
“‘If a man does a wrong act once, he is freed from it by repenting. If he does it a second time, he is freed by the vow never to do it again. If a third time, he is freed by the resolve to follow dharma alone from that day. And a man who goes about among the holy fords is freed from sins done many times over. One who wants happiness should do what leads to good. Those who live among sweet scents come to smell sweet, and those who live among foul smells come to smell foul. A man given to penance is quickly freed from all his sins.’”
“‘A man under a charge of sin is cleared by tending the sacred fire for a year. One who has killed a child in the womb is cleared by tending it for three years. Such a man is also freed if he travels on foot a hundred yojanas to the great lake of Pushkara, to Prabhasa or to northern Manasa. One who has killed living creatures is freed from that sin when he saves from death as many of the same kind as he killed.’”
“‘Manu has spoken of the Aghamarshana, the hymn that wipes out sin. A man who plunges into water and repeats it three times gains the fruit of the closing bath of a horse sacrifice. He soon throws off all his sins and is honored everywhere. All creatures are well disposed to him, quiet as the dumb.’”
“‘Once, king, the gods and the asuras together went respectfully to Brihaspati, the teacher of the gods. They said that he knew the fruit of dharma, and the fruit of those acts that lead to hell in the next world. They asked whether a yogi to whom joy and sorrow are the same overcomes both merit and sin. They asked him to tell them the fruit of merit, and how a righteous man destroys his sins.’”
“‘Brihaspati told them this. A man who has sinned through folly and afterward does good works with full understanding removes his sin by them, as lye takes the dirt out of a cloth. A man should not boast after he has sinned. Let him put away his faults in faith and without malice, and seek to do what is good. One who covers the exposed faults of good men is freed from sin, and so is one who has sinned and then turns to good works. As the sun rising at dawn drives off all darkness, a man who does good acts makes an end of all his sins.’”
“When Indrota had said this to King Janamejaya,” Bhishma said, “he had him perform a horse sacrifice in the proper form and served as his priest. All the king’s sin was destroyed by it. He shone like a blazing fire, and every good thing came to him. He went back into his own kingdom, that crusher of enemies, as the full moon enters the sky.”
The vulture, the jackal and the dead child
Yudhishthira asked, “Grandfather, have you ever seen or heard of a mortal who died and came back to life?”
“Listen, son of Kunti, to an old account of what passed between a vulture and a jackal,” Bhishma said. “It happened in the Naimisha forest. A certain Brahmin had a son who had come to him after great hardship, a beautiful boy with large eyes. A spirit that preys on children seized him, and he died while still small. He had not come near to youth, and he was all the wealth his family had. Some of his kin, wild with grief and weeping aloud, took up the dead child and carried him toward the burning ground.”
“When they reached it they stood there and passed him from one breast to another and wept more bitterly still. They kept remembering the things he used to say, and the memory sank them in grief. They could not bring themselves to lay him on the bare ground and go home.”
“Their weeping drew a vulture to the place. ‘Leave this only son of yours here and go home,’ he said. ‘Do not linger. Time has brought men here in thousands and women in thousands, and their kin have left every one of them and gone away. Look, the whole world is filled with joy and sorrow. Meeting and parting come to everyone in turn. Those who carry their dead to the burning ground, and those who do not, all leave this world when their own span is finished.’”
“‘This burning ground is a dreadful place, crowded with vultures and jackals and strewn with bones. It frightens every living creature. You have no business staying here, and no good will come of it. No one overtaken by the law of Time has ever lived again, whether he was loved or hated. That is the way of all creatures. Whoever is born in this world of mortals must die. On the road the Ender has laid out, who can bring a dead man back to life? The day’s work of the world is closing and the sun is going toward the western hill. Give up your love for this child and go home.’”
“At the vulture’s words, king, the kinsmen cried out more loudly. Then they laid the child on the ground. They were certain now that he was dead, and they gave up hope of ever seeing him again. Sure of it, and past hope, they left the child of their house and stood on the path, ready to go.”
