A question waits in every life. It chooses its own hour: what does all this mean. Four travelers carried that question down four different roads, and the roads bend toward one horizon. First the shape of the question, then the four roads, one after another.
Part one · That same question
Every life, one day or another, meets this question: what does all this mean. The Indian tradition gives the question a structure before it gives an answer. The four purusharthas, dharma, artha, kama, and moksha, are the legitimate aims of a life. The worldly aims of wealth and desire are honored so long as they stay within dharma, and moksha, release, is the final aim. The four ashramas, brahmacharya, grihastha, vanaprastha, and sannyasa, lay the aims out across a lifetime, the student, the householder, the forest-dweller, and the renunciant. It is a scheme Patrick Olivelle traces in The Asrama System. Moksha is the main answer here, and it is given in two voices: in Advaita, the atman, the self, and Brahman are one. In bhakti, devotion, the answer is a love-filled union with a personal God. The Gita adds its three paths to the same end: jnana, karma, and bhakti.
Beyond this lies a wider field, and every answer in it has been lived by someone. For some, the answer is meeting that Supreme, or serving it. For some, the ceasing of suffering. For some, right relationship with others and their flourishing. And for some, meaning is made by choosing and answering for oneself, the existentialist answer, the one Viktor Frankl set down in Man’s Search for Meaning after the camps.
Part two · Four who carried it
Now the four teachers: a short story for each, then the build of each answer, with history’s cautions kept close.
Why is there suffering, and can it end?
The four noble truths, and the eightfold path
What does God ask, when his kingdom is near?
Repentance, and love of God and neighbor
What do I do before duty, my own people, and death?
Unattached action, and steadiness in the atman beyond the body
How do I know that one formless One?
Nam-simran, honest householding, the melting of haumai
Buddha
The prince saw four sights outside the palace: old age, sickness, death, and a renunciant walking calmly through all three. The question rose: why is there suffering, and can it end. The answer came in the four noble truths: that ordinary life carries an unease, that its root is craving, that it can cease, and that the eightfold path leads there. Alongside them stand dependent origination and anatman: nothing stands apart on its own, and there is no fixed I to protect. The first sermon, given to five companions in the deer park at Sarnath, is the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, Samyutta Nikaya 56.11.
Jesus
One caution first. Historical reconstruction places him in the Jewish society of the Second Temple period, a Jewish apocalyptic prophet, whose question is what God asks as his kingdom draws near. The answer is repentance, love of God and of neighbor, the two commandments he names in Mark 12:28 to 31. And the answer is the reversals of the Beatitudes in Matthew 5, and trust in a final judgment. The caution: the sources are the Gospels themselves, written decades later by the communities that worshiped him.
Krishna
The caution first: Krishna speaks here as the Gita’s divine voice, and the Gita alone is the ground this portrait stands on. The crisis is Arjuna’s. His chariot has been driven between the two armies. He sees his teachers and kinsmen on the far side, and he lays down his bow in a moral paralysis before his own people, his duty, and death. The answers come in three movements: the atman, which outlasts the body, in chapter 2. Then comes action done with the claim on its fruit released, karma-yoga, in chapters 2 and 3. And then comes love-filled surrender, sealed by the darshan of the cosmic form in chapter 11.
Guru Nanak
The question is how to know that one formless truth, and the obstacle is haumai, the self-centered ego. At the head of the Japji, on the first ang of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, stands the Mool Mantra, and in English it reads: “One. Truth-named. Creator. Without fear. Without enmity. Beyond time. Unborn. Self-existent. Known by grace.” The whole prayer rests on that one line, and its last two words, gur prasad, say how any of it is known. The path is nam-simran, remembrance of the Name, lived inside an honest householder’s life: kirat karo, vand chhako, naam japo, earn honestly, share what you earn, repeat the Name. The janamsakhis, the life-stories told by his followers, give him the saying that there is no Hindu and no Musalman. The caution: those life-stories were written in a spirit of devotion, as W. H. McLeod shows in Guru Nanak and the Sikh Religion.
And at the end
Each one meets some face of the same condition. The condition is that we suffer, that we die, that we must act without a firm address, that we feel cut off from the Supreme. The Buddha reads it as craving, to be let go. Jesus reads it as a relationship, to be mended before the coming judgment. Krishna’s Gita reads it as a call: stand in the atman beyond the body and do the right act. Nanak reads it as an ego, to be melted into that One. Each of the four answers has carried whole lives, and they do not combine into any single doctrine.
Frequently asked questions
What are the four purusharthas?
Dharma, artha, kama, and moksha, the four legitimate aims of life. The worldly aims stay within dharma, and moksha is the final aim.
Do these four teachers give the same answer?
No. All four meet some face of the same condition, but their answers differ, and they do not dissolve into one doctrine.
Why keep history’s cautions in this?
Because Krishna is the Gita’s divine speaker, the sources for Jesus are the later Gospels, and Nanak’s life-stories are devotional. Each answer stands on a different kind of ground, and the ground is part of the answer.
One condition answers to four names, craving, a broken relationship, paralysis, and ego, and each name opens a road of its own. The roads do not need to be merged before they can be walked. Let all four stand apart, with full respect, each in its own place, and the one horizon stays in view from any of them.