What is Hinduism
A great river, with countless ghats along its banks, and at every ghat a different way of stepping into the water. First the river itself, where it rises and what carries it along. Then the stretches where the water turned murky, with the reformers who waded in to clear it. Both belong to one telling, and each keeps its own place.
Part one · What it is
Hinduism slips out of any single definition. It has no founder, no birth date, no central institution, no creed, and no one book. A tradition that lacks all five would be expected to scatter. This one has stayed alive for well over two thousand years, held by a thread fine enough to be missed.
Where the name came from
Hindu began as a word of geography, the name outsiders used for the people across the Sindhu. By the colonial period the same word had settled into the name of a religion. The census counted scattered local traditions under that one heading. Brian Pennington follows that settling in Was Hinduism Invented?, published in 2005. Romila Thapar’s phrase syndicated Hinduism names something later. In the essay of that title, printed in Hinduism Reconsidered in 1989 and first sketched in Seminar in 1985, she describes a modern, organized, uniform Hinduism. In her account, it was built on the model of the Semitic religions and pressed forward by modern politics and a rising middle class.
What holds it together
The thread that very nearly holds it together, in Brian K. Smith’s account, is acceptance of the Veda as the authority, even where that acceptance stops at the name. From there a shared vocabulary follows: dharma, the order one is bound to keep. Karma, the weight an act carries forward. Samsara, the round of births. Moksha, release from it. A shared practice follows in puja, in reverence for shruti, the word that was heard, and smriti, the word that was remembered. It follows in reaching the Supreme through many forms and many names. The thread is thin, and it is what gives so much variety one name.
The variety within
The spread within is large. Julius Lipner, in Hindus: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices, offers the banyan as its image. It is one tree with many trunks, each begun as a root sent down from a branch and now standing in the ground like a tree of its own. The major traditions are Vaishnava, Shaiva, and Shakta, centered on Vishnu, Shiva, and the Goddess, and the Smarta, which keeps to Vedic orthopraxy and worships five deities together. Six classical schools of philosophy run from the dualism of Samkhya to the Advaita Vedanta tied to Shankara. And practice stretches from the renunciate’s austerity to the glow of festival.
Part two · The hard parts
Now the parts that call for courtesy and a steady gaze. Each of them is a matter of record, with a date and a source. Beside each stands the reform that rose against it from inside the tradition.
Caste and untouchability
The varna scheme, the four orders of society, first appears in the Purusha Sukta. It is the Rigveda hymn in which they issue from the body of the cosmic man. It hardens through the Dharmashastra, above all in the Manusmriti. The sharpest critique from within is B. R. Ambedkar’s Annihilation of Caste, written in 1936. Untouchability is illegal under India’s Constitution, and it survives in social practice. How much of caste is Hindu doctrine and how much a wider South Asian social order remains a live question. Susan Bayly weighs it in Caste, Society and Politics in India, published in 1999.
The treatment of women
Sati, the burning of a widow on her husband’s pyre, was a reality, contested inside the tradition and at times forced, as Lata Mani shows in Contentious Traditions. The devadasi custom, the dedication of girls to a temple, sank in its degraded forms into exploitation. Child marriage was common, and widows lived under harsh restriction. Against all of this, reformers rose from within: Rammohan Roy, and after him the Brahmo Samaj and the Arya Samaj, who set the Hindu sources themselves before Hindu custom.
Communal and political violence
The ideology of Hindutva, set out by V. D. Savarkar in his tract of 1923, stands apart from Hinduism as a religion while drawing its material from it. The documented events include the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992 and the Gujarat violence of 2002, both studied in the work of Christophe Jaffrelot. Those events and that scholarship are the record. The wider political argument over them stays open.
The recurring stories of gurus
The deep authority handed to a living guru has been abused, and the abuse has surfaced again and again. Asaram Bapu was convicted of rape in 2018. Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh is head of the Dera Sacha Sauda, a syncretic dera that draws on several faiths. He was convicted of rape in 2017 and in 2019 of the murder of the journalist Ram Chander Chhatrapati. Swami Nithyananda, accused of abuse, left the country. Each case turns on the trust a follower places in a living teacher, and on what follows when it is betrayed.
The countercurrents within the tradition
Alongside these run the currents within the tradition that flowed against them. The medieval bhakti movements struck at caste and at ritualism: Kabir, Raidas, and Mirabai sang in the spoken tongues, and their songs are still sung. One challenge came from outside the tradition and drew its answer from within. Centuries earlier the Buddha had rejected the Vedic yajna, the fire-rite, and rank fixed by birth, and the Vedic schools answered him. Mimamsa and Vedanta thinkers, Shankara among them, argued against the Buddhist positions for centuries. The Puranas in time counted the Buddha among the avatars of Vishnu. Every great tradition carries faults of this kind, and the fact excuses none of them.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the one book of Hinduism?
No single book holds it. The Veda stands as the authority, and beside it run the Upanishads, the Gita, the Ramayana, the Mahabharata, the Puranas, and many voices besides. The tradition keeps a library.
Are Hinduism and Sanatana Dharma different?
In everyday speech the two cover the same ground. Hindu came from geography, a name given from outside. Sanatana Dharma, the eternal dharma, is the tradition’s own name for itself, and the phrase esha dharmah sanatanah, this is the eternal dharma, stands in the Manusmriti.
Is caste really a part of Hinduism?
Its roots show in the varna scheme, and it hardened through the Dharmashastra. Susan Bayly and others also read caste as a wider South Asian social order, one that reaches past any single faith. Ambedkar’s critique came from within this very tradition.
Why are these hard parts included here?
Because a tradition is understood whole, its radiance and its wounds together. The caste order, sati, the riots, and the convicted gurus are matters of record. The reformers who rose against them belong to the same record. Set down together, they serve understanding and no one’s cause.
Hold Hinduism as a loose gathering of traditions, where a shared vocabulary and the acceptance of the Veda are the only binding. And when you weigh any tradition, set its claims and its history on the same table. That one habit keeps a debate from sliding into propaganda.