“At that moment a jackal, black as a crow’s wing, came out of his hole and spoke to them as they turned away. ‘You men have no pity. Fools, the sun has not even set. Do not be afraid. Stay and show the child your love. Many kinds of hour go by, and in some lucky one this boy may live again. How can you be so hard? You have laid your own son on the bare earth of a burning ground, cast off your love for him, and now you walk away.’”
“‘It seems you have no love at all for this small sweet-voiced boy. Yet this is the child whose prattle filled your hearts with gladness the moment you heard it. Look at the love that even beasts and birds have for their young. Four-footed creatures, birds and insects are bound by love, and they rear their young with no reward to hope for in the next world. The sacrifices of sages who seek heaven bring a return. The love of these creatures brings none, in this world or the other, and still they cherish and guard their little ones. Their young grow up and never feed them in their old age. And yet, when they cannot see their dear ones, their grief has no bounds.’”
“‘Where is there love like that in men, that they should feel such grief? This boy carries on your line. Where will you go if you leave him? Weep for your darling a long while, and look at him a long while with love. A thing so dear is very hard to leave. A man may be wasting away, or standing accused, or on his way to the burning ground. At such times it is his own kin who stay beside him. Every creature holds its own life dear, and every creature knows what love is. Look how even those born as beasts and birds love their young. This boy has eyes as wide as lotus petals. He is as fair as a young bridegroom, bathed and decked with garlands. How can you leave him and go?’ The jackal lamented so pitifully that all the men turned back toward the body.”
A thousand years old, and never one who came back
“The vulture spoke again,” Bhishma said. “‘You men have no firmness in you. Why do you turn back at the word of a cruel, mean and stupid jackal? The five senses have left this body. It lies before you empty and still, stiff as a piece of dry wood. Why grieve for it? Why do you not grieve for yourselves, who will come to the same? Take up hard penance, and it will free you from every sin. Everything can be had by penance. What will wailing do for you?’”
“‘Ill fortune is born together with the body, and its bitter fruit must come. That is why this boy is going from you and leaving you grief without end. Wealth, cattle, gold, gems and jewels, and sons too, all have their root in penance. By penance they are gained. A creature comes to birth carrying the joy and the sorrow that its acts in an earlier life have earned. The father’s acts do not bind the son, and the son’s acts do not bind the father. Tied by their own good and evil deeds, all go down this same road.’”
“‘Follow dharma with care and keep from what is against it. Serve the gods and the Brahmins at the proper times. Give up grief and dejection, and draw your hearts back from this love for a son. Leave the child here on the open ground and go quickly. Whatever a creature does, good or terrible, the doer alone eats the fruit. What have his kin to do with it? Kinsmen do not stay in this place when they have laid down someone they loved. They leave their love behind and go away with tears in their eyes.’”
“‘The wise man and the fool, the rich man and the poor, all pass into the power of Time and take their good and evil acts with them. What will your mourning do? Why weep for one who is dead? Time is the lord of all, and by his very nature he looks on all alike. The young man, the child, the old man and the babe in the womb, death comes to every one of them. That is how this world goes.’”
“The jackal said, ‘See how this slow-witted vulture has weakened your love. You were overcome with love for your son and were grieving for him deeply. His words sound smooth and reasoned and convincing, and because of them you are casting off a love that is hard to cast off and going home. Men come to this empty place of the dead and weep for a lost son like cows that have lost their calves. Today I have learned how great that grief is, for at the sight of your love the tears ran from my own eyes.’”
“‘A creature should always keep striving, and then by fate the thing succeeds. Fate and effort bear fruit together in time. Never give room to despair. Where can happiness come from when the heart has given up? What a man wants is won by effort. So why are you leaving, without pity? This boy was made of your own flesh and blood. He is half your own body, and he carries on the line of your fathers. Where will you go if you leave him in the wild? Do this much. Stay until the sun goes down and the twilight comes. Then take your son home with you, or sit on here beside him.’”
“The vulture said, ‘Men, I was born more than a thousand years ago. In all that time I have never seen a dead creature live again, whether woman, man or neither. Some die in the womb. Some die as soon as they are born. Some die when they have learned to walk, and some in the fullness of youth. The fortunes of beasts and birds are as uncertain as yours. For everything that moves and everything that stands still, the span of life is what rules.’”
“‘Every day men go home from this burning ground, parted from a dear wife or burning with grief for a son. Kinsmen in great sorrow have left here thousands whom they hated and hundreds whom they loved, and gone back. Leave this body. The light has gone out of it. It is empty and has turned to wood. His life has passed into another body. Why do you not go and leave this lifeless form, which is now like a log? Your love is meaningless, and all this effort bears no fruit. He does not see with his eyes or hear with his ears. Leave him and go home quickly.’”
“‘My words seem cruel. They are full of reason all the same, and they belong to the dharma of liberation. Heed them and go to your homes. I have understanding and knowledge, and I can wake them in others. Grief doubles when a man sees his dead and remembers what they used to do.’ The men heard the vulture and turned toward home.”
“The jackal came up at once, quick on his feet, and looked at the child lying in the sleep of death. ‘Look at him, kinsmen. His skin shines like gold, and how fair he is in his ornaments. This is the son who will offer the funeral cake to your fathers. How can you leave him at the bidding of a vulture? If you go, your love will not grow less, and your weeping and crying will not stop. Your pain will only be greater. That is certain.’”
“‘It is told that Rama, whose valor never failed, killed the Shudra Shambuka, and by the power of that act of dharma a dead Brahmin boy came back to life. The royal sage Shveta lost a son in the same way, and Shveta, who lived by dharma, brought the dead boy back. Some perfected sage or some god may come to you too, and take pity on you as you stand here weeping in your misery.’ When the jackal had spoken so, the kinsmen, sick with grief and full of love for the boy, turned back. They laid the child’s head in their laps, one after another, and wept without restraint.”
The sun on the hill, and the coming of Shiva
“The vulture heard their weeping and came close,” Bhishma said. “‘Why are you wetting this child with your tears? Why do you keep pressing him with your hands? By the order of Yama, the king of dharma, he has entered the long sleep. Men rich in penance, men of wealth, men of great mind, all come under the power of death here. This is the city of the dead. Here the kin of men lay down thousands, the young and the old, and spend their days and nights in grief. Stop this. You have carried the load of sorrow long enough.’”
“‘There is no ground for believing that he will live. How could life come back to him here today? When a creature has died and let go of its body, it does not return to that body. A hundred jackals could give up their own bodies, and in a hundred years they would not bring this child back. If Rudra, or Kumara, or Brahma, or Vishnu should grant him a boon, then he might live. Shedding tears will not do it. Heaving long sighs will not do it, and neither will hours of weeping.’”
“‘I, and this jackal, and all of you who are his kin, each with our merit and our sin, are standing on this same road. So a wise man should keep far from unkindness and harsh words, from doing injury to others, from other men’s wives, and from falsehood. Seek dharma, truth, the good of others, justice, compassion for all creatures, straight dealing and honesty, and seek them with care. Those who do not look after their mothers, fathers, kin and friends while they live go against dharma. This one does not see with his eyes and does not stir at all. His life is ended. What will you do for him by weeping?’”
“At the vulture’s words the kinsmen, drowned in sorrow and burning with love for the boy, laid him on the earth and set out for home.”
“Then the jackal said, ‘How terrible this world of mortals is. Every creature in it comes to its end. Life here is short, and we are always losing those we love. It is full of falsehood, of slander and ill report, and few speak a kind word. What I have just seen swells pain and grief, and I cannot bear this world of men for the space of an hour. Shame on you. You burn with grief for your son, and at the word of a vulture you turn back like fools, with your love thrown aside.’”
“‘This vulture is a great sinner with an unclean heart. How can you listen to him and go? Happiness comes after sorrow, and sorrow after happiness. In this world, wrapped in both, neither one lasts without a break. This beautiful boy is the ornament of your house. He has grace and youth, and his body shines. Where will you go, fools, when you have dropped such a son on the ground? In my own mind I see this child alive. I have no doubt of it. He will not perish, and happiness is surely coming to you. Grief for your son has made you like dead men yourselves, and it is not right for you to go back so. Hope for joy from this boy and hold to that hope. Will you leave him of your own accord, like men of small sense, and go?’”
“That jackal lived in the burning ground and went about every night after food,” Bhishma said, “and he was waiting for the dark to do his own work. So with words that went against dharma, false words and sweet as nectar, he held the child’s kinsmen where they were. They could neither go nor stay, and in the end they stayed.”
“The vulture said, ‘This wild place is full of the spirits of the dead. Yakshas and rakshasas live in it, and owls are hooting all through it. It is terrible and dreadful, and as dark as a mass of black cloud. Lay the body down and finish the last rites while the sun is still above the hill and the quarters are still clear. The hawks are giving their harsh cries. The jackals are howling fiercely and the lions are roaring, and the sun is going down toward the western hill. The trees of the burning ground are turning dark with the blue smoke of the pyres.’”
“‘The flesh-eaters of this place are hungry and they are yelling. Every creature that lives in this fearful ground is hideous to see, an eater of flesh with a twisted body, and they will be upon you. This stretch of forest is full of cruel beasts, and great danger is coming to you here. The child is lifeless now, like a piece of wood. Leave him, and do not be caught by the jackal’s talk. If you lose your judgment and go on listening to his false and empty words, you will all be destroyed.’”
“The jackal said, ‘Stay. Stay. While the sun gives its light here you have nothing at all to fear. Until then, love this child and hold him dear. Look at him long with loving eyes, without fear, and weep your fill. This wild place is fearful, and still no harm will come to you in it. This ground is gentle, for the ancestors have their dwelling here. Stay as long as the sun can be seen. What is the talk of this eater of flesh to you? If you lose your heads and listen to the vulture’s harsh and frightening words, you will have seen the last of your child.’”
“The vulture said that the sun had set. The jackal said that it had not,” Bhishma went on. “Both of them were hungry, king, and each spoke to the dead child’s kin to gain his own end. The vulture and the jackal had each girded himself for his own business. Hunger and thirst pressed them both, and both argued from the scriptures. One was a beast and one was a bird, and both knew the language of wisdom. Swayed by words that were like nectar, the kinsmen would stand still for a while and then start to go. In the end grief and helplessness held them, and they stayed there weeping. They did not see that the two, each skilled in his own cause, had them going in circles.”
“While those two creatures, both learned in wisdom, argued on, and the kinsmen stood there, Shiva appeared before them. The goddess Parvati had urged him to come, and his eyes were wet with compassion. He said to those men, ‘I am the giver of boons.’ The grieving men bowed down and stood before him. ‘Lord,’ they said, with tears in their eyes, ‘we have lost our only son and we are as good as dead. We all beg you for life. Give life to this son of ours, and you give it to us.’”
“Asked in this way, the lord gave the child his life, and he gave him a hundred years of it. Shiva, who holds the bow Pinaka, seeks the good of every creature. He gave a boon to the vulture and the jackal as well, and their hunger was ended. The men were filled with joy. Their purpose was won, and they bowed to the great god and went away in gladness.”
“By hope that does not tire, by firm resolve and by the grace of the god of gods, a man soon gains the fruit he longs for. See how fate fell out, and see the resolve of those kinsmen. They stood weeping in misery, and in a little while their tears were wiped away. By holding to their purpose they found the grace of Shiva, and from sorrow they came to happiness. They were astonished and glad to have their son alive again. By Shiva’s grace, best of the Bharatas, they put off their grief for him at once. With joyful hearts those Brahmins took the boy and went back to their town. This understanding has been set out for men of all four orders. A man who listens always to this good account, which holds dharma, profit and liberation, is happy in this world and in the next.”
The Shalmali tree and Narada
Yudhishthira asked, “Grandfather, think of a weak man, a man of no substance and small in every way. His enemy is strong, lives always close by, is able to help or to harm, and is never idle. In his folly the weak man boasts, says what he should never have said, and makes that enemy his foe. The strong one, in great anger, comes against him to tear him up by the roots. How should the weak man act then, with nothing to lean on except his own strength?”
“On this, best of the Bharatas, the wise tell an old account of what passed between the Shalmali tree and the Wind,” Bhishma said. “On the Himalaya there stood a great lord of the forest, a Shalmali, the silk-cotton tree. It had grown through many years until it was mighty, rich in trunk and bough and leaf. Elephants in rut, tormented by the heat and worn with toil, used to rest under it, strong-armed one, and many other beasts did the same. The tree measured four hundred cubits around, and its shade was deep. Parrots and mynas lived in it in flocks, and it was covered with flowers and fruit. Merchants traveling in caravans, ascetics of the forest and other wayfarers stayed beneath that lovely tree, the best of its kind.”
“One day the divine sage Narada saw its great boughs and the vast spread of its trunk, and he went up to it and spoke. ‘How delightful you are, how pleasing to the heart. Best of trees, Shalmali, the sight of you always gladdens me. Lovely tree, birds of many kinds live happily in your branches, and deer and elephants live in your shade. Lord of the forest with your mighty boughs, I see that the Wind has never broken one of your branches, or your great trunk, in any way.’”
“‘Child, is the Wind so fond of you, or is he your friend, that he guards you always in this forest? The Wind is so swift and so strong that he shifts trees great and small from their places, and the peaks of mountains too. That pure carrier of scents, when he blows, can dry up the underworld, the lakes, the rivers and the seas. There can be no doubt that he guards you out of friendship. That is why, with all your many branches, you stand here green with leaves and bright with flowers.’”
“‘It is a lovely thing to see, child, these birds at play so gladly in your boughs. In the season of blossom the sweet voice of each one can be heard apart, and all of them together. These trumpeting elephants, Shalmali, the pride of their herds, come to you in the heat and find comfort. Beasts of many other kinds make you beautiful too. With every creature living on you, tree, you shine like Mount Meru. Brahmins, ascetics made pure by penance and wandering mendicants gather here. This place of yours, I think, is like heaven itself.’”
“‘There can be no doubt, Shalmali, that the terrible Wind, who goes everywhere, guards you always because he holds you his kinsman or his friend. You must have humbled yourself before him and told him that you are his. I see no tree or mountain or house on this earth that the Wind cannot break by his strength. I am sure of it. For some reason he and his following keep you safe, and that alone is why you stand.’”
“The Shalmali said, ‘Brahmin, the Wind is no friend of mine, no kinsman and no well-wisher. He is not the Creator either, that he should protect me. My energy and my strength are more terrible than his, Narada. With all his force the Wind does not come up to one eighteenth part of me. When he arrives breaking trees and mountains and everything else, I stop him by my strength. I have checked the Wind many times, the breaker of so much. So I am not afraid of him, divine sage, even when he is angry.’”
“Narada said, ‘You see this upside down, Shalmali. There is no doubt of that. No creature anywhere has strength to match the Wind’s. Indra, Yama, Kubera and Varuna, the lord of the waters, are none of them his equal. What then are you, who are only a tree? Whatever any creature does on this earth, Shalmali, it is the blessed Wind who gives the power to do it and gives the life. When he moves rightly through a body, every creature stirs and lives at ease. When he moves wrongly, creatures fall into distress.’”
“‘He is the best of the strong and deserves worship, and you give him none. What is that if it is not smallness of mind? You are worthless and wrong-headed. You only talk a great deal. Anger and the like have clouded you, Shalmali, and you speak what is false. Your way of talking has made me angry. I will go myself and tell the Wind every slighting word you have said.’”
“‘The sandalwood, the syandana, the shala and the sarala, the deodar, the cane and the dhanvana are stronger trees than you, foolish one. They and others like them have never spoken against the Wind like this. They are masters of themselves. They know their own strength and the Wind’s, and so those best of trees bow their heads before him. In your folly you do not know that his strength has no end. So I am going from here to his presence.’”
The Wind comes for the tree
“Having said this to the Shalmali, Narada, the best of those who know Brahman, went and told the Wind everything,” Bhishma said. “‘God of the wind,’ he said, ‘on the back of the Himalaya stands a Shalmali with a great following of branches. Its shade is wide and deep and its roots run far. That tree insults you. It said many scornful things about you that it would not be fitting for me to repeat in your hearing. I know you, Wind. You are the first of all that draw breath, great and weighty, and in your anger you are like Yama, the son of the Sun.’”
“The Wind heard Narada and went to the Shalmali in a fury. ‘Shalmali,’ he said, ‘you spoke ill of me to Narada as he passed. I am the Wind, and I am going to show you my strength and my power. I know you well, tree. Nothing about you is hidden from me. When Brahma, the Grandfather of the worlds, was creating living beings, he rested for a time beneath you. Because he rested there I have shown you favor, and that is why you have been kept safe, foolish one. Your own strength never saved you, basest of trees. Now you slight me as if I were some common creature. So I will show myself to you in such a form that you will never slight me again.’”
“The Shalmali answered with something like a laugh. ‘Wind, you are angry with me. Show what you are, then, and hold nothing back. Pour all your anger out on me. What will your rage do to me? You are mighty in yourself, Wind, and I am still not afraid of you. I am far stronger than you, and I have no cause to fear you. Those who are strong in understanding are the truly strong. Those who have only strength of body are not counted strong at all.’ The Wind said, ‘Tomorrow I will show you my might.’ And then night came on.”
“In the night the Shalmali weighed in his mind what the Wind would do, and he saw that he was no match for him. ‘Everything I said to Narada was false,’ he thought. ‘I cannot stand against the Wind, for he is far above me in strength. He is always mighty, as Narada said. I am weaker than other trees, and there is no doubt of that. Yet in understanding no tree is my equal. I will lean on my understanding and free myself from this fear of the Wind. If the other trees in the forest used the same understanding, his anger could do them no harm. They are fools, and they do not know, as I know, how the Wind bears down on them in his rage.’”
“Having settled this in his mind, the Shalmali, shaken as he was, himself brought down his own boughs and branches and twigs,” Bhishma said. “He gave up his branches, his leaves and his flowers, and at dawn he stood watching for the Wind to come. When morning broke the Wind came on in anger, breathing hard and throwing down great trees, to the place where the Shalmali stood. He saw him with his leaves fallen, his fine branches on the ground and his flowers gone, and he was delighted. He smiled and spoke to the tree whose boughs had been so fearsome a little before.”
“‘Shalmali,’ the Wind said, ‘this is exactly what I meant to do to you in my anger. You have taken the suffering on yourself. Your boughs are down, and your flowers and leaves, your branches and shoots are all gone. By your own bad counsel you have brought this ruin on yourself, and you have come under my strength after all.’”
“When the Shalmali heard the Wind’s words he was ashamed. He remembered what Narada had told him, and he was full of regret. In this way, tiger among kings, a weak and foolish man who makes an enemy of a strong one comes to grief as the Shalmali did. So let the weak never quarrel with the strong. One who does will sorrow as that tree sorrowed.”
“Great-minded men do not show enmity all at once to those who have wronged them, great king. They let their strength be seen little by little. A man of poor understanding should never make an enemy of a man who lives by understanding. The thought of the intelligent goes in everywhere, like fire running through dry grass. Nothing a man has is equal to understanding, king, and nothing in this world is equal to strength. So one should bear with the wrongs done by a child, by a dull man, by the blind and the deaf, and by one who is far the stronger. That forbearance is to be seen in you, slayer of enemies.”
“There were eleven great armies on one side and seven on the other, eighteen akshauhinis in all. Together they were not equal in strength to the great-souled Arjuna, king of great splendor. Arjuna, the son of Indra and the glory of Pandu’s house, trusted to his own strength and ranged over that field, and he killed and scattered all those hosts. I have now told you at length, great king, the dharma of kings and the dharma of times of distress. What more do you wish to hear?”